4 ms·
Generally, when the torrenting / duplicating of such data is for preservation purposes, everyone turns a blind-eye, and there's even legislation most places to
by Groxx 16y ago
Generally, when the torrenting / duplicating of such data is for preservation purposes, everyone turns a blind-eye, and there's even legislation most places to support such efforts. Nobody would be making money from it while it doesn't exist, and it can be viewed as "historical" or "educational", both of which are usually protected uses of duplication.
- pbhjpbhj 16y ago>there's even legislation most places to support such efforts. I've seen previews of suggestions for legislation but no actual legislation for this sort of scenario, can you point me to some. Making money from something isn't a requirement for copyright infringement, nor even is it the test for commercial use of copyright works. I've never heard of a "fair use" case on historical (preservation) grounds can you point to one? As for educational use in Europe one generally doesn't have the relatively liberal educational use allowances that one does in the USA, and from hazy memory I think that the USA legislation does tie down quite well what is educational use. Certainly unlicensed redistribution except on the most de minimis basis wouldn't get a pass as fair use for education. IANA(IP)L and am a little out of touch wrt the latest legislative efforts. --- OT rant: Just recently it's interesting but all my posts in which I've tried to appraise people of copyright legislation or at least the potential threat of such have been modded down substantially. I have pretty strong views contrary to the current established laws myself, FWIW, but I feel that even if you're an anarchic dissident it's important to know the laws one is fighting against. Clearly others here disagree that reminders about demands of IP legislation are worthwhile for this type of forum.
- Groxx 16y agoI'll hunt around a bit, but I don't know of any off-hand. As to evidence of the attitude, I point to abandonware sites. Technically illegal many times, but companies getting uppity about things they don't sell appearing on abandonware sites is exceedingly rare. Similar to anime companies vs fansubbers prior to the anime being translated and sold in that particular area. Since you seem like you may be interested: looked at http://www.groklaw.net http://www.groklaw.net before? They've had quite a bit of activity on IP laws, last time I checked (as has the rest of the internet, but still).