8 ms·
Google, by thinking so short term, has knee-capped any developer and engineering good will for their platforms. Today's version of Microsoft is who Google shoul
by echelon 7y ago
Google, by thinking so short term, has knee-capped any developer and engineering good will for their platforms. Today's version of Microsoft is who Google should be right now, but somehow we wound up in a different timeline. Could you have imagined these roles switched back in 2005?
Imagine if someone comes along and takes away Google's search business? At this point, their results are such a trash fire it can't be that hard. And if that happens, they've got nothing, because they've been lazy and arrogant (or at least appear that way to an outside observer).
I'm long MSFT, but definitely not GOOG. It feels like the unhealthiest FAANG. Their culture is in turmoil, they rely on one product that can be duplicated, and they routinely spurn the rest of the world.
Edit: this might be my most controversial HN comment to date. It's constantly bouncing between 2 and -2.
- reaperducer 7y agoGoogle, by thinking so short term, has knee-capped any developer and engineering good will for their platforms. And yet, legions of HN'ers use and recommend Chrome, GMail, Google's Cloud offerings, Google Voice, GoogleFi, etc... I wonder if the problem is that there are no good alternatives to Big G, or if it's just some kind of mental disconnect.
- echelon 7y ago> legions of HN'ers use Every single one of those has an alternative. I'm using Firefox at home and Brave on mobile. I do need to replace Gmail. My primary inbox uses my own domain, so that won't be too hard if and when I decide to switch. Moreover, if Google lost search, how is it going to survive on those other products? Not one of them is special and doesn't have a competing offering available.
- beamatronic 7y agoI want great services, like email, and I’m willing to pay for them.
- reaperducer 7y agoTry FastMail and see if it suits you. $5/month. There's a free trial, too. I think it's 30 days. /Not affiliated with FastMail. I'm just someone who switched ~10 accounts from GMail to FastMail a year ago and am happier for it.
- shadowgovt 7y agoBut they're alternatives that don't interoperate without more work. That's the advantage an ecosystem offers.
- cheeze 7y agoAnd Dropbox had an alternative. Just grab an FTP account, curlftpfs, and SVN/CVS.
- Jaruzel 7y ago> And yet, legions of HN'ers use and recommend Chrome, GMail, Google's Cloud offerings, Google Voice, GoogleFi, etc... I don't think that's the prevalent view around here anymore tbh.
- eclipxe 7y agoYou have a handful of users that will jump on any anti-Google HN post and bandwagon. Don't take that to mean that's the prevalent view...
- mlazos 7y agoI agree with most of this, but why do you think it can be duplicated so easily? Is the reason they are so dominant now because they've built a moat around themselves? IMO if it can be duplicated it will, there's so much money at stake.
- bmelton 7y agoI think it's fair to say that any of Google's individual technologies can be replicated in fairly short order, but the problem is that the combined effect of Google's collective suite of tools is powerful. Yes, I can build a Gmail clone in a few months. No, I can't get Android Assistant to automatically read invitations from it, add them to my calendar, generate maps to the event on the fly, and tell me when I need to leave to avoid being late to get there. So yeah, it's a moat, and it's a pretty damned big one.
- closetohome 7y agoGoogle also has a lot of assets that are just too labor-intensive to replicate with any efficiency. Apple found that out when they tried to compete in Maps. And for all that Google indexes and initiates from their end, every SEO worker on earth also makes sure their client's sites are properly formatted and submitted. That kind of buy-in is reserved for companies that can demonstrate you'll get a return on your investment.
- d1zzy 7y ago> I think it's fair to say that any of Google's individual technologies can be replicated in fairly short order, but the problem is that the combined effect of Google's collective suite of tools is powerful. What? That makes no sense to me. There have been thousands of some of the smartest/highly skilled people (payed some of the highest salaries) in the industry building systems for decades, that's Google infrastructure today. How do you expect to replicate that quickly without similar investment in time and money? The hard to surmount "moat" is inherent to the tech and its demands. Just take the amount of dark fiber they have or the highly customized datacenter hardware and software stack and the sheer amount of them. Sure, you can replace all that with a smaller set of VMs using someone's "cloud services" but your margins, power use efficiency and scale will be much worse. That reminds me of a discussion with a Linux filesystem engineer: building a POSIX filesystem is easy, building a thread-safe highly scalable fast and efficient POSIX filesystem is hard. You can have a single operating systems student build a simple POSIX filesystem in one day but it takes year-hours of multiple highly experienced system engineers to get a production level filesystem.
