3 ms·
I worked on AI-via-predicate-calculus, as a successor to Cyc, and I think the main thing I learned is that people are incredibly bad at predicate calculus. Even
by jfengel 7y ago
I worked on AI-via-predicate-calculus, as a successor to Cyc, and I think the main thing I learned is that people are incredibly bad at predicate calculus. Even when we behave "logically", it's an after-the-fact rationalization for a conclusion we arrived at much faster with heuristics.
When we think-about-thinking, or talk-about-thinking, we do so in the language of language, which quickly leads to logic. And that leads us to think that the logic is the thinking. But in fact it's a rare, specialized mode of thought. The primary mode of thought -- the one that keeps us from making big mistakes for a half-minute at a time -- is that irrational one that's very easy to fool if you put effort into it, but which actually gets it right for most of reality (which isn't, generally, trying to trick you).
- Animats 7y agoWhen we think-about-thinking, or talk-about-thinking, we do so in the language of language, which quickly leads to logic. And that leads us to think that the logic is the thinking. But in fact it's a rare, specialized mode of thought. Yes. Language is not thinking. Language is I/O.
- thedirt0115 7y agoWhat do you think about the language of thought hypothesis? Some people would say internal monologue is how they think.
- Animats 7y agoMost of the mammals have similar brains to humans, and some degree of common sense, but little language.
- Aperocky 7y agoAs a fully bilingual person, that is not always true. I can have internal monologue in both language. And then there are things I have trouble expressing naturally (Either internally or externally) using either.
- crazygringo 7y agoYes, that's essentially Whorfianism [1]. The easiest argument against it being: have you even struggled to put a feeling into words? The answer, of course, being yes. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_relativity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_relativity
- joe_the_user 7y agoAh, what you mean by "is" gets tricky. You might literally interpret this as "is internal monologue a form of thought" and the answer is clearly yes, on sum logical level, it's brain activity. You might literally interpret this as "is internal monologue the ONLY form of thought you have" and the answer seems just as clearly no and the question seems simplistic. But I think people who say that usually mean "is internal monologue the primary-in-some-way form of thought you have" and there the debate gets heated but if you reveal statement, you reveal the confusion is mostly in debating "what's primary in brain activity". But if you think about, lot of debates about human thought is about which part is primary in a fashion we can intuitively feel.
- beefield 7y agoMy thinking goes as follows: If language is how people think, then you should be able to convey your thoughts to pther people easily and perfectly by using language. Obviously, that is true for only the most trivial thoughts, thus I personally conclude that language has hardly anything to with actual thinking. Based on what I think goes around in my head when I think, I would say that language is one of the outputs of thinking. Which may happen as "internal speech",via mouth or pencil or keyboard.
- blotter_paper 7y agoThat might depend on what level of supervenience you're thinking about. We could imagine a neural network in which individual neurons communicate with one another over a REST API. Is the REST API I/O, or thinking? My view is that an individual is defined by the constriction of an interface, which is why a severed corpus callosum results in something of a second person inhabiting the same body and doing things that the vocal resident cannot account for (putting items in a shopping cart which the vocal resident does not desire, attempting to strangle the body, etc.). I believe that there are parts of the brain doing behind-the-scenes thinking that the vocal resident is unaware of even when the corpus callosum remains intact. Depending on how small of an interface we require to consider someone an individual we might decide that there are multiple individuals in every brain, or we might decide that connected networks of brains (through language or other means) can form an individual. The level of brains speaking to each other is just one level of supervenience which might not be more or less privileged than any other, simply a level that is useful for conducting human affairs. Language is message passing, and if we believe that no individual neuron thinks then message passing seems necessary for thinking.
- joe_the_user 7y agoLanguage is not thinking. Language is I/O Actually, I think the key thing is Language is not logic. People are great at simple logic statements and terrible at complex logic. A line of SQL with 1-2 predicates can indeed seem "easy and language like" but a line of SQL with 5-6 predicates can be utterly opaque, a beast that many programmers would be happy to write an entire 1000-line C program to avoid. I think a key failing of discussion of cause and effect, logic and so-forth is a failure to really come to terms with the multifaceted qualities of human language expression. And I'd agree with other posters that the distinction between I/O and thought can be debatable.
- wtvanhest 7y agoI have come to the determination that people are really good at understand, learn and explain two dimensional concepts and most people are good at understanding/learning/explaining 3 dimensional problems. After 3 dimensions it gets extremely hard and people quickly move to heuristics and short-cuts because most people (i.e. the vast majority including myself) can really only comprehend 3 dimensions of information. What happens when a human hand grabs and moves an object? At least 5 dimensions that I can think of: 1. x axis 2. y axis 3. z axis (i.e. 3 axis's just to get to the object) 4. grip strength 5. rotation Those 5 are the absolutely basic, and there are many others, speed, grip texture etc. I know engineers have programmed robotic hands to grab stuff, but I cannot imagine how many dimensions there are in unstructured problems. That requires engineers to think through so many dimensions, which seems impossible to me.
- tabtab 7y agoWe probably use habitual trial and error to train our biological neural net to perform our arm and hand movements rather than mathematical formulas. You can watch a baby experiment trying to grab and move items for hours a day. (Poor cat.)
- plzHireMeImGood 7y agothinking fast thinking slow?
- jfengel 7y agoI think so, or at least closely related phenomena. I was looking at somewhat different kinds of thinking than Kahneman is -- mine was, I think, more simplistic, basic deductions and Kahneman more about larger-scale cognitive jumps. But without having done an exhaustive study I suspect that yes, we were looking at the same distinction.