3 ms·
FDA sent a similar warning to 23&Me and later shut down their operations (and Anne Wojicicki later admitted she didn't take the warning seriously enough). Thes
by dekhn 7y ago
FDA sent a similar warning to 23&Me and later shut down their operations (and Anne Wojicicki later admitted she didn't take the warning seriously enough). These are not trivial.
- gumby 7y agoI got once a notice, not even a warning letter but just a request for a missing sheet of paper in a 1600+ page submission. I mentioned it in the next board meeting and my board wanted to know how many minutes it had taken us to respond to the FDA's fax. When 23andMe got their warnings there was much outcry in the Valley (and on HN) that the FDA was "not receptive to new technologies". But 23andMe took weeks to respond and when they would they often didn't even address the issues raised. The FDA bent over backwards for them because they were a new kind of technology -- those of us making real drugs got no such leeway. BTW they weren't shut down but were prohibited from making unsubstantiated claims. If you want to print "use of this product will not cause you to grow a third arm" you would have to design a trial to support that claim even if the product is a tongue depressor. FDA will actually let you claim anything as long as you have demonstrated it to their satisfaction.