12 ms·
Honestly, I would also say that a partial reason why these would've dropped is that everyone who can do it has done it. You only need these kinds of results on
by bobthepanda 7y ago
Honestly, I would also say that a partial reason why these would've dropped is that everyone who can do it has done it.
You only need these kinds of results once because your DNA doesn't change. I knew people who were giving or had gotten these as gifts, but those are one-off purchases. And if you've heard of people doing it then you'll do it too but that's also a one-off.
I don't think I'd personally benefit because my family came to the US relatively recently from a country that has very few records going back very far, that haven't been destroyed. So what would be the point for me?
- nradov 7y agoThat's not quite true. Your DNA doesn't change, but 23andMe only does partial sequences on those test kits. As new techniques become available they can't necessarily retest old samples, so customers who want more complete results in the future will likely have to buy and submit new kits.
- war1025 7y agoI've never seen them push that as a marketing angle. As a 23andMe customer from a couple years ago, it never even occured to me to try re-running the results.
- ianferrel 7y agoI expect that this is a difficult thing to market, since most people probably don't realize that the thing they did wasn't a "complete" sequence. "Remember the thing we sold you before? Well, it wasn't that great. But now it is. Give us more money?"
- cstejerean 7y agoThey do, it depends how far back you signed up I guess. I did this many years ago, around the time they first launched and I got constant reminders that this or that new information is not available for me unless I upgrade to their latest chip. I think once I was able to upgrade by having them rerun the first sample I submitted, but at this point I think I’d have to send a new sample in if I remember the message correctly. But that seems like too much hassle so I haven’t done it.
- war1025 7y agoHonestly the most interesting thing in the whole result to me was the "Number of Neanderthal markers" thing. All in all, probably not hugely worth the expense. But I guess the novelty of it was fun.
- ryanmercer 7y ago>All in all, probably not hugely worth the expense. But I guess the novelty of it was fun. Yeah, for me it was half novelty and half trying to figure out more about my father's side of the family. My father died just before I turned 13, when his father died about a decade ago I asked my great uncle what he knew about the family... he didn't even know his mother's maiden name which I only discovered at the end of last year, several years after my great uncle also died. I can trace part of my mother's side back with confidence to at least the 17th century, my father's family had gone cold in the early 1900s until I discovered my grandmother's maiden name. Novelty is also why I want my whole genome done. Once it's down to a few hundred dollars I want to have it done and ultimately have it printed and put in binders, purely for the novelty.
- drakonka 7y agoI recently got an email or other notification of some sort offering a discount to get retested with their new V4 chip, as apparently my tests were run on V3.
- michaelmior 7y agoThis is true but unrelated to their current decline in sales since this isn't an option they currently offer.
- nradov 7y agoIt is an option they currently offer. https://you.23andme.com/chip-upgrade/ https://you.23andme.com/chip-upgrade/
- michaelmior 7y agoI stand corrected. (That link doesn't work for me, but the one below does.) I guess I'm a recent enough customer that there's no need for me to upgrade. https://customercare.23andme.com/hc/en-us/articles/360025014494-How-do-I-upgrade-my-genotyping-chip- https://customercare.23andme.com/hc/en-us/articles/360025014...
- throwaway1777 7y agoNew people are being born all the time. There are many industries based around one time purchases. Think appendix removal or weddings (that one may be more than once for some people)
- bobthepanda 7y agoGifting someone a thing that could be used as a paternity test at a baby shower would be more than a little rude. And presumably if both parents have already done it why would you need to test the baby?
- rrego 7y agoIt would be extraordinarily rude . But it's definitely not what the parent comment meant. :)
- rrdharan 7y agoMutation is a thing.
- buckminster 7y ago"No, no, I wasn't questioning the paternity, you can use the test to check if your baby is a mutant."
- tfigment 7y agoGiven the popularity of the X-men i think that might improve sales enough to reverse the trend.
