5 ms·
> Coming from the C# and JVM Not that I disagree with you but comparing C#/JVM to go is like comparing a commercial airliner to a single seat monoplane. These
by lm28469 7y ago
> Coming from the C# and JVM
Not that I disagree with you but comparing C#/JVM to go is like comparing a commercial airliner to a single seat monoplane. These projects are diametrically opposed from the get go in every way I can think of.
There are only two languages I ever liked working with C and go. Because they're simple, full of compromises, but simple. I can't say that of C# or java, you probably need a PhD just to be able to use 1/3 of c#/java tooling and IDE features.
- tsimionescu 7y ago> I can't say that of C# or java, you probably need a PhD just to be able to use 1/3 of c#/java tooling and IDE features. That is absolutely incorrect. The whole point of having tooling at your disposal is to make the process of writing and reading code dead simple. Ypu don't need a PhD to pause the debugger, edit some code, hit continue, and have the new code executing. You don't need a PhD to select some text, click Extract Method (or press the shortcut), type in the method name, and have the new method/function on the screen. By the way, C has excellent tooling on all of these sides as well - C IDEs and debuggers are extremely powerful, unlike Go.
- rob74 7y agoYes, _commercial_ C (an Java) IDEs are extremely powerful, but it's a bit unfair to compare them to _open source_ Go IDEs/editors. From what I heard, the only commercial Go IDE available so far (GoLand) is extremely powerful too...
- BoorishBears 7y agoNot that I buy this argument in the slightest but: https://code.visualstudio.com/docs/languages/csharp https://code.visualstudio.com/docs/languages/csharp (Are you going to say, it's unfair to compare something with the commercial backing of Microsoft, because Google backs Go)
- imtringued 7y ago>because Google backs Go The degree of backing is completely different though. They appear to only do the minimum effort that they need for themselves. Microsoft provides good C# tooling because they want you to stay in the Microsoft ecosystem.
- BoorishBears 7y agoThey want you to stay in the Microsoft ecosystem is why they made an open source IDE and great tooling for it that competes directly with an IDE they sell for up to 1000$/seat/year that actually tries to get you to stay in their ecosystem with things like free Azure credits, preferential Azure pricing, free Windows Server and MSSQL licenses Not that I think any of this is not entirely tangential to the original point...
- tsimionescu 7y agoEclipse is far more powerful of a C and Java IDE than any non-commercial Go (I)DE. NetBeans is also a great Java IDE. They're not as powerful as IntelliJ or VS, but they are still miles ahead of any Go plugin I've used. Also note, for C you have gdb, you have ctags, you have all sorts of great plugins for Emacs or Vim or whatever. You also have stellar plugins for Javascript and TypeScript, for VSCode, for Emacs, for vim and many others. I'm not just comparing VS with vim+go plugins.
- aquadrop 7y agoCan't agree here. Go is going for simplicity of the language but definitely not for simplicity of tooling. If anything, I would say golang tooling is more complicated then c#, with all that myriad of small tools. Debugging story is just objectively better in c# and it's pretty easy to use.