9 ms·
To Store Renewable Energy, Try Freezing Air
- aurizon 7y agoYou might get away with pissing on Carnot's grave once - but twice - never. By that I mean the energy of compression is lost. A compressor is an analog to an internal combustion engine - in reverse. You put in energy via amotor and compress the air. Unless you can use that heat of compression it is lost. Then you run another analog to an internal combustion engine - in reverse. https://www.google.com/search?ei=jFgWXoCkI474-gTJspPoDQ&q=energy+efficiency+of+an+air+compressor&oq=energy+efficiency+of+an+air+compressor&gs_l=psy-ab.12...4691.7128..9727...0.2..0.100.661.5j2......0....1..gws-wiz.......0i71j0i13j0i13i5i30.PGxHy-B_CRo&ved=0ahUKEwiAmpzFh_XmAhUOvJ4KHUnZBN0Q4dUDCAs https://www.google.com/search?ei=jFgWXoCkI474-gTJspPoDQ&q=en... Extract:- • Is compressed air free? No, compressed air is not free. Although "it's only air," compressed air is actually very expensive because only 10 to 20 percent of the electric energy input reaches the point of end-use. The remaining input energy converts to wasted heat or is lost through leakage. For example, to generate 5 CFM it takes 1 HP. So 10-20% for the compressor. Then the expansion:- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pneumatic_motor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pneumatic_motor sir motors are in the 60-65% efficiency range. Then the electric motor to drive the generator is about 93% efficient (some as high as 95%) This string of 10-20% plus 60-65% plus 93.95% Gives a net range of 5.58% efficient all at low end of range to about 12.35% at the high end. At best you lose 87% and at worst you lose 94.5% But this is wasted energy anyway, but it has to pay for manitanance and staff etc, so in the worst case it is terrible and the best case is sub-marinal. Looks like a free energy racket to me?
- p1necone 7y agoAre there many downsides to just lifting weights/pumping water up hills? What if you connected a lot of very large weights and electric motors to the grid and intelligently wound them up/let them down based on demand? Maybe a two tiered approach combined with capacitors for fine tuning?
- petschge 7y agoThe main downside is that you need a place to store the water at the top. Favorable geography is most likely already in use. And building new lakes on hill tops alters the ecosystem quite a bit.
- pfdietz 7y ago> Favorable geography is most likely already in use. Favorable geography ON RIVERS is limited. Off rivers, the possibilities are enormous and largely unexploited.
- PeterisP 7y agoOff rivers it's hard to get a sustainable supply of the huge amounts of water required to make a reasonably large operation to work.
- pfdietz 7y agoNo, not really. The evaporative losses are significantly less than a water-cooled thermal power plant of similar average capacity, even in desert conditions. And compared to water extraction for irrigation the water needs even to charge the reservoirs would be modest.
- SailingSperm 7y agoThis startup is stacking concrete blocks as a 'battery' https://qz.com/1355672/stacking-concrete-blocks-is-a-surprisingly-efficient-way-to-store-energy/ https://qz.com/1355672/stacking-concrete-blocks-is-a-surpris...
- asymptotically2 7y agoIt's bullshit. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NIhCuzxNvv0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NIhCuzxNvv0
- wahern 7y agoThey're using a different process: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cryogenic_energy_storage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cryogenic_energy_storage Not particularly efficient, but doesn't seem to be as fundamentally broken as compressed air storage.
- robocat 7y agoText from link: "In isolation the process is only 25% efficient, but this is greatly increased (to around 50%) when used with a low-grade cold store, such as a large gravel bed, to capture the cold generated by evaporating the cryogen. The cold is re-used during the next refrigeration cycle.[8] Efficiency is further increased when used in conjunction with a power plant or other source of low-grade heat that would otherwise be lost to the atmosphere. Highview Power claims an AC to AC round-trip efficiency of 70%, by using an otherwise waste heat source at 115 °C."
