5 ms·
Enforce valid caller ID on calls coming from VoIP.
by AnimalMuppet 7y ago
Enforce valid caller ID on calls coming from VoIP.
- dvtrn 7y agoHow do you enforce that with how disposable DIDs are? It is trivially easy to acquire a block of numbers from any number of sources with easily falsifiable information, connect them to a SIP application to robocall/robotext victims using easily falsifiable CID data and disappear just as trivially. Programmatic voice via SIP trunking only makes this worse-not critiquing services like Twilio, Plivo or Telnyx, just highlighting one of the unfortunate risks the technology available to us enables. CID enforcement is a grand idea but I have no clue how you'd actually accomplish it.
- ianwalter 7y agoPassing regulation requiring audit logs sounds like a good first step.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoSHAKEN/STIR https://www.zdnet.com/article/at-t-comcast-successfully-test-shakenstir-protocol-for-fighting-robocalls/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/at-t-comcast-successfully-test... https://transnexus.com/whitepapers/understanding-stir-shaken/ https://transnexus.com/whitepapers/understanding-stir-shaken... Doesn’t solve the problem entirely, but makes it easier to identify and blacklist robocall operations using heuristics, rate limiting, etc.
- nostrebored 7y agoWhat does this look like to you? The CNAM presented on a SIP call should be authenticated against what?
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoHow about the number? If I'm making a SIP call on, say, Alianza, shouldn't what I present as my number for Caller ID match what Alianza thinks my number to receive calls is? Or, if I'm a large organization, shouldn't it at least be one of the numbers registered to my organization? I may be able to spoof the name. The number? Not so much.
- nostrebored 7y agoYou also send your number as part of the invite. Responsible VoIP providers limit this to numbers you own, but it's totally possible to send calls using a number you don't own. There are CNAM databases but not all carriers make use of them and they aren't a source of truth. How would your solution deal with numbers which go back into a carriers pool? How would your solution deal with newly claimed numbers? How do you verify the numbers on file for an organization?
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoI was thinking along these lines: It may be possible to send calls using a number I don't own. It should not be possible to send calls using a number that the VoIP provider doesn't own. If I'm sending a VoIP call to someone's cell phone, and I'm saying that I'm a cell phone in the same block of numbers as the destination phone, a responsible VoIP provider should block that, even if they don't restrict me only to my number. But we both used the word "responsible". I think that's the problem - there are some irresponsible VoIP providers. Maybe even deliberately irresponsible. For obvious reasons, they attract the spammers and scammers. And that brings us back to this lawsuit as a reasonable response to that kind of irresponsible behavior.