4 ms·
> supposed to be trustworthy why is it they're "supposed to be" trustworthy? who told you that they were worth trusting? What previous examples do you have whe
by h2odragon 7y ago
> supposed to be trustworthy
why is it they're "supposed to be" trustworthy? who told you that they were worth trusting? What previous examples do you have where these organizations acted in your interest or at least to your benefit?
How is it that you expect anyone on this planet to be "trust" worthy? what exactly is it you expect from them? that they tell you the truth as they believe it? that the beliefs they hold are totally accurate and reproduce-able? that your experiences will not diverge from their to the point their advice no longer accurate for you? that you will understand the efforts someone make to communicate to the point that their thought becomes yours?
Incoherent rant; but i hope to make the point that we assign a lot of responsibility to others that we cannot reasonably expect them to be aware of, much less fulfill, here.
- datashow 7y agoI think different people have different criteria on "trustworthy". Most are only looking for confirmation. There are a few are looking for nonpartisan, unbiased reports. For those who are interested in nonpartisan, unbiased reports. I highly recommend https://thedispatch.com/ https://thedispatch.com/ . Yes, they clearly state they are conservative leaning, but I found their reports are very good. I also would like to know any liberal leaning website like this .
- etrabroline 7y ago>David French Senior editor of The Dispatch. This is a neocon publication, and unsurprisingly their current headline is criticizing trump for trying to end the war in Afghanistan. If you are a neocon I'm sure you'll find it as good as National Review or the Weekly Standard, but to call it nonpartisan or unbiased is not credible.
- datashow 7y agoI don't know I am a neocon. I just found that report makes good points. Are you saying all the evidence provided in the article are false and we can firmly trust the Taliban, or we should just pull troops out?
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoI expect people to tell me the truth as they believe it. I think that's a pretty universally known standard.
- gwright 7y agoA reasonable baseline, but it is also a pretty low bar. It basically excludes intentionally fraudulent communications but not much else. A much more difficult problem is to discern who's beliefs are closest to the ground truth. One approach to this is to notice who is able to most accurately predict future events or actions. I would argue that being able to make successful predictions is highly correlated with perception of ground truths.
- seppin 7y ago> A reasonable baseline, but it is also a pretty low bar. Also being ignorant of reality (or the law) isn't an excuse for getting something wrong.
- IfOnlyYouKnew 7y agoYou can't do anything without trust, so drop the faux-contrarian cynicism. Seriously: everyday, you rely on thousands of facts that get to you via intermediaries. News, obviously, but also the map data for your navigation, the lunch menu at work, the flier with your daughter's soccer schedule on the fridge, etc. Of that information, you can validate almost exactly zero from first principle. I have not, for example, ever verified that Japan exists or Donald Trump is president. So what you do is: you develop relationships of trust, with people (you are more likely to give your spouse the car keys than any stranger), or with institutions (google, New York Times, the Iraqi Information Ministry). These people/institutions have the interest of keeping you as a reader (or lover). That means even if they could profit from selling you out on any single issue, they would risk being found out and losing far more. It's iterated prisoners dilemma, essentially. Peoples' assessment of quality media like the Times or Economist has also become completely unhinged from reality. Re-read their coverage of both Mueller as well as the current Ukraine affair from the beginning, and it's astonishingly accurate. The Times had an almost complete if maybe rough outline of the Ukraine scandal on day two after the first rumours, for example.
- seppin 7y ago> Re-read their coverage of both Mueller as well as the current Ukraine affair from the beginning, and it's astonishingly accurate. This is the thing I really don't understand about "fake news", if you found something wrong say so. Provide evidence it's wrong and confront them. If the news outlet is legit they will correct their mistakes. Mainstream news is overwhelmingly accurate and true.
- h2odragon 7y ago>drop the faux-contrarian cynicism. contrarian cynicism is all i do. there is nothing false about it, i assure you.