- wahern 7y agoI was being pessimistic about their claims. Theoretically you could likewise capture the heat from compressed storage, too. Plus, it didn't seem fair in the comparison to compressed storage to include efficiency gains from using residual heat from elsewhere during expansion as technically that heat is input energy.
- aurizon 7y agoThis is suspect. It looks like optimism to me. I agree you can assist it, but with the intrinsic Carnot limitations added, I dount they can beat 25-30%. It still may be economic to save even 20% of energy that would otherwise be wasted,. That added waste at 115C can make the difference
- rklaehn 7y agoThere are lots of ways to get better efficiency for this process. One is to store the heat of compression in a gravel bed for use when evaporating the liquid air again. Another way is to use waste heat from an industrial process to evaporate the liquid air. It is also possible to use the cold to increase the efficiency of a combustion carnot process such as a natural gas turbine.
- kerkeslager 7y agoYou might try reading the article before responding to it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jp57 7y agoIt's not compressing the air, though, it's liquifying it (presumably only the nitrogen), and then using the force of the expanding gas as it boils later to drive a turbine. (I don't know why the author uses the strange phrase "freezing to liquid"). There's not a compressor. Well, there might be one in the refrigerator that "freezes" the air, but the air that is being used for energy storage is not, itself compressed. In any case, as with any other energy storage, I don't think they're claiming it's lossless, but rather that the liquid nitrogen has a much higher energy density than compressed air. It sounds plausible, given that the gaseous to liquid volume ratio for nitrogen is something like 600:1, but I don't actually know. Might still have very high losses, I guess.
- hinkley 7y agoI was under the impression that liquid nitrogen was typically created using a compressor. Is it more efficient to produce it cryogenically?
- pfdietz 7y agoThe cycles for air liquefaction and separation are highly optimized, but the basic idea is to compress air, cool the compressed air back toward room temperature, then send it through an expander (a turbine, say), converting much of its remaining thermal energy to work. This leaves the expanded gas colder than when you started.
- ramses0 7y agoHow would you power a weed-whacker via non-traditional methods? AFAIK there are three main technologies in use today: gas, battery, and plug-in electric. Assuming that gas is on the way out, chemical batteries have contamination/recycling issues, and plug-in electric isn't appropriate for all use cases (definitely less convenient). I can't think of anything other than those technologies which comes remotely close to power a small engine for ~30 minutes at a time, once a week. Will we ever get to "nuclear-powered" weed-whackers? Wouldn't it be Great(tm) if there were the equivalent of AA/AAA rechargeable batteries but for larger devices? Maybe the 6-cell laptop format is the winner (but look at the variation in that use-case)...
- kortex 7y agoI have an electric weed wacker, and for my purposes it works great. But even for more industrious weed wacking demands, I don't think small gasoline engines are contributing that much to global carbon. Pollution and smog, otoh, two strokes are notorious for polluting.
- Mirioron 7y ago>Will we ever get to "nuclear-powered" weed-whackers? I wanted to say "probably not", but I looked some stuff up and now I'm unsure. Essentially all small scale "nuclear power" uses a Radioisotope Thermal Generator. You essentially have a radioactive rock that generates heat and the heat difference is used to generate electricity through the Seebeck effect. The fuel that's typically used for this is Plutonium-238, because it almost exclusively decays as alpha particles (helium-4 nuclei), it has a half life of 87 years while being the most (of the long half life ones) energy dense at around 0.57 W/g. This is what's used in space flight missions and has actually been used to power pacemakers in the past with essentially no ill effect on the patient. Pu-238 is still too heavy for the amount of power it generates for a weed-whacker. What changed my mind though is that apparently Polonium-210 also almost exclusively decays as alpha particles, but it has an incredible 140 W/g power density. The problem is that it has a half life that's only about a third of the year. It still could technically be used for a weed whacker though. From a practical standpoint though, small scale "nuclear power", through RTGs, is way too inefficient for it to be used by regular people. Even if you eliminated all the risk of contamination, it would still only make sense for things that need to be running 24/7 that you couldn't swap out the battery on. Fission and fusion, so far, require a far larger plant to generate power.
