3 ms·
While he is right I think Bruce is also missing the point here himself: he states that this law is the wrong way to fight surveillance – but that is not the st
by atoav 7y ago
While he is right I think Bruce is also missing the point here himself: he states that this law is the wrong way to fight surveillance – but that is not the stated goal of the law.
The goal of the law is to prevent the development of a technical reality in Europe, to which a Jurisdiction can only passively react. The technical space moves so fast at times, that reality has been made before the law can even start to think about what is okay and what isn't.
This time they wanted to say: "Yeah it is a shiny new thing, that would definitly come if the law stayed as it was, but it is such a hairy ball of mud that we ban it till we figured out what is allowed." Or phrased differently: it is so obvious for them that this is prone to abuse, they ban it first and then figure out how to deal with it in an adequate fashion.
So Bruce' idea that the goal was to fight surveillance is a tad bit to optimistic in my eyes..
- icebraining 7y agoI don't really agree, and in fact I think the EU already has a pretty good proactive law, in the form of the GDPR. You can't use indiscriminate facial recognition, gait recognition, or any other such mechanism if you need individual consent to process any data related to a person. That said, specific bans for cases that the GDPR doesn't cover might still make sense. But we should be careful about de-fanging it by making it seem that any technology not specifically banned is fair game.
- eivarv 7y agoConsent isn't the only grounds for processing, though.
- tshadley 7y ago> The goal of the law is to prevent the development of a technical reality Facial recognition in the brain is just specialized object recognition, therefore any research on powerful general-purpose object recognition via deep-neural-networks is improving facial recognition technology whether it means to or not. Only a law banning all artificial neural network research seems to have a chance at stopping the technical reality here.
- fauigerzigerk 7y ago>The technical space moves so fast at times, that reality has been made before the law can even start to think about what is okay and what isn't. In general I think this is exactly how it should work. You cannot stop all technological developments early on and make rules for imagined problems that may or may not arise. Imagine it's 1995. The Web gets banned for five years so that a government committee can meet to figure out what could possibly go wrong with that technology. There are always groups that stand to lose when new technologies are introduced. And these groups are inevitably very powerful at the beginning of any new development. You can be pretty sure that nothing would go ahead without great resistance. That said, we have to find a balance. Of course there are technologies that are so dangerous that they must be regulated fairly early on. Making some rules for face recognition and similar technologies seems entirely sensible to me. But as a general principle I think problems should be solved when they arise. Solving imagined problems before they arise is impossible and prone to misuse of power and influence.
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> Imagine it's 1995. The Web gets banned for five years so that a government committee can meet to figure out what could possibly go wrong with that technology. Fortunately we already know what can go wrong with facial recognition technology. We have China, and we have American and Israeli and various Asian marketing startups inventing abuse after abuse after abuse. So there is already a test bed in place; it doesn't have to be the entire world. As a general principle, it may not be a bad idea itself. Let a part of the world play with the new toys and other part observe, after that either the tech will be exported to holdouts (the control group, if you like), or the regulations will be exported to the experimenters.
- _carl_jung 7y agoBut the context in those countries is too different to ours to come to any meaningful conclusion about what should be allowed "here" (I'm assuming UK + US mainly).
- varjag 7y ago
- lbarrow 7y agoI think this article was written a few days before the EU memo was leaked. He doesn't mention the EU in it.
- amelius 7y ago> The technical space moves so fast at times, that reality has been made before the law can even start to think about what is okay and what isn't. I think lawmakers should watch more dystopian science fiction movies.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoI think it's hard for most people to tell apart cheap nonsense sci-fi for one in which the vision is plausible. E.g. there are many reasons to be concerned about human-level AI, but Terminator robots is not one of them. Personally, the best approach I've found so far is to assume that everything that is technologically and economically feasible will be attempted by someone, no matter how perverted or evil it is. If you can imagine something as a plausible consequence of the science/technology we have, and if you can imagine someone plausibly making lots of money from it, then it's the right time to talk regulations.
- IAmEveryone 7y agoI don't really see what you're getting at? As is, you seem to be employing some convoluted reserve-psychology scheme in an attempt to square this law in with "HN reality", where all politicians are corrupt and stupid, and all laws are either evil or pointless?
- anoncake 7y agoHow did you get that impression? Making laws that prevent abuse while permitting the benefits of facial recognition is difficult and takes time. During that time, companies using it could cause a lot of damage. So temporarily banning it altogether as a stopgap makes a lot of sense.