6 ms·
Would be great for Googlers ... kinda horrible for locals in KC who would still be making the same amount, and housing costs skyrocket.... funding sudden needed
by duxup 7y ago
Would be great for Googlers ... kinda horrible for locals in KC who would still be making the same amount, and housing costs skyrocket.... funding sudden needed school expansions ... and so on...
The economic and political messes of sudden expansion can be an absolute mess.
- bobajeff 7y agoAs someone who has experienced this happen to my home city I can vouch. It does suck.
- sien 7y agoWhich city?
- grawprog 7y agoNot the parent but Vancouver's become like that over the last 10 years or so. I lived just outside Vancouver and I watched the relatively quiet, affordable neighbourhood I lived in suddenly become filled with overpriced highrises and condos and watched rent more than double in price while average wages remained relatively stagnant.
- mrr54 7y agoYeah that's nothing to do with big companies moving there. That's what happens when you let Chinese investors dominate your housing market. (See Auckland as well)
- fredophile 7y agoI left Vancouver almost 10 years ago. Rents were okay at the time but housing prices were already ridiculous and had been for a long time. I'm not surprised that rents moved up to be more in line with the cost of ownership.
- remote_phone 7y agoI am from Vancouver. The house prices have always been ridiculous since the early 80s when my family moved there. Vancouver’s real estate market has always been unaffordable and the highest in Canada. This is nothing new in the last 10 years, it’s literally a 40 year old problem.
- adrianN 7y agoHousing costs can be kept reasonable if in addition to a new HQ, the city also builds a housing for a few thousand additional people.
- rednixion 7y agoI think you might be underestimating how many people will see government housing as a massive downgrad
- dodobirdlord 7y ago"The city builds" can just as easily mean "the city issues permits allowing".
- wolco 7y agoIt raises property values. Increases the tax base. For home owners might be a great time to sell. It also raises prices which means local shops and places to eat would be booming.
- duxup 7y agoThey might have to sell if there are property taxes. But if they're a local and not getting one of these high paying jobs ... they're going to have a hard time finding a place they can afford.
- nradov 7y agoIndeed a lot of long time Mountain View residents are unhappy to have Google HQ there. Sure their property values have skyrocketed, but for those who just want a nice place to live the quality of life is worse.
- sien 7y agoGoogle has heaps of offices around the world : https://about.google/locations/?region=asia-pacific&office=sydney https://about.google/locations/?region=asia-pacific&office=s... Does anyone know what proportion of their workforce is not in California? A question to Googlers and those who have worked there, is it possible to move to say Boulder within Google easily?
- B-Con 7y agoIf you're qualified to work for a team that's hiring, transfers are pretty easy. I work for GOOG outside CA and know a lot of coworkers who transferred teams within the company from out of state. Lateral mobility is something of a perk.
- anonymoushn 7y agoYou have to make sure to join in the bay area though. Offers in my local office are typically for 1/11 the initial equity of offers for the same level in Mountain View, San Francisco, or Sunnyvale, and I was not permitted to speak to any hiring managers in the US after seeing a four-day exploding offer from my local office.
- jefftk 7y agoI'm surprised you received an exploding offer; I had thought that was something we didn't do? Pay depends enormously on the local market for your skills. NYC and Boston pay almost as much as Mountain View, while (ex) London pays much less. People moving between offices are often offered large increases/decreases. A strategy of joining in Mountain View and then transferring to a lower-paying office isn't generally going to give you much higher pay at the new office (though you'll of course have the money you put away while in Mountain View). (Speaking only for myself)
- anonymoushn 7y agoWorking in Mountain View for 6 months is worth literally a million dollars of (MV initial equity - local office initial equity), assuming I was going to work in the local office for the remaining 3.5 years either way.
- AmericanChopper 7y agoThe only reason this happens is because of (perhaps misguided) attempts to resist the changes caused by population growth from local voters. If it was up to the market to decide, what would happen if there was a sudden spike in the demand for housing? Developers would build more housing. Prices might move a bit, but you’re not going to be looking at a crisis. However, entrenched homeowners don’t want that, because it would change whatever it is they like about their nice quite neighbourhoods. So they resist any attempt to develop new housing. Housing supply is artificially constrained, everybody’s property taxes go up (because the supply of property tax payers is artificially constrained too), prices skyrocket, and access to housing plummets. The idea that when you buy a house, that you’re somehow paying for your neighbourhood/city to perpetually remain in a state that personally satisfies you is behind most of our housing problems. Enabled by the almost universal dysfunctionality of local democracy.
