18 ms·
> I want to like the Microsoft that appears to be turning over a new leaf from their “evil” days. Embracing open source is just the first step of an old, old s
by AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago
> I want to like the Microsoft that appears to be turning over a new leaf from their “evil” days.
Embracing open source is just the first step of an old, old strategy of theirs. Maybe I'll be proven wrong on that, but you'd be a fool to forget their past. This the company that brought down IBM.
> I can’t imagine that corporations would allow Microsoft to market to their end-users.
No real choice, unfortunately. Oh, I'm sure some clueless Linux Desktop evangelist will try to claim otherwise, but the reality is that Windows and Office run the business world. Microsoft put a lot of effort into delivering good products and keeping compatibility with old software, in addition to shady anti-competitive practices, to ensure that. Meanwhile, the Linux Desktop is still a fragmented mess that breaks every few years (at best). I really wish it weren't true, because Windows is a painful experience these days, but Linux Desktop manages to still be worse.
> There must be some ultra-premium edition of Windows 10 that one can buy, where telemetry and ads are fully disabled?
That may be true of Windows 10 Enterprise LTSC, which can not be purchased individually and is expensive.
> Do most PC enthusiasts figure out how to disable that stuff or buy professional editions?
There are readily available tools to disable it, like O&O ShutUp 10.
- chx 7y ago> Windows is a painful experience these days, but Linux Desktop manages to still be worse. I often ranted about this: after running Linux as my daily driver 2004-2017 (and a few years before that in dual boot and since 1993 on servers) I switched to Windows + WSL in early 2018 and I am OK with it. I use an eGPU. Now, of course, Linux does not even support changing the video card under X Windows. And I am not so sure about supporting hotplugging an nVidia card either. And when I was running Linux I ran into problems with enterprise wifi and VPN all the time and my multifunction devices and bluetooth. https://xkcd.com/619/ https://xkcd.com/619/ rings painfully true. Linux is a great server operating system with a desktop badly cobbled on top.
- Miraste 7y agoI have a Linux laptop and an eGPU. I dual boot Windows when I need to use it. I didn't even try to get it to work on Linux because that's a good way to lose a week and gain nothing. Switching between dedicated GPUs and integrated ones is still barely functional after heavy tweaking, and laptops have been doing that for I don't even know how long. That xkcd is extra painful because there are still, 11 years later, zero Linux browsers that support hardware-accelerated (i.e. smooth) video playback.
- fyfy18 7y agoOn my desktop with a GTX 1060, Chrome can play 4K60 YouTube videos without issues. But yeah on my laptop with Intel integrated graphics (I thought Intel was supposed to be better supported vs Nvidia under Linux?) I can barely play a 1080p video without frames being dropped. It even struggles displaying a 4K desktop so I have to run at 1440p, while Windows handles it fine.
- vetinari 7y agoTwo notes: 1) Chrome does not use hardware video acceleration under Linux. Some distributions' Chromium build does (the code is there, and is enabled under ChromeOS). Why Google didn't enable it for desktop Linux is a question for Google. 2) Intel GPUs do not have problem with 4K desktop under Linux, they are capable enough to run two 4K display at once, at least since Broadwell. It's 8K capabilities that are currently under development.
