6 ms·
And what many overlook is many of these particles have nothing to do with emissions. Brake pads and tires turn to dust. So too bits of the road surface are sl
by sandworm101 7y ago
And what many overlook is many of these particles have nothing to do with emissions. Brake pads and tires turn to dust. So too bits of the road surface are slowly converted to fine particulates. Converting everyone to autodrive teslas powered by fusion reactors wont stop rubber from meeting asphalt.
(Switching to manual transmissions would probably reduce the brake dust. Id like to see if european roads suffer as much. Between automatic transmissions, weight, and some traction control schemes, NA cars chew through brake pads.)
- mrob 7y agoSwitching to electric vehicles would reduce brake dust even more, because they use regenerative breaking to avoid using the break pads when possible.
- murkt 7y agoAdditionally, roads can be designed in a way that calms vehicle movement instead of accelerate-brake cycle. For example, narrower roads with curves instead of wide straight roads with speed bumps near pedestrian crossings.
- sandworm101 7y agoCurves are just accelleration in a different direction. Tires would degrade just as quickly.
- thrwaway69 7y agoWouldn't that cause friction too? I feel like it might even increase braking more if it's a busy road and people want to move faster.
- Scoundreller 7y agoAt least newer automatics finally do engine braking as well.
- Jamwinner 7y agoAs well as all cars with manual transmissions.
- sandworm101 7y ago"Engine braking" isn't just letting the engine spin down at 0 throttle. Propper engine braking, aka "Jake brake", is letting the engine spin at 100% throttle but zero fuel input (and some valve trickery). This lets air in to be compressed, releasing it before the down stroke of the piston. No car does that. It is a separate installed system on trucks. It can be almost as powerful as the engine. In a car, it could handle all but emergency braking. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compression_release_engine_brake https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compression_release_engine_b... When you hear a truck making popping noises like a machine gun, that's the Jake brake in action.
- hamandcheese 7y ago> Engine braking occurs when the retarding forces within an engine are used to slow down a motor vehicle, as opposed to using additional external braking mechanisms such as friction brakes or magnetic brakes. > The term is often confused with several other types of braking, most notably compression-release braking or "jake braking" which uses a different mechanism. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Engine_braking https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Engine_braking
- sandworm101 7y agoBut when you see a sign saying "no engine braking" it refers to the jake brake, not down-shifting in a car. (It's a long trademark story over the use of "jake")
- saiya-jin 7y agoI have on my manual 15-year old diesel bmw very much an engine brake. It breaks quite well compared to neutral which seems to like to go on forever, and actually indicates proper consumption. On highways and motorways, I rarely need to use brake at all. Of course, being a sensible driver helps (in contrary to what many people expect from me when they see the car and expect yet another immature aggressive driver)
- woodpanel 7y agowhile switching to electric vehicles likely reduces break dust, such switch would simultaneously increase dust from tires, since increased acceleration. The latter being already 80% of urban "particulate matter" pollution.
- iguy 7y agoAnd weight, presumably heavy vehicles wear through more rubber, and batteries are heavy.
- brownbat 7y agoWeight. This is so much about vehicle weight. I think the heavier EVs hit a crossover point because of regenerative braking, but weight does set them back, that's one of the whole points of this study: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S135223101630187X https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S13522... This is a curve though. We could almost simplify the problem and only look at what heavy trucks generate and ignore all the cars completely, it'd be a non-crazy approximation.
- DenisM 7y agoI don’t think Nissan Leaf is particularly good at neck-breaking acceleration, and it probably outnumbers the drag-racing Teslas. Even then, a Tesla isn’t particularly speedy in traffic.
- Geeflow 7y agoI often drive a Renault Zoe which also isn't a sports car. I frequently leave sports cars behind at the traffic light. From 0-30 kph even the small/cheap electric cars are sport cars. And it is terribly tempting to develop a pedal-to-the-metal habit. So I assume tire dust will increase significantly in the cities.
- sandworm101 7y agoRate of acceleration isnt the issue. You may make more dust per second but so long as you are getting to the same end speed, and not spinning tires, the total amount of acceleration is the same. In my experience, over braking is the greater problem. Front tires degrade more quickly than rears. The average driver brakes far harder than they accelerate.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoA set of pads typically lasts about as long as a set of tires (at the very least they're within a factor of two of each other). Compare relative volumes of materials. Brake dust is always going to be a much smaller source of particulate matter in the air than tire dust. FWIW if the fumes/particulate from burning them are any indication tires are probably way nastier than brakes.
