4 ms·
The problem with this, which I learned about in grade school with bullies, is that it works only if the people are rational actors. If they don't understand the
by Waterluvian 7y ago
The problem with this, which I learned about in grade school with bullies, is that it works only if the people are rational actors. If they don't understand the principles at work or don't care, the whole thing falls apart. You just need inmates who roll the dice or don't care, or bullies who cannot contemplate mutually assured destruction and your strategy completely falls apart.
- itronitron 7y agoAlways and inevitably everyone underestimates the number of stupid individuals in circulation. https://www.academia.edu/11274021/Cipolla_-The_Basic_Laws_of_Human_Stupidity https://www.academia.edu/11274021/Cipolla_-The_Basic_Laws_of...
- nspassov 7y agoThis is a great book, thanks for sharing!
- dredmorbius 7y agoDirect download: http://www.academia.edu/download/36859613/Cipolla_-The_Basic_Laws_of_Human_Stupidity.pdf http://www.academia.edu/download/36859613/Cipolla_-The_Basic...
- recuter 7y agoPeople can be made rational. For the sake of discussion; One could watch new inmates like a hawk for an initial probationary period and enact disciplinary action should they reveal themselves as described. In fact, taking the idea to its (awful) logical conclusion, randomly enacting disciplinary action in the initial period regardless of inmate behaviour would prove effective. "Beatings will continue until morale improves" I believe is the saying.
- catalogia 7y agoI think rationality is something that needs to be deliberately exercised, particularly when in emotionally stressful situations. Even if you can teach a thick headed bully to be rational, that doesn't mean you can count on him not having moments of irrationality. In truth, I doubt anybody can manage to remain rational at all times.
- eps 7y agoThis ain't gonna work well. If there's a pattern, it will be identified and exploited. New inmates being under closer observation or duress is a pattern, easy to spot and easy to test.
- pure-awesome 7y agoPeople may call it "stupid" but as a meta-strategy or species strategy or whatever, it's actually pretty effective. There are actually plenty of adversarial situations in which it's beneficial to give yourself a handicap in order to win. If you're playing "chicken" (where you drive cars at each other and whoever turns away first loses) you can blindfold yourself and remove the steering wheel. If you're doing Mutually Assured Destruction, you can set up an automatic retaliation system which you are unable to pause or cancel. By removing some of your options, you can effectively signal to your opponents so that they are forced to respond to your strategy. Similarly, it can be beneficial to act "irrationally", because if your opponents are rational actors, they won't even try the strategy against you. E.g. If I know you will "irrationally" come for revenge after the fact even to your own detriment despite the fact that it won't fix anything, I might not try something against you in the first place.
- itronitron 7y ago>> it can be beneficial to act "irrationally" I have seen this pursued with gusto as a career development strategy on occasion and it works rather well unfortunately. The basic approach is to be so outlandish, unprofessional, and unreliable that capable and rational colleagues will pick up the slack, confident that the crazy person will be quickly gotten rid of due to their bad behavior, however that very rarely happens. The irrational actor ends up being promoted because they are the most visible person on the project as everyone else is in hiding in anticipation of a shit-storm.
- raxxorrax 7y agoI have seen that too. Some even got promoted to break in some hardened structures in companies. It can have appeal to some. And there is the fact that the standard 100% professional corporate culture is extremely unappealing and in contrast to such behavior.
- IAmEveryone 7y agoThat sounds more like an application of signaling theory, I e. “They must be very smart to be allowed this behavior”. The canonical example for OP is the “mad man” strategy Reagoj supposedly followed.