43 ms·
Nuclear power is the only green solution (2004)
- brylie 7y agoWhile being better than coal and petroleum, nuclear is still based on non-renewable uranium. How abundant is uranium compared with coal and petroleum? How destructive and energy intensive are the extraction and refinement processes compared with fossil fuels?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- simonh 7y agoWe have about a 230 year supply as it stands, including mining out known deposits. However there are plenty of ways to use recycling, breeder reactors and alternative sources that could in theory give us nuclear power for thousands of years. That’s not forever, but it’s a start. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-long-will-global-uranium-deposits-last/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-long-will-glo...
- brylie 7y agoThe breeder reactors don't yet, and may never, exist, from what I understand. Part of the appeal of renewables is they have lower environmental impact than mineral and fossil fuel extraction. It just seems to me that nuclear energy sits closer to extractives than renewables in the energy production landscape.
- keanzu 7y agoThe world's present measured resources of uranium (5.7 Mt) in the cost category less than three times present spot prices and used only in conventional reactors, are enough to last for about 90 years. [1] There are an estimated 1.1 trillion tonnes of proven coal reserves worldwide. This means that there is enough coal to last us around 150 years at current rates of production. In contrast, proven oil and gas reserves are equivalent to around 50 and 52 years at current production levels. [2] [1] https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/nuclear-fuel-cycle/uranium-resources/supply-of-uranium.aspx https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/nuclear-fuel-c... [2] https://www.worldcoal.org/coal/where-coal-found https://www.worldcoal.org/coal/where-coal-found
- neuronic 7y agoAs compared to billions of years of projected solar availability.
- brylie 7y agoThanks for the details. Out of curiosity, are those industry-neutral organizations that made those estimates?
- keanzu 7y ago> Are those industry-neutral organizations that made those estimates? Do neutral organizations still exist when even school children have strong opinions on coal power? I don't believe neutrality is thing for coal anymore and it hasn't been for nuclear for a long time. Thus, by definition, these cannot be neutral sources. Even if these were the best estimates possible, how would anyone else authenticate it? With an audit? Like how Arthur Andersen audited Enron? I feel we are post-truth and thus nothing can be claimed to be unbiased.
- YawningAngel 7y agoWe have -20 years of sustainable fossil fuel available to us (i.e. our usage is unsustainable and has been for 20 years). Even if there were only 100 years of Uranium on the whole planet, switching would still be a sane time-buying measure.
- brylie 7y agoI'm not convinced that any energy source relying on mineral extraction for fuel could be defined as "sustainable".
- k__ 7y agoIsn't this also a question of dependency? Maybe the uranium will hold on for 20 - 200 years, who knows, but look how we sustained the monarchies in the middle east by depending on their non-renewable resources. The way to go should be getting rid of dependencies as much as possible.
- keanzu 7y ago> we sustained the monarchies in the middle east Fortunately the fracking revolution broke OPEC's hold on oil prices. https://www.forbes.com/sites/rrapier/2018/07/22/how-the-fracking-revolution-broke-opecs-hold-on-oil-prices/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/rrapier/2018/07/22/how-the-frac...
- melling 7y ago“ Published in The Independent, 24 May 2004.” 16 years later coal generated electricity is still huge and 80% of the world’s electricity is still generated by fossil fuels. I imagine if we’d used nuclear instead, the world would have bought itself an extra decade or two to solve the problem.
- read_if_gay_ 7y agoMore like an extra 100,000 years http://www.daretothink.org/numbers-not-adjectives/how-long-will-our-supplies-of-uranium-and-thorium-last/ http://www.daretothink.org/numbers-not-adjectives/how-long-w...
- melling 7y agoI don’t think going green on electricity alone is enough to solve global warming. We need cars to go electric, etc. The point is that co2 generated over the last 16 years will stay with us for some time. We could have delayed the problem by doing more sooner. A slow train wreck of decades that everyone sees coming. At this rate, we’ll be saying the same thing in 2030.
