3 ms·
An interesting speculative-fiction writing prompt: performance-based compensation gets declared illegal. All salespeople instantly change careers, because, with
by derefr 7y ago
An interesting speculative-fiction writing prompt: performance-based compensation gets declared illegal. All salespeople instantly change careers, because, without performance-based compensation, their jobs are awful and they hate them. Every company in every market suddenly has to get by without the ability to actively get their products into people's hands.
What happens next?
- dbspin 7y agoThe world is vastly improved as all search results are now 'organic', and people find the products they need without being bombarded with advertising and cheap behavioral economic manipulations to encourage them to purchase products and services they don't need.
- derefr 7y agoI think you're thinking of marketers/advertisers, who are not, in fact, compensated based on performance.
- notfromhere 7y agoThat’s not true. Marketers these days increasingly have revenue targets
- derefr 7y agoTarget-based compensation (i.e. “getting a bonus if the project succeeds”) and performance-based compensation (i.e. “working on commission”) are different things. One directly rewards effort; the other (mostly) rewards office-politicking, by e.g. finding your way onto projects on the cusp of success.
- notfromhere 7y agoNo. Lots of marketing is directly tied to revenue generated and get compensated on their direct ability to generate pipeline. It's directly tied to performance.
- krageon 7y agoIs there a location that you can attach to this state of affairs? Because it's definitely not true where I live and work.
- pjlegato 7y agoThis in fact happened in Russia in the early 20th century. The results were, among other things: - allocation of resources happened through centralized planning committees of credentialed supposed experts, rather than organically by decentralized market forces checked and balanced automatically via competition among the actors, leading to huge economic inefficiencies. Perpetual shortages of consumer goods, and at times even basic foodstuffs. 10+ year waits to get a car. Hours-long lines for bread. - a massive increase in corruption, bribery, and influence trading (collectively known as блат, "favors"[1]), as people turned to unofficial backchannels to further the economic interests of themselves and their organization, since there were no effective legal channels to do so anymore; - concominant erosion of any notion of popular respect for doing things properly or legally. There simply was no legal way to advance your own economic position. - The expansion of an institutionalized system of severe punishments to force people to work productively at their jobs anyway, absent any possible reward.[3] - Eventually, economic and technological stagnation[2]. With no legal economic reward possible for working harder, trying new things, or improving conditions, why bother? Your salary is the same if you succeed, and you'll be punished severely for counterrevolutionary activity if you fail. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blat_(favors) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blat_(favors) [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Era_of_Stagnation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Era_of_Stagnation [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gulag https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gulag
- foobarian 7y agoThe aggressive performance-based compensation loving go-getters become mercenaries or warlords or gangsters just like they used to be in the medieval times and we are all worse off. I think this is one often underappreciated quality of the corporate world - an outlet for people who would otherwise cause a lot more direct harm.
- krageon 7y ago> and we are all worse off It's possible they'll do it in a specific area that isn't where everyone is (or that is where most people are not). I'd argue that we would be collectively better off in that case.