8 ms·
So how SHOULD this problem be solved? How should account recovery work?
by cortesoft 7y ago
So how SHOULD this problem be solved? How should account recovery work?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- wyxuan 7y agoApps like Google authenticator, or more conveniently, a Google voice number. The Google voice solution works well since it can't be Sim swapped, and can be accessed via email (admittedly, a potential downside).
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- cortesoft 7y agoHow do you recover your google voice account if you lose that?
- erikig 7y agoAnd down the rabbit hole we go...
- temptemptemp111 7y agoauthy's desktop app
- missingrib 7y agoLong recovery passphrase that you write down and keep in a safe
- cortesoft 7y agoAnd if you lose that?
- justincormack 7y agoGoogle voice is a US only service.
- adrr 7y agoWalk into a store and provide a government ID and the original SIM card. If customer doesn’t have the sim/phone, send a recovery code to the billing address on file in lieu of the SIM card.
- fastball 7y agoPhoto ID seems like enough, no?
- adrr 7y agoProblem with a government photo ID, There's no way to verify its authentic besides a visual inspection. I consider them as secure as SMS 2FA. For $200 and someone could get passable ID with your name on it.
- rahuldottech 7y agoThis is not true everywhere. There are Aadhar cards in India where you can confirm your identity with biometrics at any store using government-provided equipment that many stores have.
- willvarfar 7y agoI’m not in the US, but the only ID card without a chip that I can think of here is a European driving license, which is just a plastic credit-card-sized thing that is often used as informal verification eg to collect a parcel.
- PeterisP 7y agoThat's the key problem that US needs to solve - the businesses don't really have a solid gov't ID system to fall back on. In most of Europe (UK seems to be more like USA as far as I understand) passing on a counterfeit ID to a mobile shop is harder (and more rare) than paying with counterfeit money, the IDs can be checked, employees are required to verify online if that ID has been reported lost or stolen, etc. I mean, in Europe if criminals want to get a bunch of stuff on credit from some place with a disposable identity, they generally recruit poor/homeless people with real IDs, because that is simpler/cheaper/safer than trying to do it with counterfeit IDs. SMS hijacking, just as the core identity theft issue is so much rare elsewhere - it demonstrates that it's a solvable issue if the USA wanted to solve it. (in some sense the discussion on identity theft reminds me of https://www.theonion.com/no-way-to-prevent-this-says-only-nation-where-this-r-1819580358 https://www.theonion.com/no-way-to-prevent-this-says-only-na...) However, the straightforward way to do that would require a proper single centralized (i.e. federal) gov't ID issued to almost all people, which seems to be anathema in USA.
- ak39 7y agoWhat about setting up two mobile phone numbers for recipients of the recovery code: 123 sent to phone #1 and 456 sent to phone #2? (Phone #1 is yours and phone #2 is your elected trusted partner’s) Won’t this work?
- josteink 7y agoWho should single people sign up as #2? Their mom? And what if your SO is currently unavailable? This is a terrible scheme.
- ak39 7y agoDoesn't have to be SO. It can be a trusted friend who knows in advance that you may voice call them in a password recovery scenario (voice calls not via text). Edit: regarding the "lack of availability" at the point of wanting to reset the password: the urgency of resetting passwords should be considered a lesser inconvenience than the risk of having lost control of your account through insecure 2FA. (I am simply supporting my original brain storming thought through ... I am not married to this idea in any way or form. Just a thought.)
- fulafel 7y agoA web of trust style arrangement would be interesting, 2/3 of previously named recovery pals would have to verify you.
- konschubert 7y agoA sim transfer/ account recovery process should come with a transition period of multiple days during which SMSs with warnings are sent to the original sim card. On top of that, one could think of: A passphrase to authenticate a number transfer to another sim. Sending a code through physical mail.
- ahaseeb 7y agoI've implemented something like this at Dontport. There are few work arounds but again security isn't something that's on top of traditional carrier because it's a problem with a small set of people
- konschubert 7y agoNice product! https://dontport.com/ https://dontport.com/ Do you know if something like this exists in europe?
- ahaseeb 7y agoNot yet, but soon we'll launch in Europe too
- imtringued 7y agoWell first of all using a password manager should be the last resort recovery strategy. Unlike device based 2FA a password manager allows you to make an unlimited number of backups. After that 2FA should always be device specific. If you want to do 2FA with your phone then the 2FA challenge should not get sent via an identifier like a phone number that may change owners. Instead you should download a 2FA app that generates a private/public key pair where the public key is linked to your account. That way the only thing you need to do is wipe your phone remotely if it gets lost.