8 ms·
CollegeHumor is blaming this on Facebook for faking viewership numbers. This isn't the first time Facebook killed culture, and it won't be the last. We really
by echelon 7y ago
CollegeHumor is blaming this on Facebook for faking viewership numbers.
This isn't the first time Facebook killed culture, and it won't be the last.
We really need to de-platform or find a way Facebook can't steal value.
- Zhyl 7y agoSome content creators are already doing this. I'm seeing more spinning up their own newsletters or RSS feeds, patreons, direct donations, subscriptions services (or completely independent platforms). There is an awareness of the dangers of putting your eggs in one basket, let alone the dangers of putting them in a basket as opaque and uncertain as Facebook. CollegeHumor had a lot of hits and spawned some genuine talent that is now earning money on its own merits (Jake and Amir, Adam Conover) but overall the content was not consistent enough to have an overall draw that was worth subscribing to.
- ConsiderCrying 7y agoThe problem with Patreon is that it's also getting quite bad for content creators (at least there were a lot of complaints about half a year ago) with the cut they take, the money transfers, and the fact that they've tried to ban adult content creators. It would have been fine if this was all stated/implemented right away but, much like many other platforms, they're doing this at a slow creep. There are alternatives but they're coming up against a well-known name and stifling competition, same problem as with Facebook, just on a smaller scale.
- bordercases 7y agoDoes this make an argument for crypto?
- bpt3 7y agoNo, it does not in my opinion. What problem described above would crypto solve?
- endothrowho333 7y agoPatreon taking a cut and not allowing adult content. Payment processing and facilitating has tangible expenses (cost) and payment processors do not want to get involved with any companies involved with sordid industries (higher fraud). Patreon adopting crypto cuts out the middleman processor and solves both problems. But crypto ia too user-unfriendly at the moment, so usage would be very limited.
- beckingz 7y agoCrypto transfer costs on small payments are higher than traditional payment networks.
- ConsiderCrying 7y agoA more approachable solution (for the general public, at least) would be a payment processing service that takes the risk of working with adult content creators. But that seems like a tall ask, especially for a problem that's pretty niche. Porn makes a lot of money, but not for the people who're just handling the payments. Or, rather, it might make them a good amount but it's probably the same as the profit from other industries, except with added risk.
- endothrowho333 7y agoThey exist and already make a killing. The problem is that when Patreon allows high risk activities, those activities poison the well, and all "legit" processors must stop offering their services. Thereby, Patreon is now left with using more high-risk-tolerant processors, but paying the same high fees for all activities regardless of its actual risk.
- bpt3 7y ago> Patreon taking a cut and not allowing adult content. That's an issue with the payment manager, not the currency used for payment. > Payment processing and facilitating has tangible expenses (cost) and payment processors do not want to get involved with any companies involved with sordid industries (higher fraud). I agree completely. > Patreon adopting crypto cuts out the middleman processor and solves both problems. I disagree here. Presumably, the assessment that adult content is higher risk is valid, and Patreon would just assume that risk themselves if they didn't involve a third party payment processor, regardless of the currency used for payment. Is your claim that fraud would be reduced because there's no real way to reverse a crypto transaction at the moment? If so, my stance is that accepting crypto would just open them up to other issues associated with fraud, and wouldn't be worth the effort. > But crypto ia too user-unfriendly at the moment, so usage would be very limited. I agree with this as well, which is another reason crypto isn't the solution here.
- ohithereyou 7y agoCash in the mail will always be king. (Not literal cash in most cases - postal money order or personal check. Most banks will cut and mail a paper check as part of online bill pay for free. The unbanked and anyonmous can send cash.)
- catalogia 7y agoMany people might mail cash once, but how many will remember to mail cash on a regular schedule? Without that regularity, you're going to have a lot of creators worrying about whether or not they'll be able to pay their rent/mortgage next month.
- allovernow 7y ago>It would have been fine if this was all stated/implemented right away but, much like many other platforms, they're doing this at a slow creep I think this is a consequence of the nature of the tech industry. It is acceptable to lure customers in with ultra favorable terms, operate at a loss until your consumers are captive, potentially destroying competitors in the process, then gradually exploit your increasingly unhappy userbase. I imagine we have had anti-anticompetitive laws against at least some of these practices for decades, but the old farts responsible for legislation and justice are slow to catch up to tech's tricks.
- coldpie 7y ago> newsletters or RSS feeds I'm still miffed that Firefox (et al) nuked the RSS feed button in the URL bar. RSS has a lot of problems, but we could have improved it instead of just giving up entirely in the face of shitty closed platforms like FB, Twitter, etc.
