4 ms·
> But replacing it would require hundreds or thousands of banks to agree a new standard The Brazilian banks got their hand forced into changing their system re
by marcosdumay 7y ago
> But replacing it would require hundreds or thousands of banks to agree a new standard
The Brazilian banks got their hand forced into changing their system recently, but this one feature stayed exactly the same way.
Hell, if you take enough details out, it is exactly the same as a two passes commit we use in distributed databases, where there is a single team (often a single person) defining the behavior.
Don't expect that one complexity to go away any time soon.
- avianlyric 7y agoIt’s frustrating because the two pass commit only really exists as a result of slow and expensive communication channels in the past. Many payment schemes were built with idea that messages would be sent via post (on big tape reels) or expensive internet connections that can’t be run 24/7. However none of these constraints really exist anymore. Which means that you can move money using a single message and synchronous communications, with a little protection to deal with the two generals problem.
- mixmastamyk 7y agoWhat happens when the com lines are down during a storm? Will this single message still work?
- egwor 7y agohow many messages a second can be handled synchronously? what happens if the message arrives twice? what happens if the data centre is blown up/goes up in flames? how did the other data centre guarantee to be in a consistent state? how did the backup system automatically take over? These systems have to be up and running all the time and there can't be an option for mistakes!
- avianlyric 7y agoWhen I say message I’m think of the equivalent of a TCP packet. So you have a bunch of error checking and ACKs flying about. But only one message to actually move money. Single message systems already exist, most US card transactions move over a single message system. > there can’t be an option for mistakes! This is where you’re wrong. Mistakes happen all the time when moving money, a big part of any banks operations is cleaning up those mistakes.
- marcus_holmes 7y agoand yet the rest of the world manages to do this instantly