- kragen 7y agoAs I understand it, they're refrigerating air, not compressing it. If so, your calculations are entirely inapplicable. Carnot efficiency approaches 100% as your cold reservoir approaches 0 K, so it's plausible for such a cryogenic system to get very high efficiencies from an air motor, much higher than normal.
- oh-4-fucks-sake 7y agoSeems like you're pretty knowledgeable on the topic! I'd be super interested to see an efficiency comparison between the frozen air approach and the "concrete (or any other cheap, heavy thing) battery approach" For the uninitiated: the process of using excess energy to drive motors to lift/stack heavy objects tethered to a pulley. Consuming that energy is by slowly lowering them down as they drive an engine/turbine. As a rider, I'd be equally interested in the realistic energy density between the two methods: how many MWH can you store per acre. Thirdly, I would guess the concrete battery would require less maintenance--but I'd love to see a comparison of that too. Thank you for your comment and getting me thinking about this.
- nine_k 7y agoMotors efficiency, an generators efficiency, can easily be 0.95, and even 0.98. So overall the lift approach must be pretty efficient, even when we subtract losses for friction in the rope and of the air. The energy density isn't great, though, you need really much mass, and large elevations, to store anything interesting. Pumping large amounts of water uphill is more feasible, even if less efficient, and is actually done.
- aurizon 7y agoYes, pump motors and generators. so 96% motor and 96% pump up = are in the 95-7% efficiency, pumps about the same up or down. So .96 x .96(up) and .96 x .96 (down) = 84.9% and friction drops that a little. It is quite good if you hacve a handy high dam pond to use as many places do. To build a high dsm pong may not be economic unless you have a topographic valley you can dam and fill (and murder all the locals and flying snapping turtles) Dams have many objectors, so new ones are hard to build, except for China.
- natmaka 7y agoThe 'concrete'-based approach (gravity storage) is pursued, for example by a firm named Heindl Energy https://heindl-energy.com/ https://heindl-energy.com/ There are offerings and deployed energy-storage systems based upon flywheels https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flywheel_energy_storage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flywheel_energy_storage
- Taniwha 7y agoRemember that peak power is much more valuable than non-peak power (in some places non-peak renewable power has a negative value) so buying it at a discount, wasting most of it in the process, and selling it at peak time can still be economical.
- Mirioron 7y agoIf the numbers in the parent post are true, then you'd probably still be better off just pumping the water high up with that energy and letting it fall down when the energy is needed. On the other hand nabla9 quoted numbers that look very good.
- Taniwha 7y agoyeah, or the concrete block thing - but water requires valleys you're allowed to flood. BTW one solution is to use existing hydro dams as partners to wind/solar, add extra generation capacity to the dams, share the transmission infrastructure between the wind/solar/hydro and simply let the dams fill when the wind blows/sun shines. That's more efficient than pumped storage
- frandroid 7y agoThe province of Québec stops or reduces the flow of many of its hydroelectric dams at night due to the much market lower prices spot prices for electricity, especially since nuke plants flood the markets with unused capacity.
- Taniwha 7y agoThat's great - but really the dams need to be able to help handle peak grid capacity, and to do that they need to be able to generate more than they were originally designed for so that they can trade off against those other sources that weren't around when the dams were built
- 7y ago
- Bendingo 7y ago> A compressor is an analog to an internal combustion engine - in reverse A compressor is not the reverse of a IC engine. IC engine is a heat engine, and the reverse of that is a heat pump (not a compressor). Furthermore, Carnot efficiency refers to heat engine efficiency.
- extrapickles 7y agoThey are referring to an internal combustion engine as a device that coverts heat/expanding gas->work, where the reverse is work->heat/compressed air.