- kpennell 7y agosubstack FTW
- slg 7y agoFacebook faking viewership numbers is really an under-reported story. So many publishing companies had moderately successful business models. Then Facebook came along with their amazing viewership numbers. Everyone "pivoted to video", switched to targeting native Facebook views, and chasing those unbelievable viewership totals. The views ended up being well lower than reported which means the promising revenue never materialized like expected. By the time companies realized this, it was too late to pivot back to hosting their content on their own site because the behavior of their users had already been broken by Facebook. This destroyed countless publishers including CollegeHumor and the similar Funny or Die. It is amazing that Facebook only paid a $40m settlement for this fraud.
- amylene 7y agoI am out of the loop, what were the Metrics that FB falsified? And how did they falsify them before the video was hosted on their site? Just trying to understand how their game numbers caused this post, and I can’t seem to make it connect.
- trickjarrett 7y agoAdam Conover (Adam Ruins Everything guy) tweeted a good thread that explains this: https://twitter.com/adamconover/status/1183209875859333120 https://twitter.com/adamconover/status/1183209875859333120
- eitland 7y agoIf I read this correctly I'm not the only one who shys away from video content? If this is the fact, does that mean we can get plain text back?
- veb 7y agoTalking about an interesting side-effect about videos in social media in recent times is they've learned to put text (or captions) in their videos for people (because they might have sound off) which made it far easier for deaf people to understand them! For which I am glad, but I barely use Facebook these days at all - just messenger.com
- macspoofing 7y ago>CollegeHumor is blaming this on Facebook for faking viewership numbers. Facebook should certainly be held responsible for their part, but let's not let CollegeHumor of the hook. In the end, they are responsible for their business, and moving to an unproven platform is very risky no matter what promises FB sales people tell you.
- neaden 7y agoThat's ridiculous. If someone commits fraud and you believe them that is their fault, not yours for being a victim.
- macspoofing 7y agoI'm not saying you don't hold FB responsible for lying. If they made false promises they should be sued and the courts should make a proper judgement. Having said that, if you're CollegeHumor, what you can't do is abrogate responsibility for your business decisions, one of which is risking your entire business on an unproven video platform based on the promises of FB salespeople. You still have a responsibility to validate the platform and not just be a fully trusting stooge. It's like a pedestrian crossing the street when the light is green. The pedestrian should still look both ways, even if they are in the right because it's no consolation to be dead and correct.
- dave5104 7y agoFacebook was found responsible for lying. They were sued, and the courts did make a judgment--not sure if it was exactly proper or not. They simply paid a $40m fine. https://fortune.com/2019/10/07/facebook-lawsuit-settlement-inflated-video-data-advertisers/ https://fortune.com/2019/10/07/facebook-lawsuit-settlement-i...
- munk-a 7y agoI am sure CH had some serious numbers people watching FB as they initially tried it out and then over the longer term - the issue is that FB outright lied about numbers in a very misleading manner that has been found to have been fraudulent. It's quite possible CH could discover this via revenue attribution but you need to be paranoid enough to do a deep dive into the numbers to actually confirm that and, TBH, it's generally irresponsible for businesses to invest that heavily into revenue auditing when they don't have strong suspicions about their revenue stability. It's likely that CH specifically erred in acting overly bullish on early numbers back from FB, seeing the view trend they wanted to capitalize on what seemed to be a very strong market and be an early entrant - FB vastly inflated their numbers but even without that aiming to dominate an early market is always quite risky due to the lack of proof around the long term stability of the market... that sort of over-investment would usually result in a contraction to appropriate size along with a loss of fluidity for a company, it's only game ending when the market is committing outright fraud.
- rchaud 7y agoPlatform giveth, platform taketh away. There used to be a time where you actually had to go to collegehumor.com to watch the videos. Once everyone turned into sharecroppers on FB, Youtube or whatever, this was the risk they took.
- RandomBacon 7y agoIF Facebook didn't fake their numbers, then I would be inclined to agree.
- jsight 7y agoDoes it really matter? Why switch just for view numbers without a revenue model?
- maemilius 7y agoView numbers were the revenue model. Eyeballs make money for advertisers. The more eyeballs, the more money.
- manigandham 7y agoIt didn't work out that way. The vast majority of these publishers were chasing views without any increase in monetization from their direct-sold campaigns. Add in the increasing cost to promote video on FB itself and they were constantly losing more money.
- jsight 7y agoIf they were selling ads themselves that might make sense. But since they were planning to rely on the platform for ad revenue, I'd think they'd want to know others revenue experiences first. Ad revenue and eyeballs don't correlate well across different platforms, as some are better at selling ads than others.
- linuxftw 7y agoI agree. They deserve to fail. They had a major hand in the consolidation of the internet onto the major platforms.
- justinhj 7y agoThere are so many ways to make money without going near Facebook that this is a terrible excuse. If you have good content that brings in viewers there will be a way to monetize. Nobody is driving good content off the internet, collegehumor simply didn't keep up with what people wanted.