- mytailorisrich 7y ago> We need cars to go electric, etc. Yes, and that creates massive extra demand for electricity generation, which seems very hard to achieve without nuclear power.
- pysxul 7y ago> We need cars to go electric, etc. Marketing is once again far from the truth, check how co2 expensive producing a battery is. Then couple that with the fact that you need let's say 20 years of normal use of a car to "paybacck" that co2 footprint (comparing to an oil car). Last one is : are you going to keep that same electric car for 20 years?
- read_if_gay_ 7y ago
- spodek 7y agoNothing about the greenest and most sustainable solution: reducing consumption. Most Americans could drop their consumption by 75% purely improving their lives, before difficult decisions, many of which would also improve their lives. Several nations, like Thailand, have lowered birth rates purely voluntarily, increasing prosperity and abundance. Without reducing, new power sources will repeat what led Norman Borlaug said on receiving the Nobel Prize for his part in the Green Revolution: "The green revolution has won a temporary success in man's war against hunger and deprivation; it has given man a breathing space. If fully implemented, the revolution can provide sufficient food for sustenance during the next three decades. But the frightening power of human reproduction must also be curbed; otherwise the success of the green revolution will be ephemeral only. Most people still fail to comprehend the magnitude and menace of the "Population Monster"...Since man is potentially a rational being, however, I am confident that within the next two decades he will recognize the self-destructive course he steers along the road of irresponsible population growth..." We haven't made much progress stemming growth. Projections to 2100 still show our population growing, yet our global footprint is greater than one Earth.
- atemerev 7y agoThe population growth is now sublinear, and expected to stop around 2070.
- glogla 7y agoYeah. And while I'm not saying the OP is doing this, "overpulation" is often used as white supremacist dog whistle and call for eugenics.
- nickik 7y agoYou are getting down-voted but your point is totally correct. The population extremists from the 60s, many in the 'green revolution' were part of that, were VERY actively promoting eugenics and wanted to deploy it on a massive global scale. And this was not new, Eugenics was massive popular with the Progressives, in fact the Progressives were the primary political power behind Eugenics. And those are the exact groups moved over turned into the 'environmentalist' movement that was advocating those same Eugenics policy recommendation, but on a global scale. And because they were smart, they changed the language from 'We need to clean the human race' to 'If we don't clean the human race everybody is gone die'. They wanted the US government to make aid conditional on Eugenics and population control tactics. Trying to prevent the population growth in India was one of their major goals and reading now what they advocated should be done about it, is truly disturbing. Many of those, to be fair were not white supremacists, but if your main position is to advocate extreme policy to curb baby production in Asian and African countries, how much better are your really?
- skitout 7y ago1) The article does not mention consuming less energy/stuff - whether by being mush more efficient for the same result (huge potential there !) or with more sobriety 2) "there is no chance that the renewables, wind, tide and water power can provide enough energy and in time" was true in 2004, now this totally an option : this is cheaper and faster to deploy than nuclear 3) "Opposition to nuclear energy is based on irrational fear" in only partly true... 1% of all nuclear power plant did had a super serious problem (Fukushima, Three Mile Island, Chernobyl)... And there are other unsolved issues around the short term and long term security
- bipson 7y ago4) Nuclear is and always was incredibly expensive to set up. There is a reason why nuclear plants are never paid for in their entirety by any private firm/operator and heavily subsidized (at least in the EU) 5) I am still fascinated by the lack of awareness regarding waste (particularly since it is with well educated/smart people) Yes, I know, there are alternative nuclear power sources where we don't need to safely store nuclear waste for millions of years. But those are not readily available. We still do not have a real solution for nuclear waste. Just dumping something so dangerous for thousands (or millions) of years is mindbogglingly reckless. And loudly asking to increase this amount by plastering waste-producing facilities everywhere... That's like pouring poison in the floor below your own garden, hoping the next guy will have a solution for it. But I guess good ol' America, where dumping any waste is not considered a problem, there is simply no awareness for this practice. Just because you don't see it, doesn't mean it has no effect. Dumping. is. not. a. long-term. solution. And just because You don't need to care about it anymore, doesn't mean nobody has to.
