20 ms·
Google is finally killing off Chrome apps, which nobody really used
- jdlyga 7y agoThis really goes to show that if you're buying something for the potential of it, you're not always guaranteed to be an early adopter of a hot new trend or technology. Sometimes you are, but not always. You have to love what you're buying for what it can provide you right now.
- jamesgeck0 7y agoThis philosophy doesn't exactly work in this context; the devices are losing applications provided right now.
- Yuioup 7y agoWhat does this mean for the Outlook "App"?
- Eikon 7y agoI feel like chrome apps were actually ahead of their time and very much better than embedding a full browser per app with electron. Of course, they were not perfect but IHMO made much more sense than what we have today, at least on a technical standpoint and could have evolved into something truly great.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> I feel like chrome apps were actually ahead of their time and very much better than embedding a full browser per app with electron. > Of course, they were not perfect but IHMO made much more sense than what we have today, at least on a technical standpoint and could have evolved into something truly great. Killing Chrome Apps isn't about abandoning what they enabled, it's about moving it from Chrome App-specific capabilities to web platform capabilities. https://developers.chrome.com/apps/migration https://developers.chrome.com/apps/migration https://developers.google.com/web/updates/capabilities https://developers.google.com/web/updates/capabilities
- dtech 7y agoI.i.r.c. Chrome Apps are compiled binaries specific for Chrome (NaCL), they're more like Flash, Java or Webassembly applications.
- throw_m239339 7y agoChrome Apps are more like sandoxed Electron apps which do not require the user to install the same runtime every time for each app installed, unlike Electron. No need for NaCL, they can be written in Javascript.
- kgersen75 7y agono not at all. There are javascript+html+css apps that could use the Chrome API ( https://developer.chrome.com/apps/api_index https://developer.chrome.com/apps/api_index ) which allow them to do more than regular javascript+html+css web pages. There is no compilation.
- tyingq 7y agoNot NACL. JavaScript/HTML/CSS. But with access to local filesystems, sockets, etc. Because of that, Google's suggested replacement of Android Apps (won't work everywhere Chrome does) or PWAs/Extensions (both heavily sandboxed) doesn't work.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> I.i.r.c. Chrome Apps are compiled binaries specific for Chrome (NaCL), NaCl was supported in Chrome Apps, but most Chrome Apps are just web apps using the chrome.* APIs, not NaCl.
- funnygrass 7y agoIs this just a marketing move? Why is Google doing this? I also wonder how will this affect Chrome's market share. I think a lot of people appreciated the apps, especially the adblockers.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pauletienney 7y agoGoogle kills Chrome Apps, not Chrome extensions.
- funnygrass 7y agoYou're right, my bad. Sorry for the confusion.
- dindresto 7y agoNote that Chrome Apps != Progressive Web Apps, which you can still install on desktop Chrome and the new Edge and hopefully will gain more traction.
- techntoke 7y agoMy understanding is this is the direction they are heading and I don't see this as a bad move on their part for this reason. If they were getting rid of PWAs then I would be upset.
- tyingq 7y agoThere are some chrome apps that you can't do as a PWA or Chrome extension. For example, there's a local webserver that serves up a folder over http. https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/web-server-for-chrome/ofhbbkphhbklhfoeikjpcbhemlocgigb https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/web-server-for-chr...
- techntoke 7y agoA local web server is something that can easily be setup on desktop and mobile outside of Chrome.
- Shaddox 7y agoIt's a shame, really. I used to play Granblue Fantasy with their Chrome app. It was very convenient and accessible.
- hombre_fatal 7y agoI mean, it's right here: http://game.granbluefantasy.jp/ http://game.granbluefantasy.jp/
- wazoox 7y agoTypical Google move. I have a Chromebook. It was listed on the models that would support Android app, this support never came (it's still "planned", 2 years later...). Support for Linux apps didn't come, either. So now I suppose my Chromebook will be soon a useless brick. Thanks, Google. Got the message, I'll never use any product with your badge again.
