15 ms·
Half the world is now middle class or wealthier (2018)
- vectorEQ 7y agohalf of what world? certainly not earth?
- dexen 7y agoReminds me of Hans Rosling's talks, for example https://www.ted.com/talks/hans_rosling_the_best_stats_you_ve_ever_seen https://www.ted.com/talks/hans_rosling_the_best_stats_you_ve....
- ipnon 7y agoWhen will half of the world be upper class, where making more money won't increase their happiness? That is $75,000 per year in 2013 USD. This second transition almost certainly won't appear like the last. There are reasons to believe it may not be gradual like the transition from poverty to middle class. Will the population be launched into wealth piece by piece, as subgroups of developed economies get access to education and then the capital necessary to make the salary of a Bay Area software engineer, for example? Are there any "natural" forces within capitalism to proliferate this prerequisite education and capital? Can a person with enough intelligence to work in a factory but not enough to get a tertiary degree hope to make this transition into wealth "on their own"? My only bet is that the current global state of "business as usual" is completely insufficient to make the second transition for any significant proportion of the world's inhabitants.
- ramblerman 7y agoI think we can do things better for sure, and it's a tragedy for all those in poverty that it will still take time, perhaps outside their lifetime. But to suggest there is some wall to the second transition seems unfounded, as "business as usual" is what lead us here in the first place.
- throwawayhhakdl 7y agoThe idea that you can arbitrarily label a dollar value as the the point of the no return is pretty absurd. Even forgetting the differences in cost of living for different areas.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jbotz 7y agoIncorrect use of the term "tipping point". Reaching this point may be noteworthy, but there is absolutely no evidence or reason to believe that the remaining poverty will diminish much more rapidly, which is what "tipping point" implies.[1] Nor do they actually claim this in the article, they just keep on misusing the term. Also, I live in a small city in a developing country where this phenomenon was quite visible; certainly people have a lot more material wealth than they did, say 20 years ago, but education and public health have not improved significantly, and possibly even declined for the lower middle-class. And while people used to be poor here, nobody was malnourished in the bad old days, but now, with their new industrialized middle-class diets, they are getting "starving fat" like American inner city kids. If people are really better off is debatable. And all those new middle-class consumers are doing a real number on the environment, probably more so than a "first world" consumer of similar means because of the crappy infrastructure (proper waste management anyone?) and because the consumer goods here are of significantly lower quality (and so need to be replace more frequently). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tipping_point_(sociology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tipping_point_(sociology)
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 7y agoThe authors' argument for why this is important is made here: Why does it matter that a middle-class tipping point has been reached and that the middle class is the most rapidly growing segment of the global income distribution? Because the middle class drive demand in the global economy and because the middle class are far more demanding of their governments. FWIW, I agree that reaching 50% globally is of little importance, but it's certainly very meaningful locally. China's meteoric rise in the last two decades was born from the rise of the middle class, and the same is now starting to happen in India and Indonesia. Also, And while the rise is not without it's downsides (pollution, obesity, whatnot), as the authors note that it's quite well established that escaping poverty/vulnerability makes people a lot happier. Risking a heart attack from a bad diet 30 years down the road is preferable to starving now due to a lack of food.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- esotericn 7y ago> the majority of humankind is no longer poor or vulnerable to falling into poverty This isn't a definition of middle-class I've ever encountered, the bar is surely a bit higher than simply 'not poor'. They've used $11 PPP as the lower bound. That's totally ridiculous, in most of Europe that's not even liveable. Perhaps they mean discretionary income? That would make a bit more sense. Otherwise, it seems like they've chosen figures such that middle class ~= median global income, which is a circular definition.
- collyw 7y agoWhile I agree, at least things seem to be moving in the right direction.
- dahart 7y agoWhether things are moving in the right direction depends on how you measure things and who you believe. There are lots of signs in the positive direction, but Jason Hickel famously argued that things are moving in the wrong direction everywhere except China (https://www.jasonhickel.org/blog/2019/2/3/pinker-and-global-poverty https://www.jasonhickel.org/blog/2019/2/3/pinker-and-global-...) and that even including China, at the current rate it could take 200-500 years to resolve global poverty (https://www.jasonhickel.org/blog/2019/4/27/200-years-to-end-poverty https://www.jasonhickel.org/blog/2019/4/27/200-years-to-end-...)
