7 ms·
Geez. > "Would you put your family on a Max simulator trained aircraft? I wouldn't," says one employee to another, who responds, "No." > Peter DeFazio, [D-Ore
by thaumasiotes 7y ago
Geez.
> "Would you put your family on a Max simulator trained aircraft? I wouldn't," says one employee to another, who responds, "No."
> Peter DeFazio, [D-Oregon], called newly released documents "incredibly damning"
That's hard to argue with. You'd like to think this kind of thing would... leak. Who said conspiracies involving hundreds of people are impossible?
- wyxuan 7y agoBlow your whistle all you want but until something catastrophic happens, the whistleblowers would turn out the way the whistleblowers for the 737ng airframe cracking came out: fired and then ignored.
- panarky 7y ago"This airplane is designed by clowns who in turn are supervised by monkeys." The monkeys will ruthlessly suppress any evidence that they are monkeys or that they supervise clowns.
- koheripbal 7y agoWhistle-blowing is misunderstood. You can't just start leaking internal documents and making accusations without evidence. ...that will get you fired, and possibly in jail. You need to talk to a lawyer, follow the legal process, and make allegations that you can PROVE. So many whistle-blowers come out with wild stories (often true), but since they bring zero evidence to the table they are ignored. ...and if they have evidence, they just blindly leak it to the press without going through the process, which can endanger people/privacy and destroy IP. Don't get me wrong - whistleblowers are important, but if you really want to make positive change and not just stick it to your employer - do it responsibly.
- Scene_Cast2 7y agoIt feels like the problem is cultural. If the culture doesn't allow enough time for confidence in deliverables, then what proof would you have? Often there are a million items that can go wrong (although all tests pass). So probabilistically something is wrong, but there's no solid item to latch on to.
- seibelj 7y agoHow many people in the government knew about the NSA spying on citizens before Snowden finally spilled the info? That was a massive effort involving many (thousands?) of people. Then when Snowden reveals it, his life is destroyed and he’s forced to live in exile. Sends a very strong warning to any other potential do-gooders considering telling the truth.
- mickael-kerjean 7y agoI'm not sure why this got downvoted, I personally wasn't aware of the conditions on which boeing were making plane before the accidents. My gut feel is nobody did care before something really bad happen and having access to a journalist who is interested enough to make a story ain't simple when you're not in their network. As an example, I did notice a few months ago that twitter did receive identifying information about youporn users (here's a proof: https://archive.kerjean.me/public/2020/twitter.jpg https://archive.kerjean.me/public/2020/twitter.jpg). At that time, I did contact a few journalist from techcrunch, gizmodo and some linux techies but never got any answer and the story never went out
- rsynnott 7y agoEh. In that case, there _had_ been prior leaks, for years; they were just much less complete and taken less seriously. As far as I know, there was never a pre-production leak that Boeing employees thought the MAX was unsafe.
- DanBC 7y agoYes. For example, this report from the EU parliament from 2001: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/sides/getDoc.do?pubRef=-//EP//TEXT+REPORT+A5-2001-0264+0+DOC+XML+V0//EN https://www.europarl.europa.eu/sides/getDoc.do?pubRef=-//EP/... This details a lot of what we knew about ECHELON from the mid 1990s to 2002: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/EPRS/EPRS_STUDY_538877_AffaireEchelon-EN.pdf https://www.europarl.europa.eu/EPRS/EPRS_STUDY_538877_Affair...
- polytely 7y agoWhile true, Snowden position as administrator placed him outside the usual compartmentalization (because he worked on connecting separate parts of the infrastructure)[0], and placed him in a unique position to realize what was happening and to exfiltrate the proof. I suspect most of the other people who knew the whole picture, were a lot higher up the food chain. [0]: see his appearance on the Joe Rogan podcast (it's really long and rambly but there are some fun nuggets in there) Snowdens book might be a better source but I haven't read it yet.
- AmericanChopper 7y agoI feel that particular quote is taken out of context a bit. The line immediately preceding it is: > Another damning exchange calls into question the safety of the 737 Max long before the plane was approved to fly passengers. It’s the quality of the finished product I care about, not the quality of the product at some unspecified point during R&D.
- robbiep 7y agoI don’t see that extra bit of context changing the quote
- AmericanChopper 7y agoVague remarks about the design of the plane being unsound at any point in time prior to it being approved to fly passengers, doesn’t reveal any information at all about the soundness of the design of the plane that was eventually approved to fly passengers.
- netsharc 7y agoYour statements broke my brain... "The plane got approved, it must have been good enough, however grueling it got during the design process". But all evidence shows it wasn't good enough (the design killed some 300 people!), but it got rubber stamp approval.
- AmericanChopper 7y ago> But all evidence shows it wasn't good enough Sure, but without additional context we can’t know what they were talking about, or whether those remarks were relevant to the final product.
- robbiep 7y agoExcept, the quote you’re referring to was dated 2018. The 737 MAX started operations in May 2017. So the comment was after the plane was regularly flying, and people on the inside were STILL joking about its safety. (0) https://www.theguardian.com/business/2020/jan/09/boeing-737-max-internal-messages?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other https://www.theguardian.com/business/2020/jan/09/boeing-737-...
- TrueDuality 7y agoGroup think is a real thing unfortunately...
