6 ms·
The low unemployment rate is proof that this techno optimism isn’t true.
by rayiner 7y ago
The low unemployment rate is proof that this techno optimism isn’t true.
- contingencies 7y agoOr, perhaps, has society failed to adapt to present technological reality due to entrenched interest in the social status quo? When so many people in the world live happily on so little, it is undeniable that we could provide for all of our basic needs if there were political will. Without education, that would likely result in a population boom, however.
- rayiner 7y agoI mean yes, we could all live like people do in Bangladesh and reduce the work force dramatically. I fail to see how this would be desirable.
- contingencies 7y agoYou present a false (and somewhat offensive) dichotomy. Here are some more optimistic ideas. If we reconsidered vehicles, everyone could have access to them when desired. If we reconsidered city layouts, everyone could have a home with desired proximity to others without needing to sacrifice either nature or privacy. If we reconsidered education, medical care and communications infrastructure, they would be universally available and effectively free (indeed, in many places these are already the case). If we reconsidered politics, we could encourage global industry toward environmentally sustainable outcomes without irreversible disaster.
- tomp 7y agoThese ideas are beyond delusional (in today's world). > everyone could have access to [vehicles] when desired Uber is trying to do this, but has a lot of problems, from unpredictable pricing, surge pricing, long wait times, shitty drivers, chatty drivers (?), seats with puke all over them, ... self-driving cars could solve some, but not all of these problems. > everyone could have a home with desired proximity to others No, the reason real estate in e.g. NYC is so expensive is that everybody wants to live there! The only way to fix this is to fundamentally decentralize our economy and education systems, but that's a whole lot more complicated than "city layouts". > [education, medical care and communications infrastructure] would be universally available and effectively free Maybe education and communications, but with medical care almost certainly not... The main issue is that medicine doesn't save people's lives, it just prolongs them, and that can always be done better... So fundamentally, the demand for medicine is unlimited, whereas the supply (doctors) is limited, so whatever system of "free and universally available" system you design, there's going to be tradeoffs. Tradeoffs like, "do I fix my teeth or my eyes" and someone is going to have to make that choice. Personally, I'd prefer that to be me (with my money) rather than my government.
- contingencies 7y agoIt is true, perfection shall remain elusive. You can't please all of the people all of the time. That said, more equitable systems with far higher qualities in terms of environmental impact, resource consumption and sustainability, as well as fundamental service availability are clearly within reach. You raise a particularly good point about the overall properties of systems for mass medical care, but people don't live forever. Cancer is one answer. Solutions that reduce or delay post-facto treatment with holistic and pre-emptive approaches (better regulation, better education, better diets/life choices) may be another.
- jonfw 7y agoThese are very optimistic ideas. But good ideas are actionable. Do you have any of those?
- contingencies 7y agoSure. Wikiprojects (admin), cryptocurrency (exchange architect), open source (contributor/maintainer), currently working on kiosk format automated fulfillment of personalized meals directly from fresh ingredients (as an entrepreneur with my own money on the line) to contribute to food safety/security challenges (and hopefully recover costs). What about you?
- ngold 7y agoThe one war america fought but never bothered winning. The war on Poverty.
- harryh 7y agoLBJ and the Great Society won the war on poverty in America. https://twitter.com/Noahpinion/status/1205596833692565504 https://twitter.com/Noahpinion/status/1205596833692565504 "The economists find that by the standards of LBJ's time, the U.S. poverty rate has dropped from 19.5 % in 1963 to just 2.3% in 2017!!" If that's not winning, I don't know what is.
- sokoloff 7y agoThat's the beauty (to some) and problem (to others) with the definition of poverty: we keep moving the goalposts/standards.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI so hate the phrase "war on poverty." It tends to de facto turn poor people into The Enemy in the mind's of far too many people.
- craftinator 7y agoThat would be another way of lowering the percentage of people living in poverty.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoYes, please, just take us all out and shoot us for our war crimes of failing to be as wildly successful as we would like to be. (Please don't tell me this needs a sarcasm tag. If you can't tell in this case, then I think it's utterly hopeless.)
- AdrianB1 7y agoBecause that is not a war and there is no win, poverty is a moving target and it will always be, unless forced equality is imposed to everybody.
- threatofrain 7y agoBut the thing is if the markets really couldn't find any value in the output of nearly everyone, we shouldn't see this high percentage of employment -- not unless one also believes that employers in a decentralised way are implementing their own informal UBI, perhaps out of consensus on political theory or moral values. One might say a simpler explanation is that employee output is still interesting, and that what's interesting isn't just technological output, and that the bulk of interesting technological work isn't about advancement but delivery to the world.