- Andrew_nenakhov 7y agoMicrosoft has their own share of stories abandoning the developers. Remember Silverlight?
- tapoxi 7y agoA better (worse?) story is Windows Mobile 6.5, Windows Phone 7, Windows Phone 8, and Windows 10 Mobile all being completely different, incompatible platforms that deprecated the prior one, before they decided to give up and use Android.
- pjmlp 7y agoAnd yet UWP still lives on, and is being improved to be independent of the actual Window 10 version, and to have Win32 and UWP on the same process.
- gamblor956 7y agoNot comparable. Microsoft stopped selling phones with those systems long before they stopped supporting them. They didn't just "turn off the servers" on those devices like Google has done with Nest. My old WM 6.5 phone still worked the last time I played with it.
- tapoxi 7y agoThat's true, a better Microsoft analogue would be the Kin.
- gamblor956 7y agoI don't see how the Kin is comparable. It was killed after just 2 months by both Microsoft and Verizon (it's exclusive sales partner) due to poor sales. Microsoft and/or Verizon also offered full refunds to the dozen people who purchased the device after MS announced it would be shutting down the Kin servers.
- 7y ago
- paganel 7y agoThe market is pretty irrational at the moment, throwing trillions of dollars at almost everything with non-negative returns, and as such almost everything Google does as a company right at this moment doesn’t really matter for their share price, they’re too big not to attract buyers for their shares (I suspect mostly index funds).
- Despegar 7y ago>Imagine if someone comes along and takes away Google's search business? At this point, their results are such a trash fire it can't be that hard. This is not going to happen unless antitrust regulators deal with what reinforces Google's search market share: the distribution they buy with TAC (e.g Safari and Firefox) and what they get for free (Chrome) and close to free (Android). The antitrust remedy should be to separate Chrome and Android from Google and place a ban for some amount of time where they can't buy being the default. Tech people might have switched to Google because it was legitimately better than the competition, but you're still living in 2000 if you think that's how Google got big. There's a reason why the CEO of Google is someone who was responsible for building the moat around Search (Google Toolbar and Chrome).
- corporateslave5 7y agoThe tech company is rotting from the inside, no anti trust needed. Monopolies breed incompetence
- riku_iki 7y agowith such money stream it will take a long time to rot.
- achillesheels 7y agoThat’s a very short sighted approach which assumes humanity is glued to text based web crawling. The Internet is evolving in tandem with the abundance of rich media creating new opportunities for search queries. Yes, they are still rooted in symbolic transmission, but not in a 20 year old format.
- corporateslave5 7y agoYeah, I think open source nlp technology will eventually get good enough that replicating google search becomes easier. I’d give it five years before someone is nipping at their heals
- Guest0918231 7y ago> And if that happens, they've got nothing, because they've been lazy and arrogant Without search they would still have GMail, Maps, YouTube, Chrome, Android, and AdSense/Adwords. Surely that counts for something. That's the #1 email service, #1 navigation and mapping system, #1 video hosting website, #1 browser, #1 mobile phone platform, and #1 online advertising system. Then of course Cloud, Drive, Docs, Translate and all sorts of other services. I don't know how you can consider that nothing and being lazy. These are services used by most of us on a daily basis. It's an impressive and diverse group of products, and it would be very difficult to compete against any single one of them. > It feels like the unhealthiest FAANG Really? You think Netflix is in a stronger position? They're a single product that depends on the ever changing licensing from a variety of third-parties. What happens to Apple revenue without the iPhone and supporting services and products? Facebook and Instagram feel susceptible to falling out of fashion and not being cool. That's a scary business to bet on long term. It's also far easier to build a Facebook, Instagram, or WhatsApp clone compared to Google Search.
- corporateslave5 7y agoGMail, Maps, YouTube, Chrome, Android These products aren’t by themselves profitable, they just build the datasets used for advertising
- Guest0918231 7y agoThere is advertising on Google Maps and YouTube, and if I recall correctly, YouTube has been profitable in recent years, and I imagine Maps will be the same if it's not already. It's hard to find numbers online, but it seems like Maps generates about 10 billion in annual revenue, and YouTube 10-20 billion. For comparison, Netflix has 20 billion in annual revenue and 1-2 billion in annual profits. The person I was replying to said Google is the most unhealthy of the FAANG companies with nothing to show aside from search. But... one part of their "nothing" generates as much revenue as one of those FAANG companies. Google is one of my least favorite businesses, but I feel like everyone is downplaying their accomplishments and diversity.
