5 ms·
In the 1980s, when everybody was trying to do AI with some flavor of predicate calculus, he extended that to probabilistic predicate calculus. That helped. But
by Animats 7y ago
In the 1980s, when everybody was trying to do AI with some flavor of predicate calculus, he extended that to probabilistic predicate calculus. That helped. But it didn't lead to common sense reasoning. The field is so stuck that few people are even trying.
Working on common sense, defined as predicting what happens next from observations of the current state, is a classic AI problem on which little progress has been made. I used to remark that most of life is avoiding big mistakes in the next 30 seconds. If you can't do that, life will go very badly. Solving that problem is "common sense". It's not an abstraction.
The other classic problem where the field is stuck is robotic manipulation in unstructured situations. McCarthy once thought, in the 1960s, that it was a summer project to do that.
He wanted a robot to assemble a Heathkit TV set kit. No way. (The TV set kit was actually purchased, sat around for years, and finally somebody assembled it and put it in a student lounge at Stanford.) 50 years later, unstructured manipulation still works very badly. Watch the DARPA Humanoid Challenge or the DARPA Manipulation Challenge videos from a few years ago.
Great PhD thesis topics for really good people. High-risk; you'll probably fail. Succeed, even partially, and you have a good career ahead.
- jfengel 7y agoI worked on AI-via-predicate-calculus, as a successor to Cyc, and I think the main thing I learned is that people are incredibly bad at predicate calculus. Even when we behave "logically", it's an after-the-fact rationalization for a conclusion we arrived at much faster with heuristics. When we think-about-thinking, or talk-about-thinking, we do so in the language of language, which quickly leads to logic. And that leads us to think that the logic is the thinking. But in fact it's a rare, specialized mode of thought. The primary mode of thought -- the one that keeps us from making big mistakes for a half-minute at a time -- is that irrational one that's very easy to fool if you put effort into it, but which actually gets it right for most of reality (which isn't, generally, trying to trick you).
- Animats 7y agoWhen we think-about-thinking, or talk-about-thinking, we do so in the language of language, which quickly leads to logic. And that leads us to think that the logic is the thinking. But in fact it's a rare, specialized mode of thought. Yes. Language is not thinking. Language is I/O.
- thedirt0115 7y agoWhat do you think about the language of thought hypothesis? Some people would say internal monologue is how they think.
- Animats 7y agoMost of the mammals have similar brains to humans, and some degree of common sense, but little language.
- Aperocky 7y agoAs a fully bilingual person, that is not always true. I can have internal monologue in both language. And then there are things I have trouble expressing naturally (Either internally or externally) using either.
- crazygringo 7y agoYes, that's essentially Whorfianism [1]. The easiest argument against it being: have you even struggled to put a feeling into words? The answer, of course, being yes. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_relativity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_relativity
- joe_the_user 7y agoAh, what you mean by "is" gets tricky. You might literally interpret this as "is internal monologue a form of thought" and the answer is clearly yes, on sum logical level, it's brain activity. You might literally interpret this as "is internal monologue the ONLY form of thought you have" and the answer seems just as clearly no and the question seems simplistic. But I think people who say that usually mean "is internal monologue the primary-in-some-way form of thought you have" and there the debate gets heated but if you reveal statement, you reveal the confusion is mostly in debating "what's primary in brain activity". But if you think about, lot of debates about human thought is about which part is primary in a fashion we can intuitively feel.
- beefield 7y agoMy thinking goes as follows: If language is how people think, then you should be able to convey your thoughts to pther people easily and perfectly by using language. Obviously, that is true for only the most trivial thoughts, thus I personally conclude that language has hardly anything to with actual thinking. Based on what I think goes around in my head when I think, I would say that language is one of the outputs of thinking. Which may happen as "internal speech",via mouth or pencil or keyboard.
- plzHireMeImGood 7y agothinking fast thinking slow?
- jfengel 7y agoI think so, or at least closely related phenomena. I was looking at somewhat different kinds of thinking than Kahneman is -- mine was, I think, more simplistic, basic deductions and Kahneman more about larger-scale cognitive jumps. But without having done an exhaustive study I suspect that yes, we were looking at the same distinction.
- jmole 7y agoDo you think the challenge in unstructured manipulation tasks are more related to problems in AI, or more related to the incredibly primitive actuators we have at our disposal?
- p1esk 7y agopredicting what happens next from observations of the current state, is a classic AI problem on which little progress has been made How is "predicting what happens next" different from predicting, say, the next word in the sentence using modern DL models?
- RangerScience 7y agoHuh. I wonder if you setting up a board game might be an easier unstructured problem. If you've got experience with board games, you can usually figure out most of the rules by just looking at the pieces; where do the same symbols appear, and what other symbols appear with them? Still sounds super hard, but might be easier than the same (matching corresponding shapes) in 3D.
- vsareto 7y agoJust by going off the wikipedia page, this seems like a really hairy problem because of the definition We'd expect some kind of AI-human parity in avoiding obstacles while driving in common sense speak as "don't hit that, or you'll have a wreck", but we don't really expect the car AI to see a bad collision between two other cars on a perpendicular road and call emergency services (as should be common sense for humans). But if the cars involved in that collision have a detection system to automatically call 911 (any kind of OnStar variant), why should an AI concern itself with that knowing there is a system to handle that task? Would it be common sense for the AI to act as a parallel system and make sure the primary didn't fail to call 911? A human's common sense might be to act as if that system didn't exist because it might have failed and just call anyway (knowing that there's really no penalty for calling twice just to make sure)
- foxfired 7y agoHere is a video of the DARPA Humanoid Challenge from 2015 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8P9geWwi9e0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8P9geWwi9e0 If you compare these to Boston Dynamics, it is hard to watch. But to be fair, BD robots are remote controlled.
- gene-h 7y agoI wouldn't say that robotic manipulation in unstructured environments is exactly stuck, just progressing very slowly. There has been some progress since the DARPA Humanoid Challenge and Manipulation Challenge. Robots seem to be getting decent at picking things up[0][1], although manipulation is more than just picking things up. Although, robots still struggle with very basic tasks like motion planning. [0]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=geub-Nuu-Vw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=geub-Nuu-Vw [1]https://spectrum.ieee.org/automaton/robotics/artificial-intelligence/google-large-scale-robotic-grasping-project https://spectrum.ieee.org/automaton/robotics/artificial-inte...