- keanzu 7y agoAll of the used fuel ever produced by the commercial nuclear industry since the late 1950s would cover a football field to a depth of less than 10 yards. https://www.nei.org/fundamentals/nuclear-waste https://www.nei.org/fundamentals/nuclear-waste
- 7y ago
- kemenaran 7y agoThat was indeed in 2004 – long before nuclear stopped being cost-competitive with renewable energies. Oh, and renewables are also faster to deploy than nuclear plants (which take years to build).
- StavrosK 7y agoBut renewables are very bursty and don't allow you to plan well, so we need both.
- pfdietz 7y agoThe intermittency of renewables means nuclear doesn't help. Nuclear needs a constant market at a good average price to make sense. Renewables, even when they do not cover 100%, crash the price often enough to kill nuclear's business case. As renewables build out, the prospects for nuclear will only get worse. At this point, it's a delaying action by utilities to try to get their existing reactors profitable enough to keep from shutting them down. New reactors are not close to making economic sense, and the effective CO2 taxes that would be needed to make them so would be very large.
- StavrosK 7y agoIsn't that because we're using fossil fuels for the base load? What happens when all we have is renewables?
- pfdietz 7y agoFossil fuel baseload is also incompatible with renewables, although not as badly because more of its costs are variable. This is one of the reasons coal is hurting. Think carefully about the economics. Suppose we want to use nuclear to cover the (say) 20% of the time renewables + short term storage might not cover. Nuclear's cost of power would be greatly inflated over what it would be if it were baseload. The effective CO2 tax to make that cheaper than (say) gas turbines burning natural gas would be outrageous, over $1000/ton. A vast array of CO2-reducing changes would occur before that. It would also likely be cheaper to use renewable hydrogen (from electrolysis, stored underground) in gas turbines for that last bit. The round trip efficiency would be lousy, but it would still be cheaper than using nuclear there. View it another way: if we have really cheap power most of the time, insisting we use nuclear then, just so nuclear would be available in that other 20%, would incur a huge opportunity cost. That cost should properly be assigned to the place nuclear is being depended on (that 20%).
- ed_balls 7y agoDoes anyone have a good cost comparison of nuclear, gas, coal/lignite ? Total cost, with decommission. My understanding is that even with Carbon Tax coal is cheaper. From HN comment: > Take the average IPCC meta-analysis numbers [1] at face value: 820 gCO2-eq/kWh for coal, 490 for gas. Those are both extraordinarily high. This is because they both combust carbon in the presence of oxygen to form energy and CO2. They're both very high-carbon fuel sources. If we are trying to reduce carbon emissions, we need to build things that do not combine C + O2 to make CO2 + energy. Options with less than 50g CO2-eq/kWh (in decreasing order of emissions) include solar (41), geothermal (38), hydro (24), tidal (17), nuclear (12), and wind (11).
- legulere 7y agoNobody does. Nuclear power plants don’t get built without assurances and help from the state.
- tomatocracy 7y agoGas CCGT is usually long run cheaper than coal once you include CO2 cost. But old and existing coal plants can often beat new build gas CCGT because theyre fully depreciated and have financing paid off. Additionally it's got a lot harder to finance new build CCGT and is pretty much impossible to finance new build coal these days in most markets. Depending on the market, offshore wind can be cheaper than gas because of that effect and because of scale (the newest wind turbines are absolutely enormous) even ex subsidy.
