3 ms·
Real names on a forever-archived internet that follows you around for life is possibly the stupidest policy I've ever heard of. What prevents someone from sign
by ck2 16y ago
Real names on a forever-archived internet that follows you around for life is possibly the stupidest policy I've ever heard of.
What prevents someone from signing up in your name and posting something that would certainly prevent you from getting hired in the future?
Also, what if someone "internet famous" or even worse "real life famous" wants to contribute something?
There has to be a better way to control trolls.
If Quora is going to demand ID, they need to ask ID from EVERYONE before their account is active to prevent fake Steve Jobs, etc. not selectively.
Otherwise I recommend you sign up using your dog's first name or your elderly neighbor's name.
- kj12345 16y agoGreat point - the implied equivalance between posting on the internet with a real name and having a real-world conversation is wrong. Posting on an archived system available to everyone is more like writing an editorial or giving a speech, something which many are uncomfortable with.
- lhnz 16y ago...Those sound just like the kind of person that they should want using their service. If you're unhappy with something being attributed to you years later then you're probably writing crap. (I do think that people might just pick 'real sounding' names though. They should try to make this the exception though...)
- joe_the_user 16y agoIndeed, I think what those pushing real names for their site don't get is that the closer the site gets to appearing to only use real names, the more dangerous and potentially damaging it becomes for the real name users. A random site where anyone can post as anyone else has some plausible deniability. A site where everyone is really themselves has less deniability. A fake facebook account claiming to be X thus is more damaging to X than a totally random website talking about X. And that's not even getting to the dumb stuff you say on your own...
- treyp 16y agoIn their defense, they do allow anonymous posting of questions and answers. So if it's anonymity you're worried about...