3 ms·
The manufacturer should never be able to either deactivate or otherwise disable the functionality of a device they sold in a form that requires a service to fun
by scarface74 7y ago
The manufacturer should never be able to either deactivate or otherwise disable the functionality of a device they sold in a form that requires a service to function.
Exactly, why can’t I still dial in with my 2400 baud modem to get virus definitions for Norton Antivirus for my 386 that I bought in the 80s?
- the8472 7y agoYou can dial your 2400 baud modem if you find another endpoint or operate one yourself, you're not bound to a specific provider. Fax machines still work after all. You can run norton antivirus for DOS in whatever state it was when it was last sold.
- scarface74 7y agoSo now all I have to do is find someone who keeps a bank of 2400 baud modems and an updated list of virus definition files. As far as using as it was, what good is virus protection software that only works for viruses created in the 80s? Sure I can use a standalone gps device that I bought 10 years ago that doesn’t get updated but that doesn’t do me too much good navigating in a suburban area where most of the roads, houses and businesses didn’t even exist then.
- afiori 7y agoBut this is the point, manufacturers should offer improved features as incentives not intentionally and gratuitously deprecating older products.
- scarface74 7y agoIt is an optional feature in this case. He could go out and buy a regular cartridge and print from his same printer. I looked at the pricing. I would go for the free tier in a heartbeat- 15 pages a month and $1 for 10 (?) pages over that. I don’t print that often.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoA general-purpose computer with a general-purpose operating system and a general-purpose network adapter tied to it absolutely does not require Norton Antivirus or its virus definitions to function. Correspondingly, Norton is not involved in manufacturing any of these components.
- scarface74 7y agoThat seems like a distinction without a difference. I hypothetically bought a product that requires a service for functionality - Norton Antivirus. According to the parent poster, Norton should be required to keep their service running. Should Sony also be forced to keep their service running for PS1 games that had an online component - forever?
- TeMPOraL 7y agoTechnically you didn't buy a Norton Antivirus, you entered into a license agreement. Software is, unfortunately, almost always leased and not bought. However, I would very much be into forcing companies to either a) keep their service running forever, or b) allow the user to use a third-party service - in this case, virus definitions. This is in line with my comment elsewhere in the thread - companies should be allowed to either a) sell a product that doesn't require a service, and if it uses a service, it should support compatible third-party services as well, or b) lease the product as a part of a service. They should explicitly be banned from selling a product that requires their particular service to function. As for Sony, PS1 games and on-line: similarly, whatever middleware there is that facilitates on-line gaming, endpoints should be user-configurable. Fortunately, at least PS1 the device doesn't require Internet to run. (Come to think of it, did PS1 even support an Internet connection?)
- scarface74 7y agoYou’re right. It was first introduced with the PS2 in 2000. I do however have a vague recollection of early cartridge based systems where you could download games over cable.