3 ms·
Defined benifit pensions can utilize the same investments as defined contribution pensions. The actual difference is who gets the surplus from early deaths, ei
by Retric 7y ago
Defined benifit pensions can utilize the same investments as defined contribution pensions. The actual difference is who gets the surplus from early deaths, either other pensioners or children/charities etc. Equivalent investments are thus safer in defined benifit pensions at least in terms of a safe retirement.
Of course this is all rather dependent on good regulations and equivalent funding. Allow companies to issue dividends or stock buybacks with under funded pensions and you get seriously perverse incentives.
- snarf21 7y agoAs you say, the incentives are out of whack. I'd say the other difference the defined benefit tend to have an extra layer of cost in them. Maybe this can be paid for strictly with the surplus but when it can't, they start chasing. I've always found defined contribution to be more fair (why can't my children benefit from my hard work?) and by definition lower cost.
- nradov 7y agoThat is not how it actually works. Regardlesss of investment selection, most defined benefit pensions won't have a surplus. They will have deficits due to unrealistic expected returns. Many plan sponsors can't afford to pay the difference and will end up bankrupt (especially local governments). This is risky for retirees because even if the plan had PBGC insurance their payments will be cut. Defined benefit pension plans are a hidden growing cancer in our economy and may cause the next huge financial crisis.
- Retric 7y agoThe elderly will receive some form on assistance in their old age if they have no assets or income. It’s a diffuse and therefore easily overlooked, but massive hidden cost. So, defined contribution plans are a much larger and more insidious long term threat that’s going to hit as an ever larger chunk of the oldest population run out of money and get government benefits either way. Don’t forget this is a new system unlike pensions. The 401k system only started in 1978 and adoption lagged. It’s when people the entered the workforce in the late 90’s start to hit their 80’s that we are going to see a sudden spike in these costs. Worse it’s not limited based on incomes as anyone can out spend their nest egg.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoFor taxpayer funded defined benefit pensions, the actual difference is that in the defined benefit pension case, future taxpayers are on the hook for any underfunding and understating of costs in exchange for government employee votes as well as other kinds of fraud. With defined contribution, politicians and senior union officials can’t play those numbers games since there is no lien on future taxpayers.
- vkou 7y ago> With defined contribution, politicians and senior union officials can’t play those numbers games since there is no lien on future taxpayers. If you run out of money in your retirement, and are eating catfood under a bridge, you're going to ask future taxpayers to pay for your survival, either way. Regardless of whether the reason for it is 'my pension fund ran out of money' or 'I lived longer than my planned X years of runway.' The fun thing is, if you've invested into both of those things, you are reducing the risk that you end up in this situation.
- nradov 7y agoLocal governments with unsustainable pension costs are likely to choose bankruptcy instead of large tax increases. Bankruptcy judges have the authority to unilaterally cut pension benefits. For any young attorneys just starting out, Chapter 9 bankruptcy will be a growing and lucrative practice area.