4 ms·
They also must show that tests ordered on their sites have been at the request of a doctor, as required by state law Does anyone else find this to be an absurd
by Zak 18y ago
They also must show that tests ordered on their sites have been at the request of a doctor, as required by state law
Does anyone else find this to be an absurd intrusion of the government in to the rights of individuals to learn about their own medical conditions? For those of you who live there, rumor has it, California has a pretty effective voter refferendum system....
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- timr 18y agoIt's really not absurd. The problem with these tests is that they can be extremely difficult to interpret, tricky to run correctly, and bad/incorrect results can easily lead to drastic consequences (i.e. expensive follow-up tests and procedures). These companies are effectively selling medical equipment, but so far, they've side-stepped the usual regulations by selling direct-to-consumer. It was inevitable that this situation would change.
- natrius 18y agoIf I think I can interpret them correctly, I should be allowed to get the tests done, regardless of what the government thinks about it. Stick a disclaimer on them if you must, but prohibiting the request of such tests by laypeople is fundamentally illiberal.
- timr 18y agoIt's not just the interpretation that's important. Medical tests are carefully regulated and tested to ensure that they're accurate. These "tests" are not. In other words, this argument gets filed in the same bin as those that would suggest that FDA regulation of food and drugs is overbearing, and that we should all be allowed to eat whatever we want. It goes beyond personal choice; it's a matter of public health.
- jey 18y agoOK, so legislate the need for accuracy through licensing, etc -- I don't see how a doctor's order would make the test more accurate.
- timr 18y agoPart of the problem is that these tests aren't for specific diseases, and really can't be made more accurate. Nobody knows what these genetic association studies mean on a clinical level. For example, if a woman is found to have a SNP marker that is associated with breast cancer, you might conclude that she shouldn't take birth control, since that raises the risk. But what if she also has a marker associated with ovarian cancer? Hormone therapy helps with that. What then? There are dozens of stories like this one, and even doctors are over their heads when it comes to this stuff. There's absolutely no chance that a layperson is going to be able to interpret the data of such a clinically dubious test. It may not be the best idea to enforce a doctor's order for these things, but there's a legitimate argument to be made, and it goes well beyond a simplistic interpretation of personal liberty. If enough people shell out for these scans, it's going to cause panic, over-medication and over-utilization of the medical system. Again, it's a question of public health. But don't take my word for it...here's a great editorial with some even better examples of the problems: http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/opinion/2004425391_geneticsop20.html http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/opinion/2004425391_gen...
- Zak 18y agoThe tests for various SNP markers can be verified as accurate or not. The interpretation of the presence of a given marker may be up for debate, and these companies should not be making exaggerated claims about the ability of these tests to predict a person's risks for specific diseases. In short, if something should be regulated here, it's the claims these companies make about the value of the tests.
- rms 18y agoThey make little or no claim about the value of the tests. The argument against what they are doing is saying that offering any information about disease risk is an inherently medical topic.