- strainer 7y agoThe investment analysis firm Lazards publishes detailed reports on LCOE every year. These are current costs per MWh without subsidies [1]: Nuclear : $118 to 192 Solar with storage : $102 - 139 Gas : $44 - 68 Wind : $28 - 54 Solar PV : $32 - 42 They don't include carbon pricing which will increase solars price a bit, it should also push its carbon output from manufacture down as it will be more economical to optimize it. [1] https://www.lazard.com/perspective/lcoe2019 https://www.lazard.com/perspective/lcoe2019
- kragen 7y agoIn 2004 solar power was still far too expensive to be a viable option, to the point where he didn't even bother to mention it: "there is no chance that the renewables, wind, tide and water power can provide enough energy and in time." This is no longer true; installing new photovoltaic generation capacity is now cheaper than continuing to run existing coal plants in much of the world, and although the humans still need to ramp up production capacity to build enough panels, it looks like they are on track to make the switch in the 2020s. The total solar resource is about three orders of magnitude larger than marketed world energy consumption. We shouldn't fault James for not seeing this in 2004, but now we know he was wrong, as many of us were. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Growth_of_photovoltaics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Growth_of_photovoltaics Edited to add: competitive-bid power purchasing agreements hit a new low this week of US$15.67 per MWh in Qatar https://archive.fo/UBWWi https://archive.fo/UBWWi but there are projects in many equatorial parts of the world hitting similar lows. This is a factor of 10 less than what end-users currently pay for electricity in California and roughly a factor of 3 less than the average wholesale cost there.
- Scea91 7y agoBut coal plant as opposed to solar plant has a reliable, predictable output and works after dusk. Nuclear power plant also has these characteristics.
- AstralStorm 7y agoWe do not have to limit ourselves to just one source. Blocking nuclear in favor of some sort of pie in the sky global power network and huge renewable infrastructure is common for some reason. We can use any and all power sources that are clean.
- Scea91 7y agoI completely agree with you. My argument was not against solar. It was against ‘solar only’. Of course, there are other renewables and if some country has an option to use solar + hydro then they do not need nuclear. But not everyone has that option. Disclaimer: I am a layman in this topic and not energetics expert, this is my understanding of the state but please feel free to correct me.
- pfdietz 7y agoThat piece is from 2004. The installed cost of utility scale PV has fallen by an order of magnitude since 2004. The conclusions he reached then are not relevant now.
- flgb 7y agoHe writes in the context of the UK. In January 2008 the UK Government gave the go-ahead to build a nuclear power station. This is Hinkley Point C. It might be producing power in 2023. It could cost as much as £22 billion. This kind of project is certainly not the solution.
- Tade0 7y agoBut with six billion, and growing, few options remain; we can not continue drawing energy from fossil fuels and there is no chance that the renewables, wind, tide and water power can provide enough energy and in time. I beg to differ. So far in China's electricity mix renewables have contributed much more than nuclear. And it's poised to stay that way given how difficult it really is to build nuclear power in practice.
- mar77i 7y agoRight. Although, arguing China's side of the discussion as an example seems very very disproportionate at this point. See these giant, graphite-black sectors on the 2017 diagrams listed? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_China
- Tade0 7y agoMy point is that China having the fastest growing nuclear program in the world is still not getting more energy from that source than renewables. Nuclear appears to be simply too slow to roll out.
- michaelbuckbee 7y agoI mean yes - if I was playing Civ this is the route I would go. But I look at the current landscape of both political opinion and technological progress and think: we should go all-in on Solar and storage. I look at practical-minded organizations like the US Navy (who certainly have access to nuclear reactors in a more streamlined way than civilian utilities) and yet they still put in a 21 MW solar farm at NAS Oceana [1]. 1 - https://navysustainability.dodlive.mil/energy/repo-3/projects-page/nas-oceana-solar-facility/ https://navysustainability.dodlive.mil/energy/repo-3/project...
