4 ms·
> The iPad at 10 is, to me, a grave disappointment. The biggest disappointment to me is that I can't buy a Macbook that converts into a tablet. I've never owne
by gwbas1c 7y ago
> The iPad at 10 is, to me, a grave disappointment.
The biggest disappointment to me is that I can't buy a Macbook that converts into a tablet. I've never owned a tablet, and my wife never replaced her 1st generation iPad, because there's just too much overlap between tablet and phone; and between tablet and laptop.
And, as far as multitasking goes: When I do serious work that requires that kind of multitasking, I need a keyboard and mouse. Furthermore, I'll probably be sitting in a chair, at a desk, with a giant monitor... Multitasking is just an absurd use case for a "tablet." Instead, it shows that "tablet" and "laptop" just need to converge to be the same ^%#$ device.
Windows tablets might suck, but at least you don't have to own two devices!
- dangus 7y agoOn the contrary, Apple is the only one who has this market figured out. Ever see anyone at a coffee shop using a Surface Pro in tablet mode? I haven’t. That’s because the second you sit down to complete tasks for more than a minute or two you’ll want a keyboard at least if not a mouse, too. In my view that eliminates productivity as a legitimate use for a tablet. There’s no way I’d prefer touching my screen to the kind of keyboard and trackpad you get on a MacBook Pro. Next up, content consumption. As you mentioned, your phone covers this use case. I watch videos on the bus nearly every day and never desired a tablet. If you need that bigger screen, you’ve either already got a computer because you do productive work, or you buy a cheap tablet because you don’t need all the extra stuff a computer has, or you’ve got a bigger phone. Why would I watch content on a tablet when my laptop or TV can do that? A tablet doesn’t even stand itself up on my lap. I think only kids tolerate consuming content this way. Finally, there’s the creative market. Apple has this nailed down with the iPad Pro. The only other reason to need a tablet over a phone or laptop is to do digital art. These are probably the only folks who need to buy two devices, but they’ve needed to buy expensive computer peripherals for ages. So I think what you’re asking for is for someone to find the really tiny market who wants their tablet to do full computer stuff but doesn’t prefer a proper laptop computer, and then make special software modifications just for them like Microsoft did.
- pcurve 7y agoYeah tablet serves generally different market, but it can also meets needs of existing laptop users who just want more portable media consumption device, whether around bedroom, bathroom, or on a plane on business trip where you're likely to have locked-down work-issued PC.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dangus 7y agoYou’re absolutely right. This leads into the four markets that I think the tablet can sell to: 1. For kids or secondary throw-around devices (like for travel). 2. Digital Art and pen-based content creation. 3. People who won’t otherwise use their phone (in my view, not many). 4. Point of sale, retail, mobile enterprise computing. The key here is understanding that it’s not like everyone threw out their personal computers when the tablet and phone was invented. They just aren’t replaced as often as phones. That’s where I don’t think tablets compete well against someone’s existing laptop. If Apple let the iPad run full macOS software without the App Store that still wouldn’t convince me to buy one, even if that would be a welcome change. So, I guess that’s my overall point here: tablets have to compete with proper computers and I don’t think they’ve succeeded. The Surface Pro turns into a proper computer and it’s telling that most people use it as a laptop, not a keyboard-less tablet.
- pier25 7y ago> Ever see anyone at a coffee shop using a Surface Pro in tablet mode? I haven’t. That’s because the second you sit down to complete tasks for more than a minute or two you’ll want a keyboard at least if not a mouse, too. Precisely because they are sitting on table. Have you seen those same users in their couch or bed?
- dangus 7y agoSo basically, add a table and a tablet becomes silly. That isn’t a good look for that device category. Who doesn’t have a table? Now imagine how many of those people wouldn’t just use their phone while sitting on the couch or bed instead. Why should I use a tablet over my 6 inch phone screen? Why use a tablet instead of my TV? The only two devices most people would need to own are a laptop and a phone. The tablet is an awkward third device that generally isn’t needed, or it’s a “cheapest possible laptop“ replacement for people who don’t need a lot of computing ability (emails, web browsing). Buying a Surface Pro instead of a proper laptop is itself a compromise.
- tguedes 7y agoThere is a clear use case for the iPad, it just depends on if that use case justifies the price for an additional device. The iPad is the best portable device for reading (besides a kindle), watching entertainment, or using an Apple Pencil. Just because you don't have a use case for it, doesn't mean no one does.
- gwbas1c 7y ago> Just because you don't have a use case for it, doesn't mean no one does. My point was: A Macbook with a foldable or detachable screen can handle that use case. Once you have a laptop that's also a tablet, multitasking in tablet mode is silly.
- jimbokun 7y agoWhat's sad about this, is that iPad Pro has more than enough computational power to replace a laptop for almost all the tasks people use laptops for. Just using wireless peripherals or a dock should make the iPad Pro work for serious tasks just fine. But as daringfireball explains, the problem is with the poorly thought out UI choices. It feels almost like the iPad is deliberately hobbled in many ways, but I think it's just poor management.