4 ms·
> we know for a fact that we are getting gravity wrong This statement is way, way too strong. We have a theory of gravity, General Relativity, which has had it
by pdonis 7y ago
> we know for a fact that we are getting gravity wrong
This statement is way, way too strong. We have a theory of gravity, General Relativity, which has had its predictions confirmed by countless experiments, in some cases to thirteen or fourteen decimal places. That is not "getting it wrong".
Many physicists believe that GR, as well confirmed as it is, can't be the final fundamental theory of gravity because it's not a quantum theory. But nobody has yet found a quantum theory of gravity that (a) is consistent with the rest of quantum mechanics, and (b) makes experimental predictions that have been confirmed. Unless and until both (a) and (b) are done, the claim that we are "getting it wrong", even in the restricted sense of not having a final fundamental theory of gravity, because GR isn't a quantum theory is just speculation and might itself be wrong. It should certainly not be stated with the confidence you are stating it.
- mnl 7y agoNow, why am I seeing this factual comment in grey? See here for instance a popsci take on the problem: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/is-gravity-quantum/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/is-gravity-quantu... Everybody expects a quantum theory of gravitation, but if we were drawing it from scratch no one would make it that weak. It is a difficult problem, people work in string theory because you can get Einstein's equations from strings and the alternatives look indeed worse. I don't think that means GR is a wrong take on gravitation, it's more like an amazing one to begin with.
- opless 7y agoIt's grey because someone in their infinite wisdom downvoted you. Most likely because they'd rather downvote rather than challenge your statement. It's a worrying trend.
- JackRabbitSlim 7y agoGR is no more or less wrong than Newtonian physics.
- flatline 7y agoIANAP but I’m reasonably confident in asserting that GR is less wrong than Newtonian gravity, based on each models’ predictive power.
- pdonis 7y ago> GR is no more or less wrong than Newtonian physics. Then why does GR make more accurate predictions?
- hudon 7y agoAt low speeds relative to the speed of light, they have the same accuracy don't they? And in that case, the Newton model is simpler so more useful. At high speeds, it becomes inaccurate and then you need the other model. So there is no global "right" or "wrong", just different measures of usefulness depending the problem constraints.
- Supermancho 7y ago> At low speeds relative to the speed of light, they have the same accuracy don't they? When measuring signal (ie radio, light, gravity) from slow speed perspectives, newtonian physics is not as accurate - https://futurism.com/newtonian-physics-vs-special-realtivity https://futurism.com/newtonian-physics-vs-special-realtivity - Eg we actually need to account for it between gps sattelites and we do so from the perspective of GR as well as the recent evidence of gravity propogation being restricted to localization (ie roughly the speed of light)
- hudon 7y agoYup. And when you need to measure where artillery shells land, the GR model is overkill and you'll waste less time by using a Newtonian prediction. I think this proves my point?
- kyralis 7y ago"Newtonion physics is a perfectly acceptable approximation in many circumstances" and "GR is less wrong than Newtonion physics" are not in conflict. Newtonion physics can absolutely be "more wrong" and "useful in many circumstances" at the same time- and in fact is!
- trhway 7y ago>(a) is consistent with the rest of quantum mechanics i think we're on a right way in general : QM -> GR : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_gravity#Quantum_mechanics_and_general_relativity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_gravity#Quantum_mechan... " In particular, contrary to the popular claim that quantum mechanics and general relativity are fundamentally incompatible, one can demonstrate that the structure of general relativity essentially follows inevitably from the quantum mechanics of interacting theoretical spin-2 massless particles (called gravitons)" GR -> QM : We did observed gravitational waves of GR. A force field with waves mediating that force interactions - that requires just a bit of math to "quantize" it. It is a bit more complicated when classic EM -> QM because of added complication of non-stationary spacetime and just vastly different scales of spacetime/energy to run the experiments to establish/verify the gravitons parameters. For the "true deep" nature of graviton I subscribe to the view that - given gravitational force not being the "real" force and the gravitational waves being really a ripples of spacetime - graviton is more like phonon, ie. quasi-particle from the point of view of QM/SR theories.