- IAmNotAFix 7y agoNuclear is probably the best solution, but it only works if you somehow manage to calibrate its impact on people's psychology (or just hope for no disaster to happen in the next 100 years, which is hard to to be sure about). The standard procedure in case of disaster involves a massive evacuation, cleanup, and confinement, which are costly[1], deathly[2], and traumatizing for the population[3]. All of that is probably still worth it in comparison to the consequences of global warming in regards to many factual metrics (number of deaths, purchasing power, etc), but I'm not actually sure it's worth it in regards to the only metric that actually matters: how much of a disastrous state people perceive their environment to be in. In the case of Fukushima, Japan, which was beforehand in the process of switching more and more of its energy to nuclear, changed their stance overnight to switch back to all-fossile, because of pressure from the public opinion. If a nuclear disaster would come to happen in a country like France, the situation would probably be an absolute disaster, with people on a major psychosis and a state unable to realistically switch to another form of energy. [1] The cost of a nuclear disaster in France (similar to the one in Fukushia) has been estimated at 430 billions euros, which is 20% of the country's economic output. (https://www.reuters.com/article/us-france-nuclear-disaster-cost-idUSBRE91603X20130207 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-france-nuclear-disaster-c...) [2] Fukushima's evacuation caused 1,600 deaths, that is more than the deaths caused by the tsunami itself. [3] Following the Chernobyl disaster, there was a large increase of PTSD instaces, psychosomatic diseases, alcoholism, suicide, etc. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiation_effects_from_the_Fukushima_Daiichi_nuclear_disaster#Psychological_effects_of_perceived_radiation_exposure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiation_effects_from_the_Fuk...) TL;DR: you need to somehow make people chill about nuclear if you want to argue that nuclear is a satisfying source of energy. It might still be the best option nonetheless.
- jamil7 7y agoAs other comments in this thread have mentioned, since 2004 the renewable energy landscape has changed a lot and we're at a point were the technology and cost of solar is there, we just need to ramp up production. While nuclear might be carbon neutral it comes with a whole load of problems without clear solutions. Burying nuclear waste in a hole is pretty shortsighted both in terms of saftey and cost, the raw materials are not renewable and an accident can be devestating.
- lispm 7y agoThe article is old and outdated. Since Nuclear does not scale, it is no solution to climate change, for example. The World Nuclear Status Report says: https://www.worldnuclearreport.org/The-World-Nuclear-Industry-Status-Report-2019-HTML.html https://www.worldnuclearreport.org/The-World-Nuclear-Industr... --- Non-Nuclear Options Save More Carbon Per Year. While current nuclear programs are particularly slow, current renewables programs are particularly fast. New nuclear plants take 5–17 years longer to build than utility-scale solar or onshore wind power, so existing fossil-fueled plants emit far more CO2 while awaiting substitution by the nuclear option. Stabilizing the climate is urgent, nuclear power is slow. --- Just look at the electricity production trends of China: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_China#/media/File:Electricity_Production_in_China.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_China#/m...
- koheripbal 7y agoworldnuclearreport.org is an anti-nuclear activist organization, FYI. They are not an official body of any kind. There are a number of flaws in the conclusions they advocate. 1. They compare raw generation costs, but always neglect storage costs for renewables - which is the MAJORITY problem with most renewables. 2. They claim that nuclear takes long and is expensive, while continuing to advocate regulations to make nuclear more expensive and take longer. I call this the "push someone off a cliff and then accuse him of being clumsy" strategy. 3. Nuclear scales better than any other solution. Storage (at least in North America) is trivial - we have a massive facility capable of storing ALL the waste from the US & Canada, just sitting closed because of politics and fearmongering. 4. Building a nuclear plant takes 10-15 years. The most ambitious "New Green Deal" plan from environmentalists has a timeline of 10 years (despite have no solution to the storage problem). Frankly, if we get to 100% nuclear and hydro in 20 years, that is very much in line with preventing climate change. Note also that China is currently building 24 GenIII nuclear plants.
- lispm 7y ago> Note also that China is currently building 24 GenIII nuclear plants. Too slow. What is it? 30 GW production capacity? 40? 50? China is going in the direction of total 1300 GW production capacity with just coal. > Building a nuclear plant takes 10-15 years. A single one. I was taking about scale. To replace the coal power plants of China, one would need to build 1000 reactors.