- Kaiyou 7y agoYou say that, but you got a Chromebook despite everything Google did in the past. If people had gotten any message they'd have abandoned Google back in 2008.
- chongli 7y agoFirst they came for the Grand Central users, and I did not speak out— Because I was not a Grand Central user.
- slovenlyrobot 7y agoSpeaking just for one, I haven't adopted a new Google consumer product in 7 years. I don't even click the links. Pretty sure Reader had that effect on a large chunk of the technical base they previously relied heavily on.
- indy 7y agoShutting down Reader really did an oversized amount of damage to Google's reputation. I always found it surprising that Google wouldn't devote the engineering resources just to maintain Reader and not upset the influential people who relied upon it.
- misterman0 7y agoNo one is more influential than Google. - Google
- guggle 7y ago
- Twisell 7y agoPlease excuse this naive question, but what is the point of ChromeOS/ChromeBook then? If everything is now WebApp what's the point of an OS that can't run native App vs any other OS that can do both? I must be missing something???
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- SifJar 7y agolightweight/less bloat, lower resource requirements, generally reasonably cheap hardware
- dijit 7y agoI'm sure you mean this unironically, but chrome is by far the heaviest program that the majority of people run.
- dodobirdlord 7y agoWell, with a webapp solution the end user is at least likely to only be running chrome once, instead of once per electron app.
- g105b 7y agoChrome Apps were Google's idea of packaging websites as self-contained apps. They only worked within the Chrome web browser. Now, we have Progressive Web Apps, and Google have decided to promote using open standards to achieve the same goal, rather than offering a Chrome-only solution. Google have even released a migration guide (in 2016, when this was first announced): https://developers.chrome.com/apps/migration https://developers.chrome.com/apps/migration
- igravious 7y agoNearly every Chrome app is going to have an Android app counterpart I imagine. Chrome OS and Android are two competing platforms. Android took off and developers made zillions of Android apps, Chrome apps not so much. However Google has never shown any sign of abandoning Chromebooks. If anything, they're getting nicer and nicer and all new models run Android apps thus solving the app shortage problem on Chrome OS. Check out this review of Samsung's latest Chromebook at CES 2020 by Chrome Unboxed: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mD_m6-nLvfs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mD_m6-nLvfs (btw, I don't own a Chromebook, but I am a Linux fan, and so I'm glad Google have put their weight behind Linux with Android and Chrome OS)
- g105b 7y agoChrome Apps were Google's idea of packaging websites as self-contained apps. They only worked within the Chrome web browser. Now, we have Progressive Web Apps, and Google have decided to promote using open standards to achieve the same goal, rather than offering a Chrome-only solution. PWAs can be used to "install" applications on your desktop or Chromebooks that are almost identical in capability to Chrome Packaged Apps. In my view, this is a highly responsible move by Google in moving the web forwards via standards. Google have even released a migration guide (in 2016, when this was first announced): https://developers.chrome.com/apps/migration https://developers.chrome.com/apps/migration
- screye 7y agoIt is such decisions from Google that make me question if they will continue supporting GCP down the line. How will google pivot away when entire companies are dependent on their service staying up ? Sometimes I think Google should simply spin off less than super profitable ventures into a small company and host it under alphabet. As long as the service breaks even with employees working on Google wages, it can stay up. Once it goes into losses, the company can file for bankrupcy or move employees back to google.
- what_ever 7y agoYou should read the rest of the thread if this move makes you question Google supporting GCP. Disc: Googler.
- ArmandGrillet 7y agoI developed a few Chrome apps while I was in uni and what a pleasure. The APIs were easy to comprehend, the creation of an app running on any desktop OS only took a few minutes, I loved it. The lack of documentation from Google was already noticeable 4 years ago thus I'm not surprised about that move.