- quindecagon 7y ago> By our calculations, as of this month, just over 50 percent of the world’s population, or some 3.8 billion people, live in households with enough discretionary expenditure to be considered “middle class” or “rich.” > Our “middle class” classification was first developed in 2010 and has been used by many researchers. While acknowledging that the middle class does not have a precise definition that can be globally applied, the threshold we use in this work has the following characteristics: those in the middle class have some discretionary income that can be used to buy consumer durables like motorcycles, refrigerators, or washing machines. They can afford to go to movies or indulge in other forms of entertainment. They may take vacations. And they are reasonably confident that they and their family can weather an economic shock—like illness or a spell of unemployment—without falling back into extreme poverty. Emphasis mine
- chrisseaton 7y ago> enough discretionary expenditure to be considered “middle class” I don’t think money makes you ‘middle class’. You can be a millionaire but working class, or destitute but upper class. Class is about things like background, education, tastes, social status and connections. Not cash.
- quindecagon 7y agoPerhaps you would prefer the term "middle income." I think your conception of the term class and the one used in the article are different. By substituting the term "middle class" for "middle income"this issue is sidestepped.
- esotericn 7y agoThis is only true in one direction. You can be wealthy and working class, sure. But the converse is simply impractical. How many upper class individuals are there living in a rotting house share, on benefits, hitting up the food bank? There's a minimum amount of capital required to be able to meaningfully participate in social activities at different levels. That might not mean fantastic wealth but neither does it mean working in the corner shop (unless by choice).
- chrisseaton 7y agoIf you’re born a baronet, go to Eton, take a commission in the Guards, but end your days alone and penniless in a care home then I think you’re still upper class until the day you die. Likewise I could win the lottery tomorrow but I’d never have the background and connections to become upper class.
- esotericn 7y agoHmm, yeah, you're right there (on both examples). I'm still not so sure though. That's something of a special case, the extreme upper end and also at the end of one's life. It feels like you at least need to at _some_ point have the wealth if not necessarily personally (e.g. whilst growing up).
- 7y ago
- dahart 7y agoThis framing is extremely suspect IMO; the article and figure 1 calls people in extreme poverty “poor” and people in poverty “vulnerable”. Extreme poverty is not just “poor”, extreme poverty is a line below which one cannot afford enough food to keep them alive, and doesn’t include housing or anything else. The “vulnerable” line is below $11/day, and some economists have argued the definition of global poverty should be higher than that. These dollar numbers are in adjusted PPP (purchasing power parity) so you can compare them to what you make & spend in the US, for example. $11/day is $4k/year, which is very far below what we call poverty in the US (our line is almost $12k), so why are we okay with calling that poverty elsewhere? People earning the equivalent of $11/day are not going to movies. There was an enlightening article & discussion about this last year on HN https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19133221 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19133221
- m-p-3 7y agoWealth classes are relative to the purchasing power and cost of living. With many more reaching middle class it just means that the threshold to be considered middle class increases, so the bottom of the middle class will simply be downranked at some point as even though they're making more money, their power diminished.
- sqrt17 7y agoThe article gives a definition of what they mean by middle class in absolute terms: - being able to afford durable goods such as motorcycles and washing machines - not having to fear extreme poverty due to illness or unemployment right away In many developed nations, this definition would comprise a large majority of the population, and some people who would be considered poor on relative terms there (i.e. make less than half the average income) would comfortably fit into this definition of a global middle class.
- hkai 7y agoBut I was told billionaires own all the wealth and pay all the taxes.
- poelzi 7y agoThe only reason it gives you the illusion of beeing richer then our previous generations is, that you can now buy tons of cheap Chinese shit for which your grandparents had to buy very expensive western utilities (the stuff that still works). Otherwise, we are, on average, poorer then our parents. Our kids, if you are still consider having them, will be poorer then you. A necessary result from capitalism with fiat money. However, if your wealth exceeds a certain threshold, currently something around 1.5-2 million €, you will benefit from this system and earn more all the time.