3 ms·
But encryption doesn’t have “mostly safe”. It has safe and not safe. There isn’t a meaningful in between.
by olliej 7y ago
But encryption doesn’t have “mostly safe”. It has safe and not safe.
There isn’t a meaningful in between.
- rlucas 7y agoUnclear why this was heavily downvoted. Modern encryption is, eventually, either effectively unbreakable, or effectively worthless. Or is there widespread knowledge of exploits that can recover, say, 25% of a plaintext reliably, but no more?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Klathmon 7y agoI'd argue that there are levels of security and encryption, mostly around what data is secret. If I make an encrypted phone call to you, there are a few "levels" of information. There's the exact information exchanged on the call, the amount of information exchanged but not it's value, the identities of those in the call, the date and time and duration of the call, perhaps the hardware used to make the call, etc... Encryption isn't an all or nothing thing, it often involves tradeoffs and giving up some security for convenience or the other way around. And in some areas there are laws about what must be kept secret and what must be visible to the government (like in anti-money laundering laws).
- rcoveson 7y agoI hope I'm not misinterpreted as claiming that a balance must be struck between strong encryption and backdoored encryption. I was talking about a higher level balance, of which encryption is only one issue. We agree that the strength of encryption itself leans heavily towards the extremes; a "balance" on that particular issue is usually just misleading rhetoric.
- SkyBelow 7y agoIsn't encryption really 'most likely safe' and 'unsafe'. It has been a while since I've spent much time reading into the details, but the encryption we depend upon generally isn't proven safe, just failed to have been proven unsafe by many experts after many years.