4 ms·
> As weirdly counterintuitive as it feels to acknowledge, human beings are not naturally predisposed to think of life in terms of seconds and hours, of how they
by sneak 7y ago
> As weirdly counterintuitive as it feels to acknowledge, human beings are not naturally predisposed to think of life in terms of seconds and hours, of how they might be optimised.
Other merits of this article aside, it always perplexes me that the works of man are somehow regarded as outside or in opposition to “nature”, as if an atomic clock with seconds display is somehow less natural than a beaver’s dam.
Both are entirely natural processes, produced by and within natural systems.
- kilroy_jones 7y agoYou're right that they're natural processes, but they aren't natural to us. Our bodies naturally respond the day and night cycle, and even the seasons. By naturally, I mean at a chemical/genetic level. The breaking of a day into hours/minutes and such is an abstraction of these, and doesn't have a physiological basis as far as I'm aware.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoI assume because nearly all the works of man are aiming to control and suppress nature. Instead of the natural untidy beauty of an ancient forest, or wild meadow, with random animal and human tracks through it, we pave, concrete and "neaten". Everything tends to a boring concreted monoculture, with straight lines and walls or fences everywhere, such that even parks are a poor second to the natural world -- though if I ever find myself in a city they are a blessed relief even knowing they are the ersatz second best. It is almost unheard of to work with nature, to produce sustainable, sympathetic houses and cities that are a part of the natural world. The nearest we get is an occasional designer rendering of a sustainable city of the future... A future just about everyone fights hard to ensure never arrives, and we get the sad, brutal ugliness of the city. We could have both. Without much difficulty.
- sneak 7y agoIs a beaver dam an effort to control and suppress nature, or is it part of nature itself? So are the works of man.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoOnly with a completely new definition of the word. Oxford: nature [mass noun] The phenomena of the physical world collectively, including plants, animals, the landscape, and other features and products of the earth, as opposed to humans or human creations. Where in nature, outside human creations, can I find an airliner, or even a fence? A beaver dam involves no human activity so is of nature. By stretching the definition only a little, one might consider a log cabin and other buildings that use natural materials to be of nature, or at least sympathetic -- wood, stone, earth based, but certainly not steel. Once you distance yourself via fossil fuel, tools, rules of physics or chemistry and highly complex industrial manufacturing processes the claim becomes absurd. A 3d printer, airliner, drug production or an atomic clock cannot be part of nature -- they exist only through the confluence of man and fossil fuel.
- sn41 7y agoI guess instead of "natural", if you say "inherently biological" or "circadian" it conveys the sense better. I think the author intends to refer to the natural cycles inherent within the human body without the aid of devices. In that sense, sunlight and the day-night cycle, and the cycle of seasons may be a better indicator since they have a large enough effect on the human body even in the absence of other mechanical aids.
- allovernow 7y agoWe evolved the ability to think past our instincts, but not yet the ability to totally suppress or control them, generally. That is a source of conflict, particularly when we build technology that, though useful and/or pleasurable, is frequently at odd with our long term mood and health. This is the unnatural/natural divide when it comes to human engineering. Think of it as hacking the human psyche, vs living closer to the primitives we evolved from. Don't forget that the human brain has existed for an exceedingly small amount of time in proportion to life overall; but many of our primitive psychological and physiological functions are many millions of years old.
- partyboat1586 7y agoYes technically everything on this planet is natural including the creations of man. Unfortunately this is not a particularly useful definition of the word. When we talk about natural what we mean is the systems of the planet that have been around a lot longer than the tiny slice of time since civilization emerged. Things that evolved rather than things that were conceived. Things there due to instinct rather than rational thought and planning. Words exist to draw boundaries, something cannot exist without its opposite. If everything is natural then what is unnatural? If your answer is nothing then you have discovered non duality which is fascinating but has no practical value. The practical value of defining what is natural is to understand our impact on the world and what that means for the future of the planet.