- INTPenis 7y agoHow green is it when we've had it for 70 years and already created two* exclusion zones on earth. How many more exclusion zones will we have created with our hubris that we can create a perfect system? I understand that my entire career (IT) depends on nuclear, but I can't ignore the fact that we have a giant reactor at the center of our solar system. We should focus on using that instead. *not counting all the fallout from weapons.
- natch 7y agoIt’s an overly centralized solution in that it takes control away from the individual citizens and property owners, who have to foot the bill for costs, taxes, bonds, overruns, and profits for corporations not to mention possible payoffs to politicians. Including costs that are cleverly kept off the official pronouncements with accounting tricks. Technically it may have come a little by way but small individual solutions like solar panels with battery systems have huge advantages when it comes to freedom and self determination.
- british_india 7y agoOne word: Fukushima. No, do you know how much CO2 is released just by trying to build those plants. We STILL do not have anywhere to store the wastes.
- lucideer 7y agoSomeone on HN recently posted this link https://en-roads.climateinteractive.org/ https://en-roads.climateinteractive.org/ I don't have a full read on how accurately the figures backing this tool reflect reality, but one thing that really stood out to me while playing with it was how small an impact nuclear has on the overall outcomes.
- Amarok 7y agoIdeally the future is nuclear fission transitioning to fusion, with hydrogen fuel cell vehicles. Lithium battery production and recycling is still very damaging to the environment, even if it stopped relying on coal for energy[1][2]. Hydrogen vehicles also have a longer lifespan and range compared to electric vehicles, while needing less time to refuel[3]. Now if only we invested as much in hydrogen harvesting technology as we are investing in lithium batteries. [1]https://amp.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/2017/aug/24/nickel-mining-hidden-environmental-cost-electric-cars-batteries https://amp.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/2017/aug/24... [2]https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2017/11/battery-batteries-electric-cars-carbon-sustainable-power-energy/ https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2017/11/battery-batteries-ele... [3]https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/engineering/hydrogen-fuel-cell-vehicle https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/engineering/hydrogen-fu...
- edhelas 7y ago"Ideally the future" When, how ? Yes ideally the future can have magical technologies that will solve humanity problems. We had this magical "nuclear" thing in the sixties. Today a huge majority of electricity worldwide is produced by coal, oil and gaz. Hydrogen is a no go, you're loosing 70% into transforming electricity to hydrogen and back to electricity. And no you cannot simply "throw money at it" to turn 70% into 5%.
- Amarok 7y agoThis is just plain desinformación, hydrogen has an efficiency of 70%, which means a loss of 30%, and yes this figure is improving by "throwing money at it"
- IB885588 7y agoGreat (great!) podcasts about nuclear fusion reactors (the second one is an interview with a physicist at ITER, being built in the South of France): http://omegataupodcast.net/22-nuclear-fusion-at-mpi-fur-plasmaphysik/ http://omegataupodcast.net/22-nuclear-fusion-at-mpi-fur-plas... https://omegataupodcast.net/157-fusion-at-iter/ https://omegataupodcast.net/157-fusion-at-iter/
- stevespang 7y agoAnyone who is still posting this nonsense has lost all credibility with those who are educated . . . green solutions must involve cost, and nuclear power is so far off the chart in cost it will never be an option when bankers are involved, only in authoritarian states, or those states wishing to use reactors to also produce weapons, will any new nuclear sites be created (like Iran). Existing nuclear plants are merely "an accident waiting to happen". https://m.phys.org/news/2011-05-nuclear-power-world-energy.html https://m.phys.org/news/2011-05-nuclear-power-world-energy.h...
- Andrew_nenakhov 7y agoNuclear power is the only green solution that allows necessary power density and a constant power output. Too bad it has so much negative press, mostly by journalists interested in sensational scary stuff.
- pfdietz 7y ago"Necessary" power density? Please explain why the power density is necessary.
