3 ms·
absolutely horrible piece. From invoking stereotypes about basement-dwelling losers and manhood to a completely uncritical view about what constitutes hate and
by Barrin92 7y ago
absolutely horrible piece. From invoking stereotypes about basement-dwelling losers and manhood to a completely uncritical view about what constitutes hate and what doesn't, to the implicit lambda school context around the article, this reads like apologia for the tech CEO polite society who cannot handle criticism from ordinary people. The article even uses the words famous and successful interchangeably, entertaining the idea that fame may be ill-received only in the footnotes.
Also the emphasis on 'neutral opinions' is revealing. The problem when speaking to powerful people is that they're very adept at deflecting 'objective' criticism. It's the sort of discourse they're accustomed to. Hate and anger and even slightly mad and irrational criticism can come from a place of truth. And it can be valuable because in contrast to polite discussion scathing anger is hard to deflect. People in a position of power know how to deflect neutral criticism, they don't know how to deal with loud resentment. For many people, that kind of resentment is the only way to even voice their opinion.
The tone of the article sounds so far removed from reality that the article makes "famous people" sound average, the intelligent upper class like the only one with a license for legitimate criticism, while everyone else is a loser, imlpying that losers do not have valid opinions or that their sentiment can be disregarded because they have not learned how to voice them politely.
I don't know if Paul Graham reads these comments, but if you do you may ponder that it almost sounds like you're categorizing the vast majority of people as losers, and emotional expression as invalid. That's the only tool most people have to make themself heard.
My theory for why so many famous people are sensitive to hate is because hate establishes a lack of respect for authority. It dismantles a lot of pretentiousness around so-called 'critical thinking' in particular in these tech circles. The civility attitude on HN is a good example of this. I don't think it exists to actually think critically, it's just an occupational license to have a quick way to disregard the opinion of people who are perceived to be unsophisticated.
- TheTruth321 7y agoBravo.
- redsymbol 7y agoConsider that the tone of the article, as you're experiencing it, may have more to do with your own attitude and preconceptions, and what meanings you're choosing to read between the lines. Where you wrote: "Entertaining the idea that..." "... is revealing ..." "The tone of the article sounds like..." "It almost sounds like..." These are all places where one could interpret things very differently. I read the whole article also, and drew none of the conclusions you did.
- Nicksil 7y agoI, too, read the article. I felt it apparent, from just about the beginning, to be as-described by Barrin92 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22022013 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22022013
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoFamous people are sensitive to hate because they get a lot more hate than you and I do. People with half of Graham’s notoriety get a constant stream of messages and emails saying they suck, the world’s worse for having them, wishing them various kinds of physical harm. The idea that you should listen to everyone who’s mad at you becomes completely impossible at a relatively low scale of responsibility.
- SamReidHughes 7y agoBasement-dwelling losers and men with a lack of manhood are in fact a real thing. Sorry if that bothers you.
- meowface 7y agoI think you're interpreting a ton of things which aren't remotely present in this essay or implied by it.