- arcturus17 7y ago
- jayd16 7y agoI really disagree with your take. Google has been careless, not lazy. They'll start up projects on a whim and cancel them on a whim but they haven't been complacent.
- Spooky23 7y agoGoogle is like any other company. I think the HN angst is because folks attributed some sort of magical powers to them. Microsoft of all companies is even more bumbling and mercurial. They are where they are with respect to cloud today mostly due to dumb luck and in spite of their corporate strategy. There are dozens of Microsoft product shutdowns that have had similar or bigger impacts on customers.
- rchaud 7y agoThe number of times I see "do no evil" be quoted in HN posts about Google doing something contravening that borders on the absurd. It is a ridiculously simplistic phrase that Google execs themselves haven't referenced in nearly 15 years, a lifetime in tech company terms. Google's only real operating principle is "do no harm"...to the revenue-generating Google products. Everything else can and will be discarded at a moment's notice.
- gamblor956 7y agoThere are dozens of Microsoft product shutdowns that have had similar or bigger impacts on customers. Name 3 products that Microsoft has "shut down" with little to no warning. Microsoft has done a great job of sunsetting products. They give months, usually at least a year of warning that a product is being discontinued or deprecated, and continue supporting that product for another several years even after it is no longer available for sale. (Zune Music, for example, no longer works, but Microsoft didn't turn off the servers for Zune until 2015, 3 years after they stopped selling the devices, and refunded purchases made on the service. Zune devices still continue to work and it's still possible to get battery replacements for them.)
- Spooky23 7y agoSure: - Access for Office 365 - Windows 10 SCCM/MDM co-management - Health Vault I will say that Microsoft has historically had a more clearly defined release and support cadence for their products, and they clearly articulate options for end of life in most situations. That said, products like Windows 10 and red-haired stepchild products change often enough that they effectively lack a meaningful support strategy.
- yhoiseth 7y agoShameless plug: Feel free to add your bear forecast on https://www.empiricast.com/time-series/41 https://www.empiricast.com/time-series/41
- wtracy 7y ago> Google, by thinking so short term, has knee-capped any developer and engineering good will for their platforms. I can't see that hurting their already-established products, but I'm seeing even non-technical users get increasingly gun-shy about adopting new Google products. > At this point, their results are such a trash fire it can't be that hard. So far, the other search platforms seem to be even more of a trash fire. (Obviously, this is subjective.) The thing is, search gets harder every day: The number of bad actors polluting search grows. It's not fair to claim that declining search quality is proof that Google as an organization is declining in competence.
- manigandham 7y agoIt's just a conglomerate and has been run like one for the last decade. That whole "startup" culture died out a long time ago and has been overlooked because of people's nostalgia and the high pay and benefits. The company is still very profitable with several major product lines. It's far from dying and there's no 2nd place competition even close in the areas it dominates (search and advertising).
- pathartl 7y agoAnd in this specific instance, Microsoft is starting to roll out and market their Power Apps platform, as well as Power Automate. I'm not sure I know where Google is going, but I think they've decided they don't want to get into enterprise.
- d1zzy 7y ago> Imagine if someone comes along and takes away Google's search business? At this point, their results are such a trash fire it can't be that hard. And if that happens, they've got nothing, because they've been lazy and arrogant (or at least appear that way to an outside observer). How do you imagine that happening in practice? Say that someone comes with a competitor search that is overall better than Google search is right now. It won't be hugely better because Google search is pretty decent but even if it's significantly better it would have to so good that almost everyone cares enough to change their default search AND it would require that Google doesn't react to the new competition. With >100 billions of dollars in the treasure chest it seems extremely unlikely that Google wouldn't have the time and resources to react and improve their search engine in the face of true competition and they wouldn't even need to make it better than the competition, just make it good enough that's not worth for most people to switch. Also, creating a competing search engine isn't just a matter of secret juice and algorithms, it's mostly a matter of tons of network bandwidth, CPU, memory and storage. While I'm sure there are plenty of people outside of Google that can come up with brilliant new searching algorithms to actually make that into a successful product that matches the scale of Google's web products you'd need a lot of money and time.
- tjpnz 7y ago>Imagine if someone comes along and takes away Google's search business? I think DDG's going to give them a run for their money. In terms of relevance they seem to offer the superior product - at least in my own experience.