- aurizon 7y agoI beg your pardon. A Carnot engine is indeed a heat engine. The heat of combustion creates hot compressed gas - on which it runs by expanding that gas. A compressor is also a Carnot engine, you compress the gas and you must extract the heat from the hot gas or your air tank will fill with hot gas. As this cools, unless you can use that heat for other tasks, it is wasted. A carnot engine is not reversible. If you run it backwards you must submit to the equation and take your losses. They have been hard at work for almost 200 years trying to beat Carnot - he won them all, no survivors, but he gained immortality... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carnot_cycle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carnot_cycle The Carnot cycle is a theoretical ideal thermodynamic cycle proposed by French physicist Sadi Carnot in 1824 and expanded upon by others in the 1830s and 1840s. read the wiki for more
- lutorm 7y agoAn internal combustion engine runs on an Otto (or maybe Atkinson) cycle, though, not a Carnot cycle. All thermodynamic cycles are heat engines, but their efficiencies aren't the same. How do you mean a Carnot cycle isn't reversible? You can run the cycle in either direction. That's not the same as saying is has 100% efficiency.
- aurizon 7y agoThe Otto cycle means the Otto mechanical sequence. Reversible means run it backwards and it returns the burned gasses etc to fresh fuel, heat etc. etc with 100% recovery
- nabla9 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cryogenic_energy_storage#Efficiency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cryogenic_energy_storage#Effic... >In isolation the process is only 25% efficient, but this is greatly increased (to around 50%) when used with a low-grade cold store, such as a large gravel bed, to capture the cold generated by evaporating the cryogen. The cold is re-used during the next refrigeration cycle.[8] >Efficiency is further increased when used in conjunction with a power plant or other source of low-grade heat that would otherwise be lost to the atmosphere. Highview Power claims an AC to AC round-trip efficiency of 70%, by using an otherwise waste heat source at 115 °C.
- aaron695 7y ago> Such energy storage technology could help relieve congested transmission lines in places like Vermont Normal garbage form Scientific American. It's either a good battery or it isn't. What does Vermont have to do with it? If anything it's an awful test, they obviously will have to update the congested transmission lines, then you have a expensive plant that's useless, if the congested transmission lines don't factor in then why are we talking about them? CRYOBattery is being sold as a long term payoff battery that has a small footprint. Land is cheap around power stations, creating a dam and turbine is simple tech that works, I can't see why this is better and SA is not helping.
- gwbas1c 7y agoNo mention of efficiency... Anyone know the efficiency? Batteries are in the high 90s, but are so expensive that they don't make sense for stockpiling. (Charge in the summer when days are long, discharge in the winter when everyone needs to turn on the heat.)
- philipkglass 7y agoThey claim 60% in the basic configuration, or 70% if coupled with a low grade heat source: https://www.highviewpower.com/benefits/ https://www.highviewpower.com/benefits/ When I searched Google Scholar, I found this 2016 report from their first 350 kilowatt pilot plant at the University of Birmingham: https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Adriano_Sciacovelli/publication/303814262_Liquid_air_energy_storage_-_Operation_and_performance_of_the_first_pilot_plant_in_the_world/links/5757c6aa08aef6cbe35f5ad9.pdf https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Adriano_Sciacovelli/pub... That pilot project claimed less than 25% efficiency, but the authors seemed confident efficiency could be raised. A 5 megawatt demonstration plant has been running in the UK since 2018: https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/highview-power-completes-uk-liquid-air-storage-plant https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/highview-power-... I presume that the 0.35 MW and 5 MW projects worked reasonably well if they are now trying to develop a 50 MW project.
- oever 7y agoThere's some recent videos about the Highview system. Animation https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nu9zLOBi0-E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nu9zLOBi0-E Interview https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4hbyzuES5J0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4hbyzuES5J0 Recent article https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/oct/21/uk-firm-highview-power-announces-plans-for-first-liquid-to-gas-cryogenic-battery https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/oct