4 ms·
It's an interesting way of thinking of the age of the earth and geological changes that there could have been a civilization and we wouldn't know. Or someone l
by duxup 7y ago
It's an interesting way of thinking of the age of the earth and geological changes that there could have been a civilization and we wouldn't know.
Or someone later wouldn't know about us.... outside say an abandoned car floating through space...
That would be an interesting story. We travel into space to find things out there only to find things that seem to have come from... home.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoWill our geostationary satellites still be there, say, 50 million years from now? The lunar landers probably will be, unless meteorites take out all the landing sites.
- duxup 7y agoMy understanding is that I would expect there would be some left, albeit maybe more debris after their orbits slowly become more erratic (not as coordinated regarding other satellites) and collisions and failures occur.
- marcosdumay 7y agoThey will be somewhere around Earth. But not on the orbits they are now. They won't be hard to spot. I guess the most pressing evidence is that nobody used the fossil fuels before us (at least in large quantities), and a lot of it is from the time that plants first colonized the dry soil.
- philipodonnell 7y agoMaybe they found something better than fossil fuels and used it all up. Or were smarter about the impact to the climate would be if they burned it.
- npo9 7y agoOr maybe there was a whole lot more fossil fuel in the past.
- marcosdumay 7y agoWe have some very good explanations for the distribution of fossil fuels, with a lot of predictive power. They would all be trash of some thinking being decided to take some of it our.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoBut if some being had decided to take some of it, we could still have explanations that seemed good to us and that fit the distribution of what we found. And we would use the match between the theory and the actual distribution to confirm that the explanations were correct.
- marcosdumay 7y agoThey would take the easy to extract fuels first. But it was still there, distributed the same way as the hard to extract stuff. If somebody got it before us, they must have got very little of it.
- hoorayimhelping 7y ago>Or someone later wouldn't know about us.... outside say an abandoned car floating through space... The cars we left on the moon will still be there. The satellites and trash in orbit would still be there. The satellites orbiting Mars would still be there. We can see clear evidence that life has altered the climate in the past [1]. Anyone looking like we are would notice our mark on the environment. 1) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxidation_Event https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxidation_Event
- zaroth 7y agoAre satellite orbits really stable over millennia? Maybe just the geo-sync ones, but I imagine anything closer will decay in “relatively short order”.
- zamadatix 7y agoDepends what you consider "closer". Geosynchronous orbit is 35,786 km above the surface and while at 500 km you get significant decay (order of years to re-entry) while satellites at 1,000 km are estimated to take centuries to re-enter. Extrapolating that anything above the start of medium earth orbit (2,000 km) and out should last a hell of a long time.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dredmorbius 7y agoInteresting question, and not one I'm finding ready answers to. Among the better: https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/5583/can-an-artificial-satellite-stay-in-orbit-forever https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/5583/can-an-artifi... Low-Earth orbits will decay over periods ranging from years to millennia, based on residual air resistance. Those effects are minimal in geosynchronous orbit, though there's still some residual atmospheric drag which might be significant over millions to billions of years. The period under concern is roughly 5 billion years, at which point the Sun will have ballooned to a red giant, enveloping the Earth. (Increased solar radiance, as well as various cycles and changes on Earth will likely have long made it uninhabitable by life within the next 800 million years or so.) Other effects include solar wind, possible interactions with the Earth's magnetic field, precessional effects caused by the Earth's axial tilt and irregular geometry (to use that word in its literal sense), as well as gravitational perturbation from the Moon and possibly other bodies within the solar system. There's a slight possibility of impacts, though those would be highly unlikely -- space is big, as Doug said, and satellites tiny. Even the Earth only gets wallopped every few tens of millions of years. Though any such impacts might create a sufficient debries field within the orbital zone to affect other satellites. The Geostationary band itself is quite narrow, and preferential placement is above the equator, which would focus placement for potential interaction.
- ttoinou 7y agoIt's an interesting way of thinking of the age of the earth and geological changes that there could have been a civilization and we wouldn't know In science fiction there's the very good Planet of Apes novel about that :)