5 ms·
In Germany there is a strange policy for hospitals. If you do not do a minimal amount of operations of a certain kind (e.g. hip replacements), you loose the adm
by raxxorrax 7y ago
In Germany there is a strange policy for hospitals. If you do not do a minimal amount of operations of a certain kind (e.g. hip replacements), you loose the admittance to do any further surgeries of the same kind.
The incentive was probably to focus competency to certain hospitals, but you can imagine how this plays out in reality.
Especially people not familiar about medical necessities should always get a second opinion. Otherwise you might end up with an extra hip or something like that.
At least it begins to be common knowledge that hospitals do operate too often.
Still, with all its problems, and there are many, I certainly would prefer to be operated in any country of the EU compared to the US. Not because of capabilities of doctors, but to me it seems US health care as a example how private business can be worse than governmental services. Common market mechanisms don't work if your life depends on it. It is just about extracting the most amount of money from suffering and this article describes a problem to which there is no solution in my opinion.
- sneak 7y agoThis reminds me of a classic, which, it seems to me, should apply to surgeons as much as anyone: When all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail.
- qaq 7y ago"in any country of the EU" thats a very broad statement. A poor eastern EU country will not have remotely the level of surgeons and facilities that say The Johns Hopkins Hospital has this would be true even for many richest EU countries.
- slumdev 7y agoPeople with gold-plated health insurance and/or millions in reserve will receive better care in the US. The average schmuck will not. Hopkins probably isn't in-network for him even if he works across the street from it.
- runako 7y ago> Hopkins probably isn't in-network for him even if he works across the street from it. Hopkins probably isn't in-network for a lot of people who physically work in the hospital every day. Custodial, cleaning, security, etc. often are contractors and therefore do not have access to employee benefits of their platinum-level customers.
- refurb 7y agoLooks like actual employees of John Hopkins, all the way down to the non-union employees have the hospital as in-network. Network Providers - The EHP Medical Plan gives you access to The Johns Hopkins Hospital[1] [1]https://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/human_resources/_docs/benefits/jhh_nonunion_spd.pdf https://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/human_resources/_docs/benefi...
- runako 7y agoThat's the whole point. Big institutions can decide that certain job roles shouldn't have access to benefits. Then, it's trivial to outsource those roles. This commonly happens for low-status job roles like janitorial, facilities maintenance, groundskeepers, and building security. JH may be relatively unique in being a 100% employee shop, but it would definitely be a case of the exception proving the rule. *Edit -- it looks like JH has a history of fairly high-profile labor conflicts. If they are 100% employees, I would bet their history is a factor in why they are this way now.
- qaq 7y agoI don't know how you imagine things work but there is a reason many of EU countries have private options.
- merpnderp 7y agoThe US’s healthcare is hardly an example of private businesses going awry. The US’s healthcare is by far the most heavily regulated in the country with a near majority of spending by the various governments. We have the worst of both worlds, some kind of Frankenstein’s monster of regulatory capture, government incompetence, and age old corruption. 20% of Medicare billing has been fraudulent for decades and now the government can’t fix it because so many parts of the industry rely on straight up theft. So yes the US health care system needs a push to be more socialized or less regulated, but it’s not some prime example of a free market gone awry.
- Ididntdothis 7y ago“so many parts of the industry rely on straight up theft.” This will be a big issue in any kind of health care reform in the US. if they want to get costs even remotely in line with other countries a lot of people will either lose their job or make much less money. That won’t happen without a lot of resistance.
- maximente 7y agoyep, health care reform to single payer will basically guarantee a recession - a huge percentage of GDP/jobs will evaporate over the course of the transition. there is no such thing as having this cake and eating it too: there will be immense pain for a sizable part of the economy whenever this gets tackled.
- abfan1127 7y agoWhile those who are negatively affected by the reform would suffer, that money doesn't evaporate. It goes elsewhere, so it wouldn't cause a recession on a macro scale. Look into the Broken Window Fallacy in Economics in One Lesson. its a great book.
- JamesBarney 7y agoThe money doesn't evaporate, but it very likely would result in less total money spent. And people spending less money is the textbook cause of recessions.
- snarf21 7y agoWhen a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure. -- Goodhart's Law
- C1sc0cat 7y agoIts not strange you want to concentrate the difficult stuff so that you get experts who do this a lot working on you (hip replacement is not one of those) For example transplant work in the UK is very concentrated I went to the royal free and they have the best equipment and surgeons and do world leading operations. The guy across from me was the oldest patient in the world to have a new type of key hoe surgery for example.