- samatman 7y agoFirst paragraph is perfectly reasonable. Second paragraph, though: I've never been around a brake pad fire, but I'd rather breathe vulcanized rubber than "metal shavings of copper, steel, graphite, and brass bonded with resin": https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/what-are-brake-pads-made-of https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/what-are-brake-pads-mad...
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoIn my non-chemist, non-doctor opinion the circumstantial evidence points to brake dust being way less bad than tire dust. Being inert in the presence of most common substances tends to correlate well with low toxicity. It's the stuff that chemically reacts to all sorts of things that tends to be the most poisonous. Tires break down over time under "normal earthly conditions" which includes a lot of the same temperatures and molecules that are found inside the human body. To me this is a massive red flag for toxicity. High temperature tends to make things react more readily. Most of the stuff in brakes has to be really stable at high temperatures and being stable at high temperatures tends to correlate well with being chemically inert. The most reactive stuff in brakes are the long complex molecules used to bind it all together. These sorts of molecules are similiar to the molecules used in tires and all sorts of other plastic like things. So all else being equal tires probably have more of the chemically interesting things that cause problems in the human body. Burning brakes smells way better than burning tires which seems to confirm this (remember, your nose has millions of years of incremental improvement when it comes to indicating what is and isn't suitable to ingest). And before anyone thinks they're gonna get some easy internet points by saying "but asbestos", the amount of asbestos in brake pads is nonzero (to account for the sketchy unbranded stuff that may or may not use it) but still tiny enough that people working in proximity to it have mostly stopped dropping dead at 60 thanks to lung cancer so I think that however much asbestos is in brake pads it's low enough to not be an issue from a public health POV. TL;DR I'll take my chances with brakes over tires.
- scythe 7y agoFrom slide 17 here you can see that the switch from fuelled to electric vehicles is expected to decrease particulates by 60-80% from 2000 to 2040: https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2015-09/documents/sbai_pres.pdf https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2015-09/documents... This doesn’t seem like a trivial improvement. Particulates are not the only toxic component of exhaust either; electric cars should produce no NOx, CO or O3 which is a big improvement. It’s also worth noting that brake wear particulates haven’t been a target because historically exhaust-related emissions were so much larger. If we haven’t really tried to fix it, who’s to say we can’t?
- iguy 7y agoThanks, and good point. It might not be very hard to reduce brake dust dramatically, just put a vacuum cleaner in your frunk right?
- derefr 7y agoTangential question: do trains produce fine particulates where their wheels meet the rail? I.e. is it bad to live near a train (or subway!) line?
- sandworm101 7y agoYes but far fewer. The metal turns to dust, but orders of magnitude less quickly than rubber/pads/road surface. The stuff carried by the trains is probably more dangerous than the train itself.
- johnwalkr 7y agoTrains do use brake shoes on the wheels, and in some cases disc brakes. All trains have mechanical braking capability, as far as I know. Many also have electric braking, especially passenger trains with frequent stops, which is either regenerative or dissipated as heat via resistors. Freight trains tend to use mechanical breaking, but have infrequent stops and can plan a long slow-down. In any case, the braking force has to be transmitted somehow to the wheels before it is transmitted to the rails. There is only rarely wheel on rail sliding outside of emergency situations. But, particulates of steel on steel sliding should be relatively benign. A good train system is better utilized compared to cars as well. All this is to say that yes, there are fine particulates from trains, but it should normally be much less than from living near a highway.
- rezgi 7y agoI remember from my days working for London Underground Ltd that whenever I'd blow my nose after a shift, my snot would have a concerning amount of black matter in it. The days I was off and not entering the subway, my snot didn't have this black particulate matter. I like to think it was my nose doing its job and keeping all that from entering my lungs, but I'll never know.
- Nasrudith 7y agoDumb question - how well would an attempt to suck in the particles work putting aside the obvious impracticality? There are currently tons of reasons not to do it today but could it theoretically be solved via clean and cheap energy to make the efficiency loss not a foregone self defeating act.
- joncrane 7y agoYou're asking people to use a much more expensive part (transmission) to reduce their speed. The days of using the transmission to slow down are over. Brakes are better and more reliable (and cheaper) than ever.