13 ms·
“You're stealing our water”: Germans protest against Tesla gigafactory
- djohnston 7y agoTesla should just build another factory in China. Why bother w manufacturing in the EU?
- zamfi 7y agoTariffs. Cars built in the EU are much cheaper to EU buyers than those made in China.
- djanogo 7y agoI don't think it's just about tariffs, BMW and MB have been exporting cars from Germany to US for a LONG time, if the tariffs are reciprocated I am sure it's not that a big deal to just pay them. I think it's more about Tesla wanting to capture German manufacturing know how and skilled auto labor to improve Tesla's products.
- zamfi 7y agoSurprisingly, the tariffs aren’t equal: 10% on EU imports, 2.5% on US imports. It’s not a ton, but it’s not nothing. Why not just hire Germans, then? Frankly, Musk empirically isn’t the type to list on experts in manufacturing — he ignored them entirely when trying to fully automate the Model 3 production line. So your hypothesis strikes me as unlikely. Doing it to spite the German automakers, though, that I’d believe!
- rad_gruchalski 7y agoMoving the location to Poland, some 70km east, would be enough.
- mc32 7y agoOr Czechia or Polen, even Spain.
- EliRivers 7y agoI'm sure there are many reasons; one might be the tariff on imports of electric vehicles from China, which I believe is 10%. The tariff is a bit tricky to find, but I think it's 87038010 - electric cars principally for transport of persons, that aren't trains or trams. Ten percent isn't nothing but it's not like the 100% or more tariff seen in some countries on car imports; I expect it's just one more factor.
- electriclove 7y agoThey need one in the EU for tariffs and shipping costs. But I agree that they should also build another factory in China. Keep showing the world how it can be done if all parties are committed.
- 8bitsrule 7y agoSure, seems like BASF was welcome in Shanxi after Toms River. Always easy to export the problem to sacrifice-areas. /s
- Jon_Lowtek 7y ago> Why bother w manufacturing in the EU? 1. Have you ever heard of the trade war? 2. Intercontinental transport will become more expensive. 3. Geo-redundancy means safety for mega corporations. 4. China may decide those are now state owned factories.
- aguyfromnb 7y ago>Tesla should just build another factory in China. Yeah, maybe they can build one in Xianjiang for cheaper labour. Why bother with laws?
- evanlivingston 7y agoTesla has an long uphill battle trying to get it's factory built in Berlin. I also feel they're probably underestimating the seriousness with which Germans take their worker's rights.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoGermany has little choice. Their economy is heavily dependent on their auto industry, which will contract as EV demand scales up. Of all automakers, I would think Tesla would be the least impactful based on their experiences at Gigafactory 1. https://finance.yahoo.com/news/declining-car-sales-help-drive-162158679.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/declining-car-sales-help-driv... (Declining Car Sales Help Drive Germany Toward Recession) https://www.tesla.com/ns_videos/tesla-impact-report-2019.pdf https://www.tesla.com/ns_videos/tesla-impact-report-2019.pdf (Tesla 2018 Impact Report)
- maxerickson 7y agoYour theory is that any EV builder willing to work in Germany will get to dictate terms? That seems unlikely given the wealth and industrial base devoted to the automotive industry there.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoMy theory is that Tesla is the least worst auto manufacturing partner Germany could work with (there are always compromises that must be made), and has the power to go elsewhere if desired (several other EU countries have been very vocal in their demand for a Gigafactory; China bent over backwards to provide financing to Tesla for Gigafactory 3 at very favorable terms, I could see something similar in the EU considering their negative interest rate environment). Whomever has the least to lose wins. Tesla is proven and has been derisked. I also think Tesla would be receptive to minimizing their environmental impact to the site, given their mission and marketing (see my link to Tesla's impact report in above comment). Does Germany want to be included in the next chapter of automotive mobility? That's up to them. Otherwise, take a trip to Flint, MI to see what the alternative path is (auto centric, of course). It's in Tesla's best interests to be a good corporate citizen, and they (in my opinion) walk the walk. Any environmental impact issues will be resolved and Gigafactory 4 construction will move forward. Disclaimer: Have toured Fremont and Gigafactory 1 facilities, TSLA investor, all that jazz
- rainyMammoth 7y agoInteresting to see the PR greenwashing marketing claims of Tesla clashing with their real life polluting activities.
- speedgoose 7y agoGood luck explaining to the average Tesla driver that his cars did pollute a lot. I tried to explain once that the "zero emission" label on the Nissan Leaf is misleading because building a car makes emissions. I do think electric car are a good solution where developing public transports would have a higher (environmental) cost, but building cars pollutes.