- monort 7y agoIf you don't believe, choose 2160p60 on this video and see the CPU utilization under Linux: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LXb3EKWsInQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LXb3EKWsInQ
- shrimp_emoji 7y ago>Linux is a great server operating system with a desktop badly cobbled on top. Especially the most popular flavor, Ubuntu. Between releases which require reinstallations to get new features, hardware support, and bugfixes (bugfixes are supposed to be backported, but fresher DE versions have worked much better than old ones for me, so I'm skeptical) and the awkwardness of PPAs, it's sad it's the go-to assumed distro which everyone writes articles for and tests hardware/software against when rolling release is such a better model (that Windows now ostensibly uses with 10). Manjaro seems to be gaining popularity as a user-friendly, nerfed rolling distro which offers safety and fast features+hardware support+bugfixes and can use the AUR, where everything in the Universe is and can be browsed with a GUI package manager -- no PPA terminal imports needed. But so is MX Linux, a Debian-based, Xfce distro whose selling point seems to be "no systemd", which speaks to a misalignment of priorities between many Linux users and the average PC user... if "average PC user" means "vaguely technical person who games and wants fast drivers + new hardware support", which is already wrong. But FWIW, >>Windows is a painful experience these days, but Linux Desktop manages to still be worse. Disagree. Can't speak to exotic use cases though; I don't even know what an eGPU is. For me, there seems to be a magical effect of using Linux for a long time and then returning to Windows. Windows doesn't seem to work as well as it used to. There's permission problems with the new 10 Settings interface when trying to access the core system apps like Device Manager. It can't connect to the Internet when I turn off my VPN, when Linux works fine on the same VPN. So many little things. Suddenly, Windows seems like the janky, ersatz OS I force myself to go to sometimes while Linux feels like the more intuitive "home" system. But I've been on it for like 2 years now, so I'm probably brainwashed. And in 10 years Linux will get worse so I'll boomerang back to Windows like you? Or maybe something better will take over, like Fuchsia.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago> Disagree. Can't speak to exotic use cases though; Windows desktop usage is somewhere north of 80%. Consider that Linux can't even do many common use cases right, it's just that it can do your use cases.
- Accacin 7y agoFunny how things go! I had been using Arch Linux for about 4 years and recently I switched to PopOS. I never had problems with updates, but had a lot of problems with non-standard locations. For example, getting Vim to work inside of Tmux with eslint and auto complete just wouldn't work perfectly no matter what I tried. It's a different world with Gnome and PopOS, and I really miss the AUR and Pacman but other than that I feel like I'm spending more time on my system than before.
- giancarlostoro 7y ago> Embracing open source is just the first step of an old, old strategy of theirs. Sure if you ignore the fact that their major projects were not extensions, and they're MIT licensed. Their past tactics was to extend open standards and become the corporate standard.
- voodootrucker 7y ago> Oh, I'm sure some clueless Linux Desktop evangelist will try to claim otherwise Non-evangelist here. I've been running Ubuntu as my daily driver for years, and mostly it just works. Not saying it's going to take over the business world, just saying it's not worse than Windows for me in any way.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago> Non-evangelist here. I've been running Ubuntu as my daily driver for years, and mostly it just works. Not saying it's going to take over the business world, just saying it's not worse than Windows for me in any way. Ok. But it is worse for me, and basically everyone else who uses Windows and says that Linux Desktop won't suit their needs. I don't have a problem with people who use the Linux Desktop. Hell, if I bother to count all the desktops in my house then I use it on 4/5 PCs myself. What I have a problem with are evangelists who believe that anyone not using a Linux Desktop is doing so for stupid reasons. I can't even count the number of times over the past 2 decades I've had to listen to some Linux Desktop evangelist proclaim that there was literally no reason to use anything else, and then proceed to argue the case with no knowledge whatsoever of the needs of the person they're arguing against. It's these people who are being referred to when people talk about how the Linux Desktop community itself is the worst part of using the Linux Desktop. It is a mindset I really can't stand about tech people: assuming that because something works for them that it therefore is the right choice for everyone else. That they are so superior to the rest of humanity that they can instantly understand everyone's use cases, and anyone who claims otherwise is just being a stubborn fool.
- gradstudent 7y ago> Ok. But it is worse for me, and basically everyone else who uses Windows and says that Linux Desktop won't suit their needs. The irony is delicious.
- p1necone 7y agoAs a dev, but not really an OS power user: I've tried switching to Linux (ubuntu and mint) full time before and I really don't see any major shortcomings vs windows for regular desktop use - I know anecdotal evidence is pretty useless but it's all you really can get about this on here. The only reason I'm not on Linux full time is video game compatibility. I suspect no retail PCs coming with Linux preinstalled, and general lack of knowledge that it even exists or what it is is just as big (if not more) of a contributor to it's lack of users for non techies as UX is.
