5 ms·
The US, like other countries, do not want to set 'bad' precedents on diplomatic immunity. Afaik she had diplomatic immunity and despite the speeches on both sid
by mytailorisrich 7y ago
The US, like other countries, do not want to set 'bad' precedents on diplomatic immunity. Afaik she had diplomatic immunity and despite the speeches on both sides the US will never extradite her because of the precedent that would set.
In addition, in her case I suspect they also want to avoid any disclosure of the activities of her husband.
The point actually also (or especially) applies in the UK: If she did have diplomatic immunity then what is the basis to prosecute (or even just sue) her in the UK?
- raxxorrax 7y agoProcecuting a foreign citizen that helped uncover war crimes is by all measures of a sane mind a much worse precedent. And that even while accounting for the "what goes around comes around"-rules of diplomacy.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoBoth the Foreign Office and the US State Department appeared to accept that she no longer had diplomatic immunity, and she wasn't a registered diplomat anyway -- she was the Intelligence officer's wife. Or at least that's what the Foreign Secretary was claiming at the tail end of last year. The surprise is either of them getting immunity for an airbase intelligence role outside London in the first place. I've seen several reports questioning whether the immunity was valid at all. But having returned to the USA there is no longer any immunity. A crime is still there to be investigated and prosecuted, an extradition could proceed. Additionally US-UK extradition agreements both under Thatcher and later under Blair have been notable for their imbalance, but that seems rather academic here. A balanced discussion of the issues underlying: https://www.diplomacy.edu/blog/sacoolas-affair-diplomatic-immunity-or-special-immunity https://www.diplomacy.edu/blog/sacoolas-affair-diplomatic-im...
- mytailorisrich 7y agoThey said that diplomatic immunity was no longer relevant. Which was a way to tell us that it did not matter anymore because she was in the US and the US would not extradite her. > But having returned to the USA there is no longer any immunity. An extradition could proceed. They are claiming that for political reasons. That way it is up to the US to refuse extradition, which they obviously and predictably have, and be the 'bad guys'. The reality is that both governments knew full well from the start that nothing would happen to her the instant she left the UK. The reality is not popular with British public opinion so they are posturing.
- secfirstmd 7y ago"airbase intelligence role outside London" There are lots of US bases outside London that conduct US intelligence gathering - e.g RAF Menwith Hill.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoWhich don't have everyone running on diplomatic plates, or actual diplomats. For a diplomatic cover, usually something for missions in unfriendly and hostile states, (shades of Cold War le Carré here) it would be for staff at the embassy -- which is in London. So the airbase would have to be considered a branch or part of the London embassy under the Vienna Convention. Yet Menwith Hill and Croughton etc are supposedly RAF bases militarily shared under NATO deals. Hence all the controversy currently coming out of the woodwork, and numerous articles quoting QCs and ministers disputing the validity at all, or considering it abuse of Vienna, including the exploration piece I linked above. IANAL. :)
- seanhunter 7y agoFirstly she was not a diplomat so it seems difficult to claim diplomatic immunity. Secondly, the US have already established a precedent that seems very relevant to this where they claimed that a foreign national did not have diplomatic immunity relating to a much less serious traffic offense https://autos.yahoo.com/owner-of-beverly-hills-laferrari-does-not-have-129289165617.html?guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly9lbi53aWtpcGVkaWEub3JnLw&guce_referrer_sig=AQAAAK1NqrLbgTxJUcUGZ8lfnv0khDpks2MIY4v2trvzyyFMTHh1L3ADrcuTL0vMXCXylUT34Q-idCANWw3piSklv98uIqrZzVyMmCufzh8euqtV_fi6qTz9wfJUufP19-wbtUUTaR-FLD1Lq2XZa-jqoWWxwxn3DV6ukDBVxEfzf5vU https://autos.yahoo.com/owner-of-beverly-hills-laferrari-doe...
- LanceH 7y agoDiplomatic immunity typically covers families. The point of immunity is that a diplomat (or their family or staff) can't be arrested and threatened with the law in order to influence the diplomatic process. Thus it is really a matter of whether her husband was legitimately working as someone with immunity. Everyone says no. But if it's something like the CIA involved, event the UK gov't may only be going through motions of outrage for appearances and not trying to actually win an extradition.
- goatinaboat 7y agoBut he was not a diplomat. He was working at an Air Force base, not the embassy!
- greatpatton 7y agoI think that you don't fully understand the concept underlying diplomatic immunity. Diplomatic immunity exists to ensure that countries cannot use the local legal system when no crime is committed in order to put pressure on the diplomat or his family, not to go away when a real crime is committed. A lot of countries will wave diplomatic immunity when a real crime is committed or will prosecute the diplomat in their local legal system. The only countries refusing to do so are rogue or third world countries.
- commoner 7y ago> The only countries refusing to do so are rogue or third world countries. The U.S. has failed to waive diplomatic immunity in a number of reckless/drunk driving cases. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diplomatic_immunity#Vehicular_assault_and_drunk_driving https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diplomatic_immunity#Vehicular_...
- FpUser 7y ago"The only countries refusing to do so are rogue or third world countries." I wish people consult at least wikipedia when making claim. In this particular area "good" US looks worse than "bad" Russia which at least criminally charged the offender once he had been sent back to Russia. The US does stand up for its citizens which is a nice quality but on the other hand it goes overboard in many cases.
- greatpatton 7y agoyes that's exactly what I'm saying... (puzzled)
- ceejayoz 7y agoThere's already precedent for revoking diplomatic immunity for one's own diplomats. It's fairly rare, but very doable.
- goatinaboat 7y agoIf she did have diplomatic immunity then what is the basis to prosecute (or even just sue) her in the UK? If you do something that is a crime usually sentenced to >1 year in both countries, then diplomatic immunity does not apply. Source: BBC Also to have diplomatic immunity you must be an accredited diplomat agreed by the host country before entering. She was not.
- mytailorisrich 7y ago> If you do something that is a crime usually sentenced to >1 year in both countries, then diplomatic immunity does not apply. That's not the case. If it was then bypassing the Vienna Convention would be straightforward. In the UK foreign diplomats commonly avoid prosecution for serious crimes because they are protected if their home country refuses to waive immunity. > Also to have diplomatic immunity you must be an accredited diplomat agreed by the host country before entering. She was not. It does not matter as family members are covered. What matters is whether her husband had diplomatic immunity. In any case, diplomatic immunity is a moot point at this stage since she was quickly 'exfiltrated' and the US have made clear that they won't send her back.
- shadowgovt 7y agoShe's not a diplomat.