- jefftk 7y agoChrome Apps were a Chrome-only proprietary solution, and they're being replaced by Progressive Web Apps which work in other browsers as well. This is the sort of change we should be supporting! (Disclosure: I work at Google, not on Chrome)
- ilrwbwrkhv 7y agoNo I don't support pwas either.
- rpastuszak 7y agoWhy?
- nolok 7y agoDo you support X or support Y is not really what was being talked about, the question is from a starting point of X existing do you support it moving to Y (instead of remaining X). Moving from a proprietary to a shared/common system is an obvious move forward.
- pier25 7y agoSo PWAs will have support for Bluetooth and all the other features of Chrome apps?
- dragonwriter 7y agoThat's the broad idea of Google's Web Capabilities effort, “There are some apps that are not possible to build and deliver on the open web today. We call this, the app gap. The gap between what’s possible on the web and what’s possible on native. We want to close that gap. We believe web apps should be able to do anything native apps can.” https://developers.google.com/web/updates/capabilities https://developers.google.com/web/updates/capabilities
- pier25 7y ago> We believe web apps should be able to do anything native apps can It's a nice sentiment. Time will tell how that turns out.
- nova22033 7y agoWhen Google first announced all the way back in 2016 that it would end support for Chrome apps on Windows, macOS, and Linux, it said approximately one percent of users on those platforms were actively using packaged Chrome apps. The move was announced in 2016. Apps are used by 1% of users.
- throw_m239339 7y agoThat's still a shit load of users. Chrome claims it has 1 billion users, thats 10,000,000 users of chrome apps, 1/6 of the french population. Of course I myself never used them, I learned not to trust any Google product to begin with. These are the kind of decisions that will damage Google on the long run. I've heard that Stadia is not doing so well...
- djohnston 7y agoimagine relying on google to maintain a product in 2020
- damq 7y agoThey told you this was going to happen in 2016 and will continue to maintain it for another two years. If you still haven't found an alternative by then, that's on you.
- darkwizard42 7y agoNot really appropriate here. They announced this change to an open standard...in 2016.
- flokie 7y agoDoes anyone commenting on this thread even use a chrome app that's not just a wrapper on the site or a pwa? Just curious.
- pier25 7y agoI worked in edtech for a couple of years and we had our own Chrome app.
- chadlavi 7y agoI learned about the existence of these today, from this thread.
- crazygringo 7y agoFirst of all, this was announced more than 3 years ago, and it still won't happen for another 2.5 years. Second of all, this should be treated as good news for the HN crowd: Google is transitioning from a proprietary, Chrome-only app model to the open-standard, PWA model. Who doesn't support that? There are a bunch of "typical Google cancelling a product" comments here. But for real, I simply cannot imagine any Chrome app which people actually use, whose developer is not going to transition to PWA and gain a bigger market. Seriously, this is like complaining that Microsoft Edge doesn't support ActiveX controls. (And I certainly don't recall any complaints about that here.) This is good news, people. Less fragmentation and more open standards.
- jermaustin1 7y agoAs a person who uses the Hangouts chrome app daily, I have been expecting a day when I go to launch it and it wont open for the last 3 years. Google doesn't want to support "Classic Hangouts" anymore (and supposedly they killed it in October for GSuite, but not for my domain, I guess). Hangouts is one of the only ways I privately communicate with old friends and past co-workers since EVERYONE has at least one gmail account. And trying to get 20 people to switch to something else is a complete non-starter.
- skinkestek 7y ago> And trying to get 20 people to switch to something else is a complete non-starter. Eh. I participated in getting all my friends to start using WhatsApp and later to stop using it. Way more than 20.
- crazygringo 7y agoDoes hangouts.google.com not work for you? It works for me. You don't need an installable app to use it. And it works inside Gmail too, of course. (True, for companies Google's currently transitioning to the alternative "Hangouts Chat" which has enterprise features. But that's different from consumer Hangouts, and in any case obviously neither depends on Chrome Apps.)
