3 ms·
Interestingly, quality of life doesn't seem to have plummeted in the era of a digitally-mediated panopticon as some sci-fi scenarios predicted.
by shadowgovt 7y ago
Interestingly, quality of life doesn't seem to have plummeted in the era of a digitally-mediated panopticon as some sci-fi scenarios predicted.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoBecause it depends on human operators using intuition to look for suspicious activity. When the machine flags you as a terrorist you will be sent through the system as a CYA precaution. I knew a Mexican citizen who was a legal green card holder in the US. Unfortunately his name was a match to a fugitive on the most wanted list. Every US entry involved an hour long interview to confirm his identity. This is what machine vision will to to everyone with its false positives.
- shadowgovt 7y ago> This is what machine vision will do to everyone with its false positives. That's definitely an impossible scenario, because it's not sustainable to interrogate every entrant into the country for an hour. So it's likelier that the ML algorithm will acquire bias to tone down the likelihood of false positive (at the tradeoff of occasional false negatives).
- imtringued 7y agoYou misread the comment. Not every entrant. Every entry by any person whoose name matches.
- shadowgovt 7y agoIronically, match-by-name is what US customs has to fall back on because it lacks a facial-recognition system to make it easy to determine if the person in front of them looks nothing like the person of interest, and a well-implemented facial recognition system could decrease the odds your friend is subjected to an hour-long interrogation for having the "wrong name."
- monkeynotes 7y agoI think the changes have happened slowly enough not to be perceived. Yes, it's not as dramatic as sci-fi, but if you presented today to someone living in the 80s I think they'd recognize enough Orwellian crap going on to fear where their future is headed. On paper the UK is living in some of the most authoritarian times in modern history. Post 9/11 is a completely different world across much of western society, we have less freedom in many respects. It's almost a trope to say we've given up freedom for the illusion of security. Quality of life isn't entirely represented by how many cars you can afford. I feel like we live in constant fear of terrorism, war, and so on. And yet we never actually get close to these perma-wars, they exist entirely in the press and on TV. I mean, how much Orwellian prophecy do you need before you recognize you are worse off than before?
- shadowgovt 7y agoHere's the thing though: is the situation actually worse than things were for people in the '80s, or do we only believe it must be worse because Orwell wrote some fiction about what life would be like in an era of constant public surveillance, and it turns out the reality on-the-ground is quite different? Orwell assumed a system with a lot of power that was also unaccountable and heavily abused by those in control of it. UK government is neither of those things; they have elections more often than the US does. I'm personally of the opinion that people take 1984 as prophetic gospel when there are multiple scenarios that include mass ubiquitous surveillance that could come to pass. David Brin looks through several alternatives in "The Transparent Society" that seem to reflect more closely the nature of the modern world. Assuming the worst-case scenario is as much an anti-pattern for planning as assuming the best-case scenario.
- monkeynotes 7y agoI can't help but relate the 'First they came ...' prose to the above. I don't really have much to say as I feel the erosion of freedom is clearly apparent and 'worse' than before by all definitions. From "The Transparent Society" Wiki page (I have not read the book) > Brin argues that a core level of privacy—protecting our most intimate interactions—may be preserved, The UK govt. has already invaded intimate interactions, to the point that they got hauled into a Human Rights court https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2018/09/uk-surveillance-regime-violated-human-rights https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2018/09/uk-surveillance-regime... I mean, how much more are you going to accept before they finally come for you?