- hacknat 7y agoMost companies operate within a market, but don’t, themselves, operate like a market (internally). Have you really not heard any duck and cover stories from corporate America? It absolutely is easy for incompetent people to remain employed. Talented people tend to job hop to realize their increased utility (not always, but mostly), while incompetence gets promoted at the 50% of companies that cannot compete in the labor market.
- carlmr 7y agoAlso not to forget a middle manager may want the feeling of power, which they could derive from having more people below them. Humans aren't rational.
- tempsy 7y agoHuh? No it’s not. He is exactly right that we’ve invented a lot of “bullshit jobs” that don’t add anything of value to society and would not change anything if they were gone tomorrow e.g. How many jobs out there just prop up rent seeking?
- rayiner 7y agoThe whole idea of “bullshit jobs” is ignorant. You’ve got armies of managers and bean counters trying to squeeze nickels out of processes, and yet we are supposed to believe that we’re keeping all of these people employed for no reason? It’s the same sort of juvenile thinking that causes someone to look at a vast legacy codebase and decide “oh we could easily rewrite that.” The reality is that automation is progressing as fast as technology allows, but technology just doesn’t work that well. In fast food, for example, self-order touch screens are vastly inferior to a trained order taker. There are no machines to roll a burrito. There’s no machines to wipe tables, clean bathrooms, clean the kitchen, or even take drive through orders. We don’t, get, have automated ubers, taxis, freight trucks, etc. Grocery checkout automation is atrocious, which is why higher end chains like Whole Foods don’t have them, even though they’re better able to afford automation. There’s not a single job I can think of that qualifies as a “bullshit job.”
- tempsy 7y agoI’m not talking about service jobs. I wouldn’t consider service workers to be rent seekers at all. I’m actually referring to mostly white collar ones, a lot of administration jobs, finance, government, etc
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoThese jobs may be bullshit in the feelings they induce in people performing them, or the meaning those people give their jobs, but they are probably not bullshit in the utility they have for the organizations that pay for them.
- 7y ago
- JDiculous 7y agoNo it's not. Low unemployment is a result of a system that forces people into employment to make a living (not to mention how skewed the statistics are when they consider part-time workers seeking full-time opportunities as "employed" and exclude disparaged workers).
- hacknat 7y agoNot at all, a lot of the work being done is probably having a minimal or, even negative, impact upon the overall economy. Labor productivity is low, because the Pareto distribution of productivity across individuals is at historically staggering proportions right now.
- kelnos 7y agoI think it proves -- or at least suggests -- the opposite of what you think. If we have low unemployment, but a lot of low-end jobs don't pay a living wage and people have to work multiple jobs at greater than 40 hours per week to make ends meet, that points to the work being so low-value that maybe it just doesn't need to be done, or that we'd be better served automating it. The logical extreme in the opposite direction -- that our technology gets to the point where everything is automated and no one needs to do any kind of work -- suggests that we should be moving toward some form of universal basic income that provides for everyone's survival needs. People who want more than that can become skilled enough to do worthwhile jobs that provide meaningful income. Obviously this won't be a panacea, and human nature will cause some people to be exploited while others are enriched, but this idea that life's purpose and meaning is just work work work work work is sad and nonsensical.
- dang 7y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22027960 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22027960.
- konschubert 7y agoThe efficiency (output per hours of input) of the economy has stagnated because manual labor has become so cheap that automation isn’t worth it.
- sedachv 7y ago> The low unemployment rate is proof that this techno optimism isn’t true. An observation that was already obvious in the 19th century: "The extraordinary productiveness of modern industry… allows of the unproductive employment of a larger and larger part of the working-class, and the consequent reproduction, on a constantly extending scale, of the ancient domestic slaves under the name of a servant class, including men-servants, women-servants, lackeys, etc. [footnote: Between 1861 and 1870 the number of male servants nearly doubled itself. It increased to 267,671. In the year 1847 there were 2,694 gamekeepers (for the landlords' preserves), in 1869 there were 4,921.]" Chapter 15 of volume 1 of Marx's Capital. Today the servants are delivery people, Uber drivers, personal chefs and assistants, maid services, etc.
- hooande 7y agoYou can't disprove the idea of "make work jobs are not necessary" by citing that a lot of people have jobs