7 ms·
This works well for women, not so well for men. For men, typically making a visible effort will cause your spouse to perceive you as weak and low value. This w
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
This works well for women, not so well for men.
For men, typically making a visible effort will cause your spouse to perceive you as weak and low value. This will only make things worse.
- jedsmith 16y ago[citation needed]
- _h4xr 16y agoI recommend The Red Queen if you want to start learning about this. The short answer: men largely choose mates based on looks; women choose based more on social status. Signalling low social status reduces male attractiveness; signalling high social status raises it. n = 1, but this has worked for me. Deliberately act like you can take it or leave it, and you're unlikely to be left. (And note that women initiate the majority of breakups and divorces, so you're not risking much if you risk a breakup.)
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- _h4xr 16y agoI know. I often fear a nightmarish reality in which women spend minutes or even hours per day carefully disguising natural facial features, odors, and hair--or even exercising at a gym--just so they can manipulate men into wanting to be with them. I pity the guys who get suckered into preferring women who engage in such behaviors. It's almost as bad as men altering their behavior to be more attractive to women. Empirically, prior girlfriends have been unimpressed with my slavish devotion to their every-moment's well-being. My current girlfriend is much more devoted, and much more enthusiastic. I am fairly overt about this. I told her to read The Red Queen after our first date. And I don't lie about this. But when I'm asking myself what's better for the relationship, and what's going to make the person I'm with happier, I have to take into account that my behavior affects her happiness indirectly, too. You'd have to be a real jerk to make her date a nebbish.
- haploid 16y ago"My personal belief is that if a woman chose you for your social status, you made a mistake getting involved with her." I'd suggest reading the book cited by the grandparent. You're a little naive on the topic. The vast majority of women marry for social or financial status, but it's an unconscious mechanism. In the end, it's all about optimizing genetic fitness and resource availability. Our genes do this automatically, and it's not limited to humans.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- spoondan 16y agoThe vast majority of women marry for social or financial status, but it's an unconscious mechanism. In the end, it's all about optimizing genetic fitness and resource availability. Our genes do this automatically, and it's not limited to humans. Are you saying that the book cites research to backup these extraordinary claims? While I'm little more than a dilettante, I can't see how I could completely avoid hearing that a social behavior as complex as marriage had been pinned to genetics. What I've heard is that surveys have shown women will find a man more attractive if they believe he's wealthy. I have not seen it shown that this is wholly unconscious, let alone genetic (rather than cultural). And I have not seen it claimed that this effect dictates why women marry particular men.
- haploid 16y agoBoth you and yummyfajitas are making the classic error of espousing an unpopular opinion amongst people who tend to irrationally believe magical romantic things about evolved bags of meat. It's a fairly well established biological fact( caveat - there are of course exceptions )that female primates, including humans, respond sexually favorably toward high status behavior on the part of males. The Red Queen is a good book, but there are countless others. Sperm Wars, Sex At Dawn, The Evolution of Desire, and myriad academic papers that these books reference, paint a very clear picture of female sexuality that few will ever want to believe. n=1 is irrelevant in this discussion. As far as I'm concerned, the actual scientific evidence is quite clear on this matter. Edit: removed reference to emo hipsters. Not constructive.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- _h4xr 16y ago"You are aware that the very definition of a fact precludes it from having exceptions, right?" He's talking about statistical distributions. "It's an established fact that six-year-olds are taller than five-year-olds. There are exceptions." I'm not sure where he got the "hipster" stuff, though.
- haploid 16y agoI edited my post. The hipster reference was not constructive. Re: fat nerds and social value: In 2011, "fat nerds" can wield quite a bit of financial power. This can make them attractive to females by virtue of the fact that they can be utilized as resource providers for their future offspring. However, it should be noted that sexual attraction and attraction to resources are generally two independent drives in female primates. Many female primates utilize independent strategies, procuring resources and genetic material from different men simultaneously. See the citations in "Sperm Wars" for references to the research on this phenomenon.
