6 ms·
This may be a major event in Google's history - the point where they overdid ads and started to be perceived as a inferior service. This is sometimes called "pu
by Animats 7y ago
This may be a major event in Google's history - the point where they overdid ads and started to be perceived as a inferior service. This is sometimes called "pulling a Myspace".
Myspace was once the top social network. They looked unchallengeable. Then they got greedy. Myspace kept upping their ad content until usage dropped. Instead of backing off the ads, they upped the ad content even more to maintain revenue. Usage dropped further. That death spiral ended with Myspace irrelevant.
- olalonde 7y agoI'd say the customizable CSS was worse than the ads (search for "ugly myspace pages" in Google Images).
- toastal 7y agoThat was actually the most interesting part of MySpace. Sure, you could get bad designs, but there was an ability to express one's self that you can't do beyond the header image--much like the amateur GeoCities aesthetic we admire. MySpace and GeoCities were why and where I started to learn CSS.
- IshKebab 7y agoDefinitely. MySpace was killed because Facebook was superior. And Facebook was superior because it didn't look like shit, people used real names and real photos of themselves, and they did that because it was only available to university students so it was quite a bit more private than MySpace. It didn't really have anything to do with ads.
- onion2k 7y agoThere are tens of thousands of people who first learned to code by customising their MySpace page. They might have made some seriously ugly stuff but that feature was amazing for getting people in to the tech industry. It was brilliant.
- hadlock 7y agoIn the early 2000s we called this "Jumping the Shark"
- Siemer 7y ago"Pulling a MySpace" means messing up your product so badly that your users abandon ship. "Jumping the Shark" means taking your story to such incredible heights that it becomes unbelievable. Not the same thing.
- sethammons 7y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jumping_the_shark https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jumping_the_shark Nothing to do with being believable. More to do with being gimmicky and irrelevant.
- gundmc 7y agoEarly 2000s? "Jumping the shark" is from the 1970s.
- product50 7y agoNothing like this is going to happen. Google Search is leaps and bounds ahead beyond anything else. And Google Assistant on top of this makes it even more effective. This was a mistake by Google and they heard the feedback and corrected it. MySpace analogy doesn't make sense since there is no Facebook, which was a competent social network, here. Search is a massive investment and you don't just have random companies suddenly rising taking over the users. Duckduckgo itself uses Bing Search as its backend.
- drno123 7y agoI disagree about search result quality. I switched to DDG over a year ago and only need to use !g bangs when I search either for some specific local stuff or when I search for news that have happened in the last day or two. Actually, in some cases DDG gives more relevant search results than Google, especially for programming stuff.
- apatters 7y ago+1 for having zero issues at all with using DDG as my daily driver, I only use Google for some local searches and currency conversions. DDG results have improved every year even as Google's have gotten much worse. Edit: just realized that DDG does currency conversion too, there's one less class of searches that goes to Google!
- vic-traill 7y agoI concur. I only occasionally use !g w/ DDG now, whereas two years ago it was more frequent (although I can't quantify). I stuck w/ it as I wanted some distance between myself and Google. Whether I've achieved any distance is an open question and I suspect that it is less than it feels like when I use DDG. The results are comparable in my current experience. Compage searches for 'bluetooth speakers' on Google [0] and DDG [1]. In my location (Canada) DDG returns national results which are preferred and relevant. I like that on the DDG results page the ad is clearly separated from organic results and I get the results w/out a mapping insert. That's just my preference, though. Even the results URLs speak volumes. I have no idea what data - if any - I'm exposing about myself w/ the Google result. [0] https://www.google.ca/search?source=hp&ei=KyUsXtPGIIGL5wKRx7OYDg&q=bluetooth+speakers&oq=bluetooth+speakers&gs_l=psy-ab.3..0l10.1203.5693..6226...0.0..0.113.1277.17j1......0....1..gws-wiz.......0i131.6l0tVnNAqTY&ved=0ahUKEwiTiK7R0Z7nAhWBxVkKHZHjDOMQ4dUDCAg&uact=5 https://www.google.ca/search?source=hp&ei=KyUsXtPGIIGL5wKRx7... [1] https://duckduckgo.com/?q=bluetooth+speakers&ia=shopping https://duckduckgo.com/?q=bluetooth+speakers&ia=shopping
- spiderfarmer 7y agoAs an Adsense publisher, I noticed they enabled ‘Auto ads’ on every website, automatically. What this does is it plasters 15 ads in a long web page, it adds interstitials to mobile page and it just fucking ruins your websites UX. It’s enabled on millions of websites now. It’s like Google is desperate to make more money. I can disable it, for now. I won’t be surprised if at some point in the future, they make it the standard and only behavior.
- Ididntdothis 7y ago“It’s like Google is desperate to make more money.” It’s getting exponentially harder to achieve their expected growth rates. They haven’t managed to find another significant revenue source beside ads so they have to squeeze everything out of that. Kind of sad that all the super smart people there still haven’t come up with any product they can sell with enough revenue besides ads.
- BurningFrog 7y agoGoogle search+ads are a once in a generation in the world phenomenon. It's not at all strange they can't just pop out a few more of those.
- zaroth 7y agoThose interstitials are horrific. And they are on so many sites now. Google deserves as much condemnation for introducing those as it does for the recent redesign. I think most people don’t realize it’s Google’s fault and blame the sites. Thank you the comment. It explains so much of how the Internet has gotten markedly worse in the last couple months. These “auto” AdWords are totally overwhelming and awful.
- spiderfarmer 7y ago> I think most people don’t realize it’s Google’s fault and blame the sites. Absolutely. That's how I noticed what 'Auto Ads' really did. People thought my site was infected by malware and contacted me with screenshots.
- thebruce87m 7y agoI think “Pulling a Digg” is more apt. The change to digg was abrupt and user jumped ship immediately.
- superasn 7y agoThe only thing in favor of Google is that so far nobody still hasn't got a better engine. Creating a Myspace clone or even a better service wasn't as hard as making a better search engine as google. I've tried all the alternatives ddg, bing etc but the Google's results are still much better imo and as long as that is true they will keep trying such shenanigans.