- geddy 7y ago> This isn't the first time Facebook killed culture You know, I never really thought about it this way, but the way you worded it is perfect. I talk about the "good old days" of the Internet, and it always comes down to Facebook ruining everything. I'd pin it around 2012. You're spot on though - Facebook outright murders internet culture. God, I despise that company and what it stands for so much.
- Zak 7y agoOne of the things I miss that Facebook killed is... Facebook. Prior to its attempt to dominate media sharing on the internet, most of the content I saw on Facebook was created by people I know, about their personal lives. People share far less content of that sort now, and the algorithm doesn't prioritize it when they do. Personal updates from people I actually know are probably reduced by an order of magnitude from a decade ago. If I want to see funny stuff, cat videos, news, political memes, pictures of food, or anything else of that sort, reddit serves much better than Facebook. Nothing has come along to fill the gap for many-to-many personal updates though, and I miss that. There's a startup opportunity here. The hard part isn't technical - something resembling the Facebook of a decade ago wouldn't be hard to build - but attracting a critical mass of users would be a significant challenge.
- mrtksn 7y agoOh definitely, FB was the most amazing thing that I have ever seen for a few years. Instagram or any other social network never gave me the kick that FB used to give. It was like a new ability to browse the lives of the people you know. I don't know what happen, maybe there's no money in this service maybe people simply got bored with each other's ordinary life.
- Zak 7y agoI know what happened: Facebook decided to emphasize published content instead. There's evidently more money in that. As a result, the algorithm is less likely to show my friends if I post a picture of my lunch, we're less likely to have a conversation in the comments about recipes or restaurants, and I'm less likely to bother posting the next one.
- shadowgovt 7y agoI'm extremely torn between "This is an outrage" and "Buyer beware." Nobody forced College Humor, Funny or Die, or any of the other companies that shifted resources to believe Facebook. They took a calculated market risk and the gamble didn't pay off (and they don't have enough reserve capital to survive a failed gamble). In an ideal market, the back-stop on this behavior would be "Nobody trusts Facebook's self-reported numbers moving forward." Is that a sufficient back-stop, or should there be (further) government intervention?
- reaperducer 7y agoNobody forced College Humor, Funny or Die, or any of the other companies that shifted resources to believe Facebook. Yep. Their mistake was they believed the hype. A bunch of publishers did. "Facebook is the future!" and 90% of newsrooms started pushing their original content to Facebook, sacrificing their own ad views. Fortunately, most of the big J players have seen the folly in this already and reversed course. Usually they build their own platform because they have many media properties. But I see a lot of small market and independent publishers still stuck in the "Facebook is king" mentality because of middle managers who are still stuck in the old echo chamber.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- munk-a 7y agoNope nobody forced them to compete on FB. They would've been quite silly had they not at least tried to capture the FB market - but I think the false reporting of views is something that really shocked the folks trying to balance the books - their videos still seemed to be performing great while the revenue was slowing down. FB isn't responsible for tempting CH over (and CH made the right choice giving it a try) but FB is responsible for viewership reporting that borders on fraudulent as they try to boost their own overall numbers.
- bsder 7y ago> Nope nobody forced them to compete on FB. I actually disagree. Both Facebook and YouTube were almost certainly causing video view numbers on video websites like these to decrease. The problem is: what do you do? You can pivot to YouTube or Facebook and become a sharecropper like the 9 zillion other sharecroppers or ... die. While people complain that CollegeHumor should have held out, I don't see anybody who held out doing any better.
- tracker1 7y agoEven then, it's not like they've been doing that well on YouTube... I mean, you can only do the same tired millennial jokes so many times, as much as I like bashing millennial culture, it's tired and played out. Aside: If Google Was a Guy series is one of the funniest things online. A lot of their efforts just don't land very well. Compare this to say RoosterTeeth (Red vs. Blue, RWBY and others) has done very well in terms of adapting overall, including a couple movie releases (not huge, but out there).
- munk-a 7y agoThis is going more toward critiquing the content rather than the business which I think is less interesting to discuss on HN, but I wanted to voice that they've put out a lot of interesting stuff - a quite high quality RPG series in Dimension20 along with both short form videos (like A message from the CEO of _____) and longer form vignettes like their summercamp series - I have been pretty appreciative with just how experimental they've gotten lately and I would disagree strongly that they painted themselves into a single formula.
- gowld 7y agoCH has vastly more programs than RT, so the fact that some are better and some are worse doesn't mean much.
- yardie 7y ago> CollegeHumor is blaming this on Facebook for faking viewership numbers. This is fraud and Facebook employees should feel threatened about going to jail. This was not a sleazy sales pitch. This was outright fraud to convince content producers that they were making more money than they actually were.
- gowld 7y agoHow did FB lie about how much money they were making? Views aren't money.