- georgieporgie 16y ago
- hartror 16y agoI love pop psychology books that tell me it is fine to be lazy and uncaring. /sarcasm We aren't talking about dating here, we are talking about long term relationships. The whole Red Queen thing breaks down when we add artificial human constructs such as marriage and monogamy. We are not a Silver Back leading a band of gorillas, we are far more complex than that. Sure, signalling plays a roll in initial conditions, impressions and attractiveness. However once we get past the monkey brain and into the far more complex social behaviors humans have developed there aren't just a couple of sliders to adjust to determine how successful a relationship is. I would love to hear of anyone having a successful and above all healthy long term relationship using the ideas you espouse.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI love pop psychology books that tell me it is fine to be lazy and uncaring You are confusing normative and positive claims.
- joezydeco 16y agoSo let's turn it back to Hacker News for a moment. You're slaving away in a startup, working insane hours and getting paid way less than what you're worth. There's equity in there somewhere. Maybe. You've finished up another 12 hour day and there's the wife glaring at you at the kitchen table: "When is this job going to get us somewhere? Why can't we be doing/having <x> like your friend Bob who works at <consulting firm y>?" The social status thing makes sense. And you're working your ass off to try to make that next step up, or cash out, or whatever. So what do you tell her in return?
- randallsquared 16y agoPlease stop deleting your replies in this thread. It's becoming difficult to follow.
- ghurlman 16y agoYou sound young and/or divorced. No amount of effort will make up for a bad match.
- varjag 16y agoHe actually sounds just young. I'll stop at this.
- hartror 16y agoWhat!? You can be thoughtful and accommodating without being a doormat which is what you appear to be alluding to. Breaking this down to an evolutionary biology standpoint, what advantage would that sort of psychology provide the woman? It has the opposite effect on the intended outcomes, that of security and stability from which to raise offspring. The whole treat em mean, keep them keen mentality might work in the short term and get you laid but a happy productive relationship it will not build. Eventually the woman is going to go elsewhere to obtain the security and stability a healthy relationship provides.
- yummyfajitas 16y ago...what advantage would that sort of psychology provide the woman? It leads her to believe your genetic material is of a higher quality than she could normally gain access to. Eventually the woman is going to go elsewhere to obtain the security and stability a healthy relationship provides. Sometimes. But that's a better outcome than if she stays with you and goes elsewhere for higher quality genetic material, which is far more common than most people believe.
- jules 16y agoAren't we talking about marriage here rather than a relationship between teenagers?
- jscore 16y agoYou are correct, but it's a much more complicated topic (especially in the West). Reading a book won't reverse decades of cultural conditioning. I recommend getting a Brazilian or Colombian wife instead.
- Psyonic 16y agoOr you can live up to the challenge posed by American women. If you can manage that, Brazilian and Columbian women will also be interested, so you'll get to pick.
- jobrahms 16y agoYou overlook the fact that making effort (and most importantly following through) gets you sex. Happy wife = happy life. It's not beneath you to try to make your partner happy. And if she responds the way you're implying - I'm sorry, something is probably wrong with her.
- loewenskind 16y ago>Happy wife = happy life I hate this phrase, it's the battle cry of those who do whatever their wife says and laugh with their buddies about how whipped they are. Marriage is a balancing act. Of course you have to change and give in where appropriate but if you do everything she says she wants you will lower her opinion of you (as it should, since you're a coward).
- khafra 16y agoI encourage you to marry. If you find a good wife, you will be happy. If not, you will become a philosopher. -- Socrates
- jobrahms 16y agoHappy wife = happy life only works if your wife thinks "Happy husband = happy life". The premise of the phrase, for me, is that you're actually married to the right person. But way to read too far into a silly little phrase and call me a coward, Mr. Anonymous Internet Man.
- Afton 16y agoI think you're reading the parent wrong. They're not calling you a coward, they're classifying"[anyone who does] everything she says she wants" as cowards.
- loewenskind 16y agoLooks like you're getting a bit defensive for some reason. I was using "you" as a generic pronoun (I could have said "one would be" instead but that's more wordy and is IMO less clear).