- kortilla 7y agoTwo things: 1. You would be surprised at how normal talk like that is in huge corporations due to internal politics. People bad-mouth other projects that are getting limelight, taking away resources, etc. A more benign example is how often Google employees rag on the GCP engineers as being inferior, which has more to do with the money flowing into GCP than merit. 2. People are irrational about safety, despite data showing something is ok. There were droves of people that said they would never get on a fly-by-wire plane (Airbus), despite having no evidence to support their fears.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ReptileMan 7y agoIn pilot lingo there are four levels of trust in a pilot (ascending order): 1. I won't fly with you 2. I will fly with you 3. I will fly with you and take my shoes off during take off 4. I will let my family fly with you. This phrase used verbatim means quite a lot.
- fingerlocks 7y agoIf what you’re saying is true, this is a full reversal in the meaning of the leaked conversation. You’re implying the employees not only trust the MAX, their trust is such that they are comfortable kicking back with their shoes off on a flight.
- jpmoral 7y agoHow'd you get there? >"Would you put your family on a Max simulator trained aircraft? I wouldn't," says one employee to another, who responds, "No."
- thaumasiotes 7y agoConceptualize it as a three-point scale of trust: 1: I will fly with you. 2: I will fly with you without even wearing shoes. (Realistically, I can't imagine why shoes would make a difference.) 3: I would let my family fly with you. If you say you wouldn't put your family in a Max, then your trust in the Max is not at level 3. Logically, this is a very weak constraint; it only shows that trust < 3. Maybe trust is 2. That's what fingerlocks is saying. However, vernacular language generally doesn't work that way. A common mode might come from the following train of thought: - I don't trust this plane. - How much do I not trust it? The MAXIMUM LEVEL, LEVEL 3! - "I would not let my family fly on this plane." Here, from a logical perspective, the person has confused "lack of level 3 trust" with "level 3 distrust". This is bad in a math class (the scope of the negation is wrong -- [not [level 3 trust]] vs [level 3 [not trust]]), but routine in ordinary speech.
- awb 7y ago> Who said conspiracies involving hundreds of people are impossible? Companies are pretty opaque by design and I'm sure these people signed NDAs. As long as they believed the company was acting legally (even if not ethically) they might not have felt like they had the legal right to share insider information. Others might have simply felt the company was working on it. And others might not have wanted to damage the company that employs them. The people that knew something wrong was going on and kept passing the buck are certainly at fault though and in retrospect I bet a lot of people wish they said something. It's a tragedy what's happened and unfortunately a bunch of people probably could have saved some lives but didn't.
- toyg 7y ago> And others might not have wanted to damage the company that employs them. Paraphrasing a famous saying, it's hard to make somebody care about something if their livelihood depends on them not caring.
- MisterTea 7y agoIndeed. Another thing consider is if someone blows the whistle it could leave all of their coworkers without jobs. Men and women with families, mortgages, bills and lives. That is a lot of guilt and a very heavy decision to make, especially when there is no consequence in sight. Now that hundreds of people have died as a result that guilt has waned.
- lgeorget 7y agoNot that I want to defend Boeing, but it's easy to play Nostradamus and predict catastrophies to then only dig up the prophecies if they turn up true. The article doesn't say how much the claims were substantiated and backed up by the concerned employees. Looking back, Boeing certainly should have investigated the claims more seriously but just from reading the article I feel we don't have a very clear picture of what happened.
- makomk 7y agoAlso, this prophecy didn't come true. If anything it was completely ass-backwards - it's about the quality of the 737 MAX sim, not the plane itself, and it looks like Boeing's engineers believed internally that Boeing shouldn't have pushed so hard to release it given that existing 737 pilots didn't need simulator training on the MAX and felt safer flying on the MAX with pilots trained on the NG than they did about flying with MAX-simulator trained pilots. You may recall that the general narrative is that the crashes were, in part, the result of Boeing's desire to avoid MAX-specific simulator training.
- acollins1331 7y agoBut that's the whole point. They literally made the MCAS system basically impossible to override just to not have their pilots do training.
- jsight 7y agoThis is what gets overlooked in these stories. Most failures have at least a few of these. But if the same investigation happened with successful aircraft, they'd likely find a lot of the same things. "Employee at X mocks regulator" is not exactly uncommon.
- perl4ever 7y agoWell, perhaps they didn't have enough vehement disagreements.
- tigershark 7y agoHere on hn, on the other hand, there are plenty of people that say that they don’t see any problem in flying on the max once it is again in service. From my point of view I’ll happily let them be the guinea pigs while I’ll avoid at all costs to fly on that death machine.
- beefield 7y agoTo be fair, flying in MAX was/would still be orders of magnitude safer than pretty much any other transportation method outside flying. (No, I don't think I still want to fly that, either)
- vinay427 7y agoSure, though many people aren't deciding between flying a 737 MAX and driving or taking a bus. They're often deciding between flying on a specific flight that uses a 737 MAX and flying at a different time and/or on a different airline that doesn't use a 737 MAX.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoMost people are just choosing the cheapest flight that fits their schedule, which is usually 1.
- tigershark 7y agoFrom my back of the envelope calculations at the time of the second crash they had worse safety than a car. Did you run the actual numbers?
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoI'm confident I'm a safer driver than at least 50% of the people on the roads - if I thought pilots were only as safe as an average driver I'd be worried.
- 7y ago