4 ms·
I think those with a programming background take terms like "no code" far too literally. For those who've worked in finance IT, you may know of staff who've bui
by rchaud 7y ago
I think those with a programming background take terms like "no code" far too literally. For those who've worked in finance IT, you may know of staff who've build incredibly elaborate models in Excel, and then have come to you when they need something that can't be done in Excel.
"No code platforms" will likely work the same way. These platforms provide just enough interactive/dynamic functionality for non-programmers to build a decent prototype of what they're trying to create. They can then take this to their dev team (if they have one) and ask for refinements.
Even if the end result requires a full rebuild, I'd wager the devs would be happier because they wouldn't waste time building something based on vague specifications communicated by a non-technical staff member. They'd have a prototype to work off of, and can ask clarifying questions that will be easier for the stakeholder to answer because they can see where the devs are coming from, instead of simply speaking in abstractions about something that doesn't yet exist.
- flarg 7y agoI have spent 5 years on and off in the no code space and IMHO you're almost spot on. Almost all standard enterprise platforms are non complex and can be delivered in no code solutions, requiring maybe 5pc as real code. Failing to acknowledge this is why IT organisations in large enterprises are typically sidelined by shadow IT teams, who often deliver great solutions in Excel and Oracle Apex.
- delusional 7y agoI've spent 2 years in a fairly large bank, and I heavily disagree. We have tons of procedures and edge cases that are subtlely unique. Our problem is purely one of speed. When there's 3 quarters and 5 org layers between you and the developer, you are much more likely to just grab a tool you have access to and get to work.
- bcrosby95 7y ago"Shadow IT" teams are great at delivering solutions quickly because their clients tends to be themselves. When you're writing solutions for your own problems you're cutting out multiple communication layers which will reduce the effort involved by several orders of magnitude. Also by not making it an "official" project you can cut through lots of red tape and requirements not related to the problem at hand.
- gnud 7y agoA large part of my job is writing custom logic for an enterprise application with much-touted "no-code" facilities. You _always_ need code. Some customers don't need much, but they all need _some_. The first example that comes to mind is duplicate detection. Sure, the basics are simple. No two agreements of the same kind for the same customer. A lot of no-code solutions struggle at this point. But then you get to the slightly more complex requirements. You _can_ have two agreements of the same kind for the same customer, as long as they are not overlapping in time. But if customer B is a subsidiary of A, and A already has the agreement, then B cannot have its own, if A's agreement is marked "company-wide". This also goes for C, which is a subsidiary of B. I've yet to see a no-code solution that makes this sort of thing accessible to non-programmers. And programmers will prefer just writing the code.
- matwood 7y agoIMO, Excel was one of the first 'no code' platforms. The first part of my career was taking Excel solutions and turning them into something that could used corporate wide. It was pretty fun because by the time it got to my team, the requirements were pretty well hammered out.
- hinkley 7y agoI worked with or around a number of people who had to productize an Excel spreadsheet when the team got a little too big for that to work and everyone was always surprised by how long it takes to recreate all of the functionality they had built up in Excel. When Oracle bought Sun and got Open Office people as part of the deal, I thought for sure that Larry had some plan for an Excel killer to make it quicker to transition people out of Excel into relational databases. I kept waiting for the other shoe to drop and it never arrived.
- coffee 7y ago> I think those with a programming background take terms like "no code" far too literally. Agreed. Poor term. But what these platforms can accomplish is liberating for those who can't code yet want to get something live on their own.
- aylmao 7y agoI agree with this, but it also means the hype is overdone, because these "no-code" tools that are gonna "revolutionize the industry" have been here for ages. For example in the web space, Microsoft took a stab at it with FrontPage since the 90s. WordPress was released in 2003 and sits behind a third of websites [1]. New tools are popping up that are more complex, but IMO that's because people's expectations of a good web experience is also more complex. I am unconvinced that new tools in this space are fundamentally changing it— I think they're just keeping it up with the times. [1]: https://wordpress.org/news/2019/03/one-third-of-the-web/ https://wordpress.org/news/2019/03/one-third-of-the-web/