4 ms·
I am guessing it is the cutting of service to neo-nazi websites: https://www.wired.com/story/free-speech-issue-cloudflare/ https://www.wired.com/story/free-spee
by cortesoft 7y ago
I am guessing it is the cutting of service to neo-nazi websites: https://www.wired.com/story/free-speech-issue-cloudflare/ https://www.wired.com/story/free-speech-issue-cloudflare/
Personally, I don't think free speech requires providing services to neo-nazis, but I get the nuances of the case.
- Valmar 7y agoI do not trust the SPLC to determine what is a "Neo-Nazi" website, as they regularly smear anyone and everyone who dare have beliefs that they don't like. They then throw everyone into the same corner, and collectively smear them as "white supremacists" and "Neo-Nazis". The terms, when used so broadly to silence harmless views that they disagree with, lose their meaning... Harmless, as in, said views are not really "white supremacist" ~ the SPLC has merely given them that label because they know its a powerful weapon.
- cortesoft 7y agoFirst, no one said the SPLC is the final say for this. Second, do you have any examples of an organization that the SPLC deemed a white supremacist that wasn't?
- merpnderp 7y agoI know the SPLC has paid out in defamation suits rather than allow the cases to go to trial. Pretty good sign they knew they'd lose as it has severely hurt their reputation. Here's a particularly egregious case where a UN affiliated group was labeled an extremist hate group and the SPLC wouldn't relent even after evidence was presented: https://www.newsweek.com/splc-nawaz-million-apologizes-981879 https://www.newsweek.com/splc-nawaz-million-apologizes-98187...
- cortesoft 7y agoIt sounds like they did relent? It doesn't say anything about them refusing to relent after evidence was presented. It seems like they made a mistake in this case, clearly, but I don't know if you can extrapolate from that that they acted in bad faith.
- merpnderp 7y agoThey relented as part of a multimillion dollar payout. Relenting under threat of legal action, isn't acting in good faith. Good faith is receiving the very first email and being "oh, my bad, let me fix that for you."
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- htfu 7y agoHow to you go from SPLC backing down after '"human rights advocates affiliated with the United Nations" praised Nawaz's work.' to Quilliam being UN affiliated, and SPLC not backing down? At least read your own link, please. I get what you're saying about the settlement but they could've just paid out and not gone to such lengths explaining how they felt they'd gotten things wrong.
- merpnderp 7y agoCould they have, or was an apology a part of the settlement? We'll never know - but since it got to the point of a settlement, I'm betting the apology was a requirement of avoiding court.
- Rebelgecko 7y agoThat is a ridiculous claim, I honestly can't imagine how anyone could make that in good faith. The website is named after a Nazi tabloid that was so virulent its publisher was executed at Nuremberg. The website's style guide for guest writers talks about the importance of "gassing kikes". If a website that glorifies Adolf Hitler, fascism, and genocide isn't enough to be considered neo-Nazi, then what is?
- erichocean 7y agoNeo-Nazi sites, for better or worse (obviously: worse) should still be on the Internet. If only for the rest of us to point at as an example of what not to do. Censorship is a bit like antibiotics: short-term positive impact but long-term negative impact. Neo-Nazis are not a threat to anyone, anywhere, in any way. We can survive their stupid web page, and have no need to censor it. The cure is MUCH worse than the disease. UPDATE: I love how I get downvotes and literally NO ONE has engaged with my core argument, that censorship is a bit like antibiotics: short-term positive impact but long-term negative impact. Making the future worse over a tiny group of "neo-Nazis"—who are probably 90% Feds anyway—is a bad idea. People used to know this stuff, but I guess we'll have to re-learn it all over again the hard way. sigh
- detaro 7y ago> Neo-Nazis are not a threat to anyone, anywhere, in any way. Except to the people they attack or murder of course.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Rebelgecko 7y agoMy comment isn't meant to make a judgement call or restart the argument as to whether or not neo-nazi sites should be on the internet. I'm just saying that it is ridiculous to question whether the people behind the site are Neo-Nazis and fascists. They admit what they are— there's not much room for debate.