- 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- est 7y agoThat's too bad. Chrome Apps allows TCP/UDP communication and it could create interesting apps.
- Jyaif 7y ago+1 I'm still using JSTorrent (https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/jstorrent/anhdpjpojoipgpmfanmedjghaligalgb?hl=en https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/jstorrent/anhdpjpo...). It's impossible to implement the BitTorrent protocol using a webapp, which means that once Chrome Apps are gone I'll have to revert to using a native client, which I don't trust one bit.
- techntoke 7y agoWhy do you think it is impossible. There are plenty of JS BitTorrent implementations.
- z3t4 7y agoThey however only work with other browser clients via webrtc p2p.
- ambrop7 7y agoIt could be done with a local TCP / UDP <=> WebSocket gateway, especially if it's written in a safe language like Rust.
- kevingadd 7y agoWhy use a webapp AND a local native gateway instead of just a native app? If your goal is to just not open any native win32/cocoa/etc UIs for some reason, there are existing native torrent clients with web interfaces served over http and those have been available for like a decade plus. Webapp + native gateway also means that the torrent traffic ends up being suspended/throttled if the tab isn't foregrounded or if you close it, something you wouldn't have to deal with if the native gateway was just a native torrent client. Chrome Apps had a background privileged context that could keep running even if no tabs were open (though Google naturally discouraged this unless the app needed it), something you can't really get with a PWA currently (though Service Workers come close if you keep the tab open, I think? Maybe?)
- nilsandrey 7y agoI'll miss GetPocket app, despite what the article said it works offline on Desktop. Anyone known about an alternative?
- somesortofsystm 7y agoI've bought a few Chrome apps over the years, but I don't like it. They've all disappeared, or no longer work. Its a worse user experience than plain ol' apps, imho. Definitely not good value for money when you can't even use the apps a year or so later ..
- factsaresacred 7y agoProbably as good a place as any to highlight how broken the Chrome extension approval process has become over the last month or so. Updates that would take an hour now take up to 10 days, including minor updates like a change to an extension's description. Having your deployment date be determined by one of Google's algorithms is ulcer-inducing. And the support is...well, see for yourself: https://groups.google.com/a/chromium.org/forum/#!forum/chromium-extensions https://groups.google.com/a/chromium.org/forum/#!forum/chrom... They can fix this. G Suite support is fine. I would pay for this process not to suck.
- gd2 7y agoI have Chromebooks. I'm now concerned and confused. The implications are not adequately explained.
- thinkloop 7y agoAny idea if this means they will also get rid of: "more tools" > "create shortcut" > "open as window" I use this exclusively and chromium is the only browser left that supports it.
- spondyl 7y ago> You probably aren't using Chrome apps anyway My coworker sitting to the left of me still uses the Chrome App version of Postman because it works, and hasn't stopped working. It has had an orange banner for the last year saying to upgrade but I'm pretty sure he never will, until it actually stops working. I think in his mind, the Chrome version is fine and ultimately, he'd be going through the install process then potentially moving his saved requests to what is essentially an identical copy of the exact same application
- somehnguy 7y agoI still use the Chrome app of Postman too. Reason is that I'm just used to it and it works perfectly fine for every use case I've had. I did install the new version but they changed the UI around a bunch and it kinda ticked me off because I was just trying to do some work, not relearn an app because they wanted it to be shinier looking.
- offmycloud 7y agoI believe that Authy has both a Chrome app and an extension.
- thrower123 7y agoI want to think that Postman was one of these, at least at one point. There may also have been a SQLite browser that I used briefly. Otherwise... yeah, I can't say that I remember using any of these. I think I'd rather have all of the Electron apps that I use now share a version of Chrome rather than each package the whole shebang themselves though.
- shecklestein 7y agoDoes this include Apollo client devtools???
- shecklestein 7y agoWhat about apollo dev tools?
- SahAssar 7y agoTip: theverge (like medium, etc.) is one of those sites that is better without JS.