5 ms·
Interesting - Sun didn't fold when Apple threatened them but there wasn't a suit either. The thing is, it seems there are examples of open source companies or
by joe_the_user 16y ago
Interesting - Sun didn't fold when Apple threatened them but there wasn't a suit either.
The thing is, it seems there are examples of open source companies or developers folding when presented with the "whiff" of a patent suit. See: http://forums.fedoraforum.org/archive/index.php/t-234073.html http://forums.fedoraforum.org/archive/index.php/t-234073.htm...
Further, as I recall, it has been speculated that Nokia's Apple suit involved a demand by Nokia that Apple cross license its UI patents. http://www.businessinsider.com/did-nokia-sue-apple-to-access-multi-touch-patents-2009-10 http://www.businessinsider.com/did-nokia-sue-apple-to-access...
The thing is, if Nokia had previously been "coding around" Apple's UI, it's not surprising that their UI sucked.
It's easy to imagine that the more timid an organization, the more willing they are to be pushed around by an over broad claim.
Altogether, It would be a good thing to provoke Apple into actually suing someone for violating "their" UI controls: Threats people back away from put a bully in a more powerful position than threats carried through.
- jerf 16y ago"The thing is, it seems there are examples of open source companies or developers folding when presented with the "whiff" of a patent suit." Well, carry the logic out a bit further. $COMPANY threatens $TARGET vaguely with a patent lawsuit. There's two ways this can go: 1. $TARGET has patents important to $COMPANY 2. $TARGET does not. The post is about case 1. This has little relevance to case 2. The next step after threatening the open source developer is to file a suit, and even the slightest legal interaction will drain a disproportionate amount of time from an individual.
- skymt 16y agoThe problem is, most open-source developers don't have their own patent arsenal.
- joe_the_user 16y agoWell if the only allowing you to create software is a patent arsenal, there is trouble indeed... Plus Red Hat did get sued eventually anyway by a troll claiming a patent on more or less any kind of GUI. Sure, flinch against the patent mafia if you don't have a patent arsenal. Just don't be surprised if another troll walks through the door in five minutes asking for more money and/or more GUI crippling... Edit: The most frustrating thing about all this is it difficult to determine if this is what has kept Linux GUIs lame or not; Information on the various decisions involved is spread in dribs and drabs around the web. You would think anti-patent organizers would at least keep a list of these actions.
- gst 16y agoThat's the ugly part about the whole thing: Apple takes quite a lot from the open-source community, starting at the kernel, continuing with the user-space utilities, up to the HTML rendering engine. And at the same time they threaten open-source developers with lawsuites and/or leave patent situations deliberately unclarified (such as in the case of the patents against Freetype).
- berntb 16y agoI'm not that knowledgeable about Apple and open source, but: http://www.apple.com/opensource/ http://www.apple.com/opensource/ >>Apple takes ... HTML rendering engine From the Apple page: "Apple uses software created by the Open Source community, such as the HTML rendering engine for Safari, and returns its enhancements to the community." Similar with contributions to the kernel, afaik? Didn't Apple buy CUPS, hire the main developer -- and let it continue be open source? And so on. Corporations, like countries, are a bit above (or, if you want, below) the concepts of good/evil. But Apple is hardly Microsoft. Edit: I checked, the HTML rendering is under LGPL/BSD licenses! A bit ridiculous to complain about that, since it now is used by direct competitors of Apple. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WebKit http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WebKit "WebKit was originally derived by Apple Inc. from the Konqueror browser’s KHTML software library for use as the engine of Mac OS X’s Safari web browser and has now been further developed by individuals from the KDE project, Apple Inc., Nokia, Google, Bitstream, Torch Mobile and others.[4]"
- thwarted 16y agoI think gst's point was not that Apple contributes back to the open source community or not in terms of code, it's that Apple reaps the benefits of the open source software and community and then attacks open source projects and contributors with patent threats. While they are good citizens on the code contribution front, they are not all around good citizens on the plays-wells-with-others front.
- statictype 16y agoWhat Open Source projects did Apple threaten with lawsuits?
- Samuel_Michon 16y ago"It would be a good thing to provoke Apple into actually suing someone for violating "their" UI controls" When HTC started selling Android smartphones, I think Apple considered that provocation. So they sued HTC. [0] Apple has sued other cell phone manufacturers as well, but those are all countersuits [1] -- AFAIK, the HTC lawsuit is the first in which Apple went on the offensive. [0] http://www.patentlyapple.com/patently-apple/2010/06/apple-sues-htc-and-exedea-for-patent-infringement.html http://www.patentlyapple.com/patently-apple/2010/06/apple-su... [1] http://www.patentlyapple.com/.a/6a0120a5580826970c0134889b012f970c-pi http://www.patentlyapple.com/.a/6a0120a5580826970c0134889b01...
- truestatement 16y agoThe rule of thumb holds: if somebody calls you up and threatens to sue you, they aren't going to sue you.
- SeoxyS 16y agoSun was a large commercial company that owns quite a portfolio of patents. It had the resources to fight back and tell Apple to go fuck itself. Your average open-source project, on the other hand, might not.