- thiagomgd 7y ago> Meanwhile, the Linux Desktop is still a fragmented mess that breaks every few years (at best). I really wish it weren't true, because Windows is a painful experience these days, but Linux Desktop manages to still be worse. In Brazil we used to say that the year of linux (desktop) was current year + 1. Because people who used it would always tell others that "next year is going to be the year of linux on desktop", only for that not to happen and then they adjust their prediction for the next year again...
- 0xDEEPFAC 7y agoWindows 10 LTSC is great - it doesn't have Cortana or the Windows Store and it even has a nifty search icon beneath the Start menu which says "Start typing to search..." Not that I would recommend it but you can purchase LTSC on Ebay for about ~20 to 30$. That is where I got mine... Sketchy? Yes, but worth a chance in my book
- justinclift 7y ago> but you can purchase LTSC on Ebay Doesn't sound like you purchased it. It sounds like you gave some [random] place money for a pirated (and maybe backdoored) copy of Windows. That's likely a very bad approach. ;)
- 0xDEEPFAC 7y agoNo problems yet... Updates work just fine and are only performed at reasonable intervals
- justinclift 7y agoSure. The approach seems like it works for you (so far), and sounds like it worked out well for whoever got money out of you. But, please don't encourage others to put themselves at risk. aka fall for a scam on Ebay
- 0xDEEPFAC 7y agoI disagree, but I admit it is risky.
- blibble 7y agothe keys seem to be about $2 you could get scammed or have your key deactivated a hundred times and still be ahead
- justinclift 7y agoThat's assuming there aren't backdoors in the software. Not a safe bet to make. At least, not without (at a minimum) having the SHA256 (or better) checksum of the ISO match that of the MSDN equivalent download.
- runn1ng 7y agoLTSC can be purchased individually legally. But it is indeed expensive. Luckily, there are also all those shady eBay “key resellers”. (They are all cracked of course, but they also work, so it’s worth it.)
- johannes1234321 7y ago> No real choice, unfortunately. Oh, I'm sure some clueless Linux Desktop evangelist will try to claim otherwise, but the reality is that Windows and Office run the business world. Also mind that "professional" editions of windows contain less of the crapware than Home or similar editions...
- wtallis 7y agoNote however that "Windows 10 Pro" is not one of the reduced-crapware editions.
- technofiend 7y agoPro has slightly more knobs exposed than Home letting you adjust behavior but it’s nothing like the corporate version of Windows, no. I use tron script regularly to cut out what I can and it does help. Reading online the true believers load LTSB or LTSC licenses instead although they give up latest-gen CPU support by doing so.
- z3t4 7y agoLinux desktops are rare because there are few companies selling them. See for example Redhat. This is a pretty lucrative business opportunity. I think Microsoft is seeking other revenue models (ads) because once they get competition prices will drop.
- fouc 7y agoThe old strategy that you're referring to was called "Embrace, Extend, and Extinguish" in their internal memos [0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embrace,_extend,_and_extinguish https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embrace,_extend,_and_extinguis...
- mthoms 7y agoWow, I never realized that phrase was used internally at MS. I always thought it was an outsiders description of their practice. Shameful.
- dabbernaught420 7y ago>I'm sure some clueless Linux Desktop evangelist will try to claim otherwise ubuntu just werks
- hawski 7y agoEmbracing open source may be even sincere as companies go. But being a company means that it may eventually all change without notice. Companies change people and their positions, but even people change minds.
- Diesel555 7y agoI'd really like to believe that the embracing open source is different than the embrace, extend, extinguish mantra they had. I really do see a different attitude towards developers with VSCode, GitHub, Bash on Windows, etc (long time Mac user here - not on the Microsoft bandwagon). For the OS Ads... I also see red. But I try not to forget that a corporation isn't a person, it's a large group of people. History doesn't mean that a corporation always acts the same with the same incentive structure. Look at Apple over the years. Now corporations do have a culture derived from history (and leadership obviously). And that culture is different in different places of a large company. I believe the ads in the OS is something that is culturally wrong with the group developing that OS. And likely, knowing nothing of Microsoft's structure, the culture of the people working on the projects I mentioned above is drastically different than that team. Point is, because Microsoft is a large organization it can be "evil" and "good", it depends where you look. It doesn't have to be mutually exclusive.