- rightbyte 7y agoIsn't that an example of functional local democracy? Why bother make your town a mess in the name of growth. In SF's case the external pressure just was to huge and they should have given up long time ago keeping it a low built city.
- TulliusCicero 7y ago> Why bother make your town a mess in the name of growth. Yeah, and why bother making the country a mess by letting foreigners into your country? People moving for opportunity is a fundamental part of what America is. To deny others opportunities that you have by virtue of birthplace is nativism, and it's ugly. Sure, it sounds relatively harmless when it's "just your town", but you can look at the bay area and see what happens when everyone behaves this way for their neighborhood or city. Massive rents, struggling families, hideously long commutes: all the result of NIMBYism.
- ericmay 7y ago> Yeah, and why bother making the country a mess by letting foreigners into your country? I mean, that’s kind of the point, isn’t it? And unless you’re a proponent for open borders, you advocate a similar position - just a different scale. I’m also not really a fan of the “deny others opportunities” grandstanding. I mean you do it right now. I bet someone wants the job you have. Why not give your money away so others have opportunities? It’s easy to talk the talk with that. We all, by nature of our global system, deny others opportunities. The Swiss deny me an opportunity to move to Switzerland since I don’t have a million bucks. New Zealand requires me to invest half a million. Canada has a points system for immigration. > People moving for opportunity is a fundamental part of what America is. To deny others opportunities that you have by virtue of birthplace is nativism, and it's ugly. Well, like towns, you shouldn’t expect the idea of America to not change. There is like 350mm people here. Personally I think that’s plenty and the Statue of Liberty mindset just reminds me of 2nd Amendment arguments. I don’t want to end up like India, China, or Bangladesh with crowds and crowds of people (whether they are here due to immigration or birth). I think the US is overpopulated as it is. My idea of America is a lot of untamed wilderness, clean air, national parks, peace and quiet. Increases on population don’t really fit my vision (but that’s mine). > Massive rents, struggling families, hideously long commutes: all the result of NIMBYism. And this isn’t solved by building skyscrapers and having more people. It’s solved by having fewer people and jobs less concentrated in specific areas. PG talks about taboo topics. Population is one of those I think, for me. I feel uncomfortable saying anything about it publicly, and I feel as though people have largely been indoctrinated that growth=good and you shouldn’t challenge that. I really just don’t see the value in adding more and more people to the US (birth or immigration). If we could have fewer, better educated people and less wealth disparity this could be an even better place to live. Imagine getting rid of jobs that people don’t want to do and then paying people a lot more money to do jobs they do want to do? Pay a barista $100,000/year instead of two business analysts making $50,000. It’s not like we’re going to add enough jobs to keep up with the pace of growth, unless we add mind-numbing bullshit jobs or create another TSA. But I think the whole raison d'être for everything here in this tiny post is that our economy is built on a growth model. It’s a huge Ponzi scheme (in function not intention), so if we don’t increase the population or increase global population and sell to them, the whole thing falls apart. But it’s also this growth mindset that’s destroying the pristine wilderness we have, causing global warming, and contributing to nonsense wars and terrorism.
- anonymoushn 7y agoIf we invent some sort of technology that lets us increase the housing supply we may be able to avoid this issue.
- dredmorbius 7y agoCarpentry?
- sgt101 7y agoSocialism.
- wutbrodo 7y agoLol, imagine thinking that the undersupply of housing in US metro is due to the market having too much say.
- claudeganon 7y agoLol, imagine thinking housing serving as a speculative asset for global Capital doesn’t constrain and distort supply away from what is needed vs what provides the greatest returns for this class of investors.
- dredmorbius 7y agoThere are better ways of expressing this valid notion.
- dredmorbius 7y agoThat would be an economic or market structure, and may be a possible solution. I'm looking at LVT and land use regulation myself. My initial quip was to point out that (as I suspect @anonymoushn was alluding) the problem isn't technological. Rather it's one of incentives, politics, and market structure.
- lazyjones 7y ago> kinda horrible for locals in KC who would still be making the same amount, and housing costs skyrocket Surely the locals already have their houses in KC and would benefit more than they'd suffer, as renters, sellers, shop owners.
- humanrebar 7y ago> ...housing costs skyrocket... In the short term, sure, but there's plenty of room in KC.