- air7 7y agoNuclear critics seem to ignore, at least when discussing the dangers, that the world is currently producing 10% of its energy from ~440 nuclear power plants in ~50 countries. France for example, derives about 75% of its electricity from nuclear energy. This is not some spooky new technology to be wary of. It's doing fine. All we need is to scale by a single factor of 10 compared to what we have now to go 100% green. [0] In terms of public perception of danger, Nuclear vs Coal is akin to Flying vs Driving. In both the latter kills many many more people, although little by little. The former has disasters extremely rarely, and even then they are not that bad [1][2][3], but when they do its all anyone can talk about for a long time, and they cement an erroneous perception of danger. "Coal is responsible for over 800,000 premature deaths per year globally and many millions more serious and minor illnesses." [4] The only real issue is cost. While its very competitive to run a NPP, its very expensive to build one. Note how the number of plants has grown exponentially(?) until 1986 and then just plateaued. [0] Considering the crisis we are in, I think its only logical we subitize NPPs, take extra care of them (for example in Fukashima the right protocols were in place and so the death toll as a result of radiation is "1" [5]), deal with the waste problem later, and work on perhaps better solutions in the ensuing decades. Sure it's not perfect, but its our best bet. [0] https://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/current-and-future-generation/nuclear-power-in-the-world-today.aspx https://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/current-an... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_and_radiation_accidents_by_death_toll https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_and_radiation_... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deaths_due_to_the_Chernobyl_disaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deaths_due_to_the_Chernobyl_di... [3] https://ourworldindata.org/what-is-the-safest-form-of-energy https://ourworldindata.org/what-is-the-safest-form-of-energy [4] https://endcoal.org/health/ https://endcoal.org/health/ [5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fukushima_Daiichi_nuclear_disaster_casualties https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fukushima_Daiichi_nuclear_disa...
- pfdietz 7y ago> Nuclear critics seem to ignore, at least when discussing the dangers, that the world is currently producing 10% of its energy from ~440 nuclear power plants in ~50 countries. We don't ignore it, we recognize that it is irrelevant. You seem to be saying that if a choice was the correct one at one time, it will always be correct. But that's nonsense.
- ThinkBeat 7y agoIf we were to build reactors to replace existing fossil fuel plans there would not be enough uranium cheap enough that it makes sense to use it.
- diegoholiveira 7y agoThe problem is the kind of nuclear reaction used. Fission reactors are bad, but once we got fusion reactors, we'll have an almost perfect energy source: clean, reliable and cheap. The project Iter (http://iter.org/ http://iter.org/) is building the first fusion reactor. It's a big challenge but I'm glade that this project exists at all.
- pfdietz 7y agoFusion is going to be more expensive than fission, if it works at all. The idea that it would be cheap has no rational basis. The power density of ITER that you reference there is 400x worse than a PWR. Fusion reactors will be monstrous expensive things.
