5 ms·
Also make sure the people who hire you actually own the system being tested. Like if my neighbour hires some random to pentest my house for kicks, it doesnt ma
by bawolff 7y ago
Also make sure the people who hire you actually own the system being tested.
Like if my neighbour hires some random to pentest my house for kicks, it doesnt make it ok for pentester to break into my house because they signed a contract with my neighbour
- p1necone 7y agoDepends, if the pentesters didn't ask for any proof that your neighbour owned and occupied the house then sure, the neighbour and the pentesters should be prosecuted. But if your neighbour lied and falsified documents to the point reasonable due diligence would have been fooled, perhaps the pentesters can be considered not at fault?
- bigiain 7y ago> But if your neighbour lied and falsified documents to the point reasonable due diligence would have been fooled, perhaps the pentesters can be considered not at fault? And here we end up back with irjustin's proposal that if pentesters are doing things that would be illegal without proper permission, they need to be prepared to spend some time in jail. Their risks there for which they need to be compensated include their own organisation failing in their due diligence and sending them into a test for which they're genuinely not legally authorised.
- SkyBelow 7y ago>And here we end up back with irjustin's proposal that if pentesters are doing things that would be illegal without proper permission, they need to be prepared to spend some time in jail. This sounds very unreasonable once you start applying it to other actions in life. For example, picking up someone's kids so they can go on a play date with your own kids. That's kidnapping without permission. Should everyone who picks up another person's kids need to be prepared to spend time in jail for kidnapping?
- gowld 7y agoThis is an issue in schools today regarding after-school care and custody handoffs, with the liberty/efficiency-oriented people battling the law& order/safety/think-of-the-children people. They both have valid perspectives, as is usually case in matters of statistically danger.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoIn this case, branches of two different governments were colocated in the same building.
- Lazare 7y ago> Also make sure the people who hire you actually own the system being tested. There's an ongoing political dispute in Iowa over the extent to which the court system controls court buildings. The courts maintain they have full control (and thus can legally authorise, eg, pen testing), and (perhaps unsurprisingly) they keep winning court cases about it. Some of the criticism of Coalfire, DeMercurio, and Wynn was about how they were pentesting buildings their client did not control, but it's worth noting that this is 1) disputed and 2) almost certainly wrong (at least from a legal realism point of view). It's worth emphasising, I think, how much this story had to do with jurisdictional fights between different branches and levels of the Iowa state government, and how little it had to do with Coalfire, DeMercurio, Wynn, or pentesting.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kjs3 7y agoThis is a very important bit of insight. Thanks for this perspective. My comments about contractual protections aren't nearly as strong in light of this.
- dillonmckay 7y agoSeriously, stay out if politics are involved as a pentester, or even as an MSP. We had a legal matter with a county commissioner requesting the MSP use an external harddrive to transfer documents for which the commissioner had no right to access. This happened in broad daylight.
- Stratoscope 7y agoForgive me, but what is an MSP?
- _jal 7y agoManaged Service Provider.
- peteretep 7y ago> Also make sure the people who hire you actually own the system being tested. I feel like an alternative take on this is “inform the local police department of your plans”
- muro 7y agoReaction time of the local police department might be part of the test.
- michaelt 7y agoUnless you're hired by the chief of police, that sounds very close to testing a system - the police - without the permission of the owner? And there are safer ways to find the police's reaction time than having them turn up with guns drawn, finding signs of forced entry, and finding you - a non-employee - sneaking around with burglary tools. For example, you could make a FOIA request for their internal records, ask a local journalist - or if you insist on a real-world test, have the alarm 'accidentally' tripped by a legitimate employee arriving for work early.
- matt_the_bass 7y agoYes. I don’t understand why this isn’t part of the game plan. I understand not informing the patrol level of the police dept, but I do t see how informing the admin above does. The deputy chief is not involved in the management of an enforcement patrol/stop.