- pdonis 7y ago> one can demonstrate that the structure of general relativity essentially follows inevitably from the quantum mechanics of interacting theoretical spin-2 massless particles (called gravitons) While this is technically true, it doesn't help much, since the quantum theory described is not considered a viable candidate for a fundamental theory of gravity for a number of reasons. > We did observed gravitational waves of GR. A force field with waves mediating that force interactions We have observed classical gravitational waves. We are many, many orders of magnitude away from being able to measure any possible quantum properties of those waves. > that requires just a bit of math to "quantize" it Math (more than "a bit") can quantize it in theory. But theory is not enough. We would actually have to observe the quantum properties experimentally to confirm the theory.
- trhway 7y ago>We would actually have to observe the quantum properties experimentally to confirm the theory. While not directly quantum properties of gravitational waves yet, we've already observed quantization of gravitational potential (and that naturally suggests "gravitational quantas" at least by similar machinery as with EM->QM) - at small scales/energies when the spacetime curvature can be not paid attention to, the gravity potential of an ultra-cold neutron quantizes just nice using the Schrodinger equation in full agreement with experimental observation - https://www.physi.uni-heidelberg.de/Publications/dipl_krantz.pdf https://www.physi.uni-heidelberg.de/Publications/dipl_krantz... . In my view, giving the amount of clarity in gravitation as well as in QM that experiment produced, it is worth of a Nobel.
- kanzenryu2 7y agoWe also have the flyby anomaly where multiple space probes flying past the earth do not exactly match the predictions of GR. So is GR therefore falsified? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flyby_anomaly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flyby_anomaly
- monadic2 7y agoThere could be unaccounted mass (dark matter) or magnified sensor error, just off the top of my head. Lots of ways to interpret this result.
- ksaj 7y agoThe predictions are based on what we know is out there, and how we would expect it all to react with us simultaneously. So as long as we have it exactly understood and haven't missed anything whatsoever, then yes, it would be therefore falsified. But we can't make such a claim. I haven't really seen science work that way, since it isn't all that often we base our expectations solely on things we can completely account for. Science necessitates a certain amount of calculated projection. Theories are adjusted as new details are discovered, and only fools entertain themselves by resisting the bigger leaps needed to make actual discoveries.
- kanzenryu2 7y agoI'm not quite sure what you meant in the 2nd para. But I find it interesting that multiple probes showed the same effect. It's so compelling I wish they would send some missions specifically to test this even more precisely. The obvious parallel was https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pioneer_anomaly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pioneer_anomaly which was finally solved. But who know at this point? Personally I think GR has to be "wrong", since it conflicts with QM, and if the 20th century showed us anything it's that QM alway wins.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> Many physicists believe that GR, as well confirmed as it is, can't be the final fundamental theory of gravity because it's not a quantum theory. But nobody has yet found a quantum theory of gravity that (a) is consistent with the rest of quantum mechanics It was my (lay) impression that we believe general relativity cannot be the final fundemental theory of gravity because general relativity itself is not consistent with quantum mechanics. Whether general relativity is a quantum theory or not is beside the point; we want to have a theory -- any theory -- that is consistent with itself. Right now we have two separate theories (general relativity / quantum mechanics) that can't be combined because they conflict with each other. Obviously, that in itself doesn't prove that the problem is in the theory of gravity, but it does prove the problem is either in the theory of gravity or the theory of quantum mechanics, and we have to be getting one of them wrong.
- pdonis 7y ago> It was my (lay) impression that we believe general relativity cannot be the final fundemental theory of gravity because general relativity itself is not consistent with quantum mechanics. That's the same as "not a quantum theory", which is what I was saying. "Consistent with quantum mechanics" requires "is a quantum theory", according to the many physicists I was referring to. > Right now we have two separate theories (general relativity / quantum mechanics) that can't be combined because they conflict with each other. Most physicists believe that they conflict, yes. But not all. Freeman Dyson, for example, has speculated that gravity might just be different and not require a quantum theory the way the other interactions do.
- ncmncm 7y ago> the problem is either in the theory of gravity or the theory of quantum mechanics, and we have to be getting one of them wrong. Not true: we could also be getting them both wrong.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoThere is no way to be getting both of them wrong but not be getting one of them wrong.