4 ms·
I feel like signatures are completely meaningless at this point. Applying a picture of someone's signature to a document they didn't sign is certainly shady, a
by jrockway 7y ago
I feel like signatures are completely meaningless at this point. Applying a picture of someone's signature to a document they didn't sign is certainly shady, and I hope is found to be illegal. But I think we're pretty far gone on signatures being any sort of authentication mechanism. Already you can "e-sign" all sorts of legal documents with no verification of your identity whatsoever. (Meanwhile, one time my bank did check my signature when I was withdrawing what seems now like a tiny amount of money. They decided it didn't match, and then I had to submit a new signature sample before I could have my money. This was after showing them a driver's license, passport, and entering the PIN on my debit card in front of the clerk. Several years later, different bank, I wrote a check for $30,000 to a doctor by logging into my bank with an 8 character no-capital-letters-allowed password.)
I feel like the direction that the standard is going is that you are assumed to have signed something if you benefited from signing that document. So you can't slip through the cracks by not signing something, it's just assumed that you signed it now. This fake signature is just an acknowledgement that signatures are useless. "If we issued you insurance, you signed every form. Prove otherwise." And my feeling is they will probably prevail in court on that, because signatures died a long time ago.
- aguyfromnb 7y ago>Already you can "e-sign" all sorts of legal documents with no verification of your identity whatsoever. Well, not really. If you e-sign a document, it's not like there's no traceable provenance to the signature to establish your identity. To what email were the documents delivered? What computer/device were they signed from? At what location were they signed? Sure, all of those things can be "faked", but they really only matter if the signature is disputed. In this case, that's happened, and it will be quite easy to prove he didn't sign the documents. >This fake signature is just an acknowledgement that signatures are useless This is a bit of a reach. Signatures are not meant to be a secure identity measure. If the story is as explained in the Tweet, it's fraud, and that fraud can be proven thanks to what was or was not actually signed. The story doens't end with the insurance company pointing to the signature and saying, "Look, there it is".
- gruez 7y ago> The story doens't end with the insurance company pointing to the signature and saying, "Look, there it is". Was it? The tweet seems to be 8 months ago. This should have been resolved. Was there an update posted?
- msla 7y ago"It isn't meant to be secure!" is ahistorical, given the difficulty of forging someone's signature by hand in a way it would fool a professional questioned documents examiner, or even someone who knew they were looking for a forgery and had a legitimate signature to hand. Just because technology has overtaken signatures and everyone's politely declined to notice doesn't mean they weren't intended to be secure at one point.
- ljm 7y agoAt least in Europe, when you 'e-sign' a document, you're doing it with the cryptographically secure identity cert embedded in your ID card. You haven't 'e-signed' anything if you haven't used your ID for it. In some countries this is a requirement for almost all docs, including signing a mobile phone contract, or opening a bank account. You'll have the same if you get a fancy Estonian e-residence.
- mattr47 7y agoIn the US Military a lot of the finance, personnel action and evaluations are all e-signed. This requires your CAC (I'd card with embedded crypto) and your PIN. You insert the card into a reader and then type your pin. Document is then e-signed.
- lopmotr 7y agoAn important part of the value of signatures is ceremonial. The act of signing something reminds you that you're making a serious agreement and not just having a casual conversation or carelessly clicking an OK button. As long as nobody disputes that you actually signed the document, then your signature shows that you really meant it. Perhaps nowdays clicking "I have read the T&Cs" also has that same value but I hope not because it's such a mindless activity. I wonder if the bank telling you to correct your signature was so that if you somehow claimed that you didn't want to withdraw that money after-all and that the bank did it without your permission, they could point out that you used your "serious business" signature, not your joke signature. Hopefully it wasn't really for authentication.
- jrockway 7y agoMaybe, but you have to sign your signature to buy a pack of gum with your credit card, which is far from serious business. (Yes, I know this requirement has gone away, but not everyone has gotten the message.) As for the bank... they really do allow and deny checks based on looking at the signature. My problem is that I can't consistently draw a signature. Different paper/pen/surface quality throws me off. And I don't really practice... I use a pen and paper like once a month.
- mijoharas 7y agojust fyi, signing when using a card is very uncommon except in america. Most other countries have long since moved to pin/contactless/other things.
- ender341341 7y agoIt's phasing out in America too, usually only when tipping on the signed receipt anymore (though some of those are even moving to pre-swipe w/o signiture). It's mostly getting the word out to smaller businesses that the credit card companies no longer care about signatures and for older POS machines to be updated.
- mannykannot 7y agoThey are meaningful in at least this sense: a requirement for them led to this disclosure of State Farm's practices, albeit in the small print.
- ProAm 7y agoAuthentication is completely different from legally binding a contract.
- patmcc 7y agoSignatures work perfectly well in the two usual cases: one, when the service is delivered properly and as expected, and two, when the service is not delivered as expected but no one disputes that both parties agreed to it. Where they fall apart is where there's disagreement as to whether one party actually agreed to certain things, but that's not actually particularly common. Most court cases about contracts do not hinge on "did you actually agree to this whole contract?", they're about edge cases, or wording of the contract, or a clear breach that hasn't been dealt with yet.
- account42 7y agoThat's like saying a broken lock works perfectly if only authorized people ever try to enter.