- gambiting 7y ago"I tried to explain once that the "zero emission" label on the Nissan Leaf is misleading because building a car makes emissions." I don't know why anyone would ever think the "zero emissions" label applies to the manufacture of the car. *obviously" it only means the car doesn't emit anything when moving, that's what it's about.
- speedgoose 7y agoThat's your opinion but anyway a Leaf will still emit when it's moving. Indirectly with the production of the energy, which can be very low in countries such as France or Norway, and directly with brakes dust even though the electric regen reduces that a lot, and particles from the tires.
- brianwawok 7y agoTire particles are emissions? When I walk are my shoe particles emissions? My skin shedding?
- hexchain 7y agoElectricity. In some places, electricity is still largely produced in thermal power plants, which do pollute a lot. In France and Norway, I guess most of their electricity is from nuclear and water?
- BelleOfTheBall 7y agoWhile the water issue is, indeed, quite serious, I'm not exactly sure why the 'increased traffic on highway' is so much of a concern that it's raised in the same article. Yes, traffic will increase because more people will be coming to newly created job opportunities. I suppose some of the worries might be due to the equipment being moved by big trucks which could inflict infrastructural damage but this is solvable.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- diminish 7y agoI'm curious how German engineering and the Tesla's american engineering will work together. Especially in light of the Opel & Focus experiences.
- oblio 7y agoOpel and Ford Germany are pretty successful...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kken 7y agoDoesn't Tesla already heavily rely on "German engineering"? They have/had plenty of executives from German automotive companies, they own an automation company in Germany and their supply chain probably has many German companies in it. (Three of the Top5 automotive suppliers are German)
- IfOnlyYouKnew 7y agoLiving across the street from the old factory in Berlin that was going to house a Google office until the local anti-gentrification movement started to protest, I'm not surprised. If you build a factory around here, with as much publicity as Tesla gets, you are going to see protests. There are probably two rare species of mosquitos being released in that forest right now. But just the existence of opposition isn't very meaningful. Of a few million people, some will oppose manna raining from heaven. Does this have a chance to derail the project? Absolutely not! Germany is getting quite nervous of its car industry doing an impressive 4-way re-enactment of Nokia's fate, and a significant Tesla presence is just about the best thing imaginable. The local politicians here in Berlin and Brandenburg (the state surrounding Berlin that includes the actual factory) are even more motivated, because it (still) lacks industry. Not one of the top-30 public companies in Germany is located in the east, for example. It's also important to mention that the concept of "protests" has significant different meaning here than elsewhere, especially the US: A protest is seen as one method/venue/institution among the many that make up "civil society". It carries no connotation of lawlessness[0], and any average citizen, even the blandest centrist, will attend many protests during their life. It's often a social event as well, and can include entertainment, somewhat similar to parades in the US. 0: some specific protests, like May Day, tend(ed) to involve some violence. But these number in the single digits, while there are 15 protests per day on average, just in Berlin.
- Jon_Lowtek 7y ago> rare mosquitos almost.. its bats :D welcome to germany elon https://www.businessinsider.de/international/tesla-gigafactory-endanger-bar-species-scientists-warn-2019-11 https://www.businessinsider.de/international/tesla-gigafacto...
- vanusa 7y agoOf a few million people, some will oppose manna raining from heaven. As much as these companies may try to present them that way - these factories they build are not "manna raining from heaven." A significant Tesla presence is just about the best thing imaginable. We get that there are potential benefits to bringing a major manufacturer to the area. So do the people protesting, I hope you realize. The question is whether these companies are willing to pay the true price for the resources they need. And whether they're willing to respect the environment (and yes, regulations) in doing so. Or whether they expect some kind of a free free ride. Quite often, the it's the latter that seems to be the case.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- symplee 7y agoWould it be possible to build a floating (or submerged) factory in the ocean? Far enough from shore but linked to a coastal city via a "boring company" tunnel. And thus be outside of any political jurisdiction.
- agumonkey 7y agoconsidering the chances of water level rise, knowledge in large floating structures seems like a worthy endeavour
- chrisseaton 7y ago> And thus be outside of any political jurisdiction. Are you going to have your own navy and marines to defend yourself?
- C14L 7y agoThere also were protests in favor of Gigafactory 4: https://twitter.com/Gf4Tesla/status/1218566354116149254 https://twitter.com/Gf4Tesla/status/1218566354116149254 https://twitter.com/Gf4Tesla/status/1218526931655761920 https://twitter.com/Gf4Tesla/status/1218526931655761920
- kken 7y agoThese are just your run off the mill NIMBYs. Many of those are way past their employment age, just take a look at the pictures. There was also a counterprotest.