- La1n 7y agoBut 23andme will always show some differences, while individual SNPs have high accuracy >99% due to the amount that is being tested you will always have some results that are wrong. Multiple testing problem is an issue here.
- jedberg 7y ago
- zyang 7y agoI did it 6/7 years ago because the novelty, and enthusiastically recommended it to family and friends. Now I regret doing it considering how Google and Facebook has abused consumer data. I definitely would not submit my kids to the same fate.
- evv555 7y ago>I definitely would not submit my kids to the same fate. You already have since your DNA is out there in a database.
- johntiger1 7y agoThat's not exactly how DNA works. Their kids should be mostly fine (99.99% similar is still night and day)
- scarmig 7y agoIf the government encounters one of their kid's DNA, that's enough to identify them as a son/daughter of the person with that DNA profile. If a medical insurance company purchases their DNA, analyzes it, and anticipates that a child of theirs is likely to have medical costs 5x the average, those costs will be passed on to those kids, absent legislation to the contrary. This applies to everyone you're related to, as well.
- munk-a 7y ago> If the government encounters one of their kid's DNA, that's enough to identify them as a son/daughter of the person with that DNA profile. I don't believe that's ever been tested in court (so there isn't precedence) and the ways in which DNA are complex enough - and the mutation rate is high enough - that it might be like fingerprints... if you're the only person with DNA that might be like the kind found and you've got some serious suspicion around you for other reasons... then they might be able to use it as supporting evidence or to compel you to submit to DNA testing to confirm the match (which apparently does have precedence in the US... wow America)
- Ohn0 7y agoThey need a SaaS! Monthly/yearly subscription to updates of some sort
- perardi 7y agoThat might be workable. Frankly, I think these mail-in DNA tests are like modern-day phrenology, but you could spin in that "pay us $x per year, and we will analyze your DNA every month once research becomes available".
- reaperducer 7y agoMonthly/yearly subscription to updates of some sort And tie it into credit score fear. "Do you want a higher credit score? Sure, we all do. So be sure your 23andMe DNA is up-to-date!"
- YinLuck- 7y ago23andMe actually had a subscription service when they launched. I was one of the earlier customers and remember having to pay monthly to continue to access my reports. What 23andMe needs is a premium full sequence service rather than today's limited one. I'd pay ~$1k for a full genome sequence.
- a_imho 7y agoPivot into mining all the present data and sell it to the highest bidder if not doing that already.
- recursive 7y ago> Honestly, I would also say that a partial reason why these would've dropped is that everyone who can do it has done it. In my immediate circle of acquaintances, that doesn't seem to be true. I haven't done it. I'm aware of it, but I've never looked into it, since I've never seen a reason to care.
- xivzgrev 7y agoThis. Only so many people willing to spend $100 on a novelty purchase, and they do it once
- megablast 7y agoThis makes no sense. Most people only go to paris once, of bunjie jump once, or a billion other things. Just because you do it once doesn't mean it is no sustainable.
- chipotle_coyote 7y agoWhile I get what you're saying, "most people only go to Paris once" is a very odd analogy to use in this case. Paris may be a tourist destination, but it's not a tourism company. :) In any case, I think the caveat to what you're saying is that the sustainability of a business proposition that many people only do once (or at least, do comparatively rarely) also has to take into account the cost. Very people take a Jeep tour of the Grand Canyon, but the Jeep tour company is almost certainly a very lean operation compared to 23andMe.
- 2muchcoffeeman 7y agoThis sort of thing really makes me wonder whether execs thought about this scenario or not. It seems obvious to me that the novelty could wear off and people stop buying kits. Was it worth the effort and cost to ramp up staffing only to make them redundant?
- monkeydust 7y agoVery good point, re-sales chances almost zero not allowing for product enhancements perhaps. I use a blood test service (https://www.getlivesmart.com/ https://www.getlivesmart.com/) every six months but I can measure changes to my markets based on interventions to my lifestyle that they suggest post GP review. To me that type of service is worth it.