- ptah 7y agonuclear power is not scalable though https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?arnumber=6021978 https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?arnumber=6021978
- DonHopkins 7y agoI posted this about David MacKay's book "Sustainable Energy - without the hot air", which advocates nuclear energy, to a discussion about solar panels, and llukas pointed out that solar power development has exceeded MacKay's expectations, and linked to a page with updates, and dane-pgp also posted some interesting criticisms and links. If Solar Panels Are So Clean, Why Do They Produce So Much Toxic Waste? (forbes.com) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18751049 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18751049 https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelshellenberger/2018/05/23/if-solar-panels-are-so-clean-why-do-they-produce-so-much-toxic-waste/#2a1c244a121c https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelshellenberger/2018/05/23... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18751049 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18751049 DonHopkins on Dec 24, 2018 [-] The late David MacKay's book "Sustainable Energy - without the hot air" is available free online: http://www.withouthotair.com/ http://www.withouthotair.com/ Here's the chapter about solar energy: http://www.withouthotair.com/c6/page_38.shtml http://www.withouthotair.com/c6/page_38.shtml Here's a 1000 word synopsis he wrote for his talk to the House of Lords: http://www.inference.org.uk/sustainable/book/SUMMARY http://www.inference.org.uk/sustainable/book/SUMMARY David MacKay also invented the Dasher text input system: http://www.inference.org.uk/dasher/ http://www.inference.org.uk/dasher/ llukas on Dec 24, 2018 [-] Very good book but tech went lot further than David expected in many places (ie. solar power efficiency vs price). This page tried to keep it updated: https://www.carboncommentary.com/blog/2017/3/30/l6qcqgoedse1wmjjz87t09usoq6jva https://www.carboncommentary.com/blog/2017/3/30/l6qcqgoedse1... dane-pgp on Dec 24, 2018 [-] David MacKay has done some great work, but I feel I need to present some of the criticism he has received, for balance. In particular, there is a perception that he is biased towards nuclear energy (understating its drawbacks, while also being unnecessarily dismissive of renewables). People can consider these articles for themselves: https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/professor-david-mackay-britain-must-go-nuclear-to-control-climate-bgtjk0j6wh9 https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/professor-david-mackay-br... "Professor David MacKay: Britain ‘must go nuclear’ to control climate" https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2016/may/03/idea-of-renewables-powering-uk-is-an-appalling-delusion-david-mackay https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2016/may/03/idea-of-... "Idea of renewables powering UK is an 'appalling delusion' – David MacKay" The latter, from 2016, includes the line: "There is this appalling delusion that people have that we can take this thing that is currently producing 1% of our electricity and we can just scale it up..." For reference, according to: https://www.independent.co.uk/environment/wind-solar-overtake-nuclear-electricity-source-uk-first-time-renewable-energy-a8281656.html https://www.independent.co.uk/environment/wind-solar-overtak... "Renewables’ share of electricity generation shot up to 29 per cent, while nuclear sources accounted for around 21 per cent." benj111 on Dec 24, 2018 [-] I think when he was writing, solar wasn't competitive, and neither really was wind. With that in mind nuclear had a place in zero carbon fuel mix, we should perhaps be thankful that other renewables have made such amazing strides. He isn't around anymore to update his book, but I'm not sure it matters. For me anyway, it was the approach not the specifics that mattered. Id rather be reading MacKay's 10 year old book for advice rather than those people who think banning straws is going to save the world.
- toxik 7y agoOne negative aspect of nuclear reactors that I found is rarely discussed is their vulnerability to military attacks. Wind, water and solar are distributed much more. Of course there are other single points of failure, but at least those failures don't involve risk of nuclear contamination.
- Slashbot 7y agoWhat kind of retard would ever consider nuclear ....a green solution? Maybe green as in hazardous green to all that is living.. How many nuclear disasters do you pro 'nuclear' tards need to see the amount of destruction it causes.. cancer rates can practically be directly linked to the amount of nuclear sites constructed... the waste storage alone is a lifetime problem for all future generations to deal with. Honesty doesn't even worth the reply, the evidence is out and surmounting against Nuclear, just uneducated and blissfully unaware morons or the worst those who have an invested interested in it.
- kadonoishi 7y agoSuppose you exhaustively incorporated all risk when engineering power plants, and you designed such that exhaustive risk was equal across all power plants. That would mean risks from climate change were included in the engineering of coal plants, and the engineering of nuclear plants therefore needed to match the exhaustive risk of coal plants including climate change risk. That would mean nuclear plants could be engineered to accept higher risk, to match the exhaustive risk of coal plants. If a nuclear plant might render a region uninhabitable due to radiation, that would be matched against a coal plant rendering a region uninhabitable due to sea level rise, etc, all risks exhaustively incorporated. How much cheaper would a nuclear plant be if it was engineered to an exhaustive risk-mitigation standard commensurate with the exhaustive risk of other industrial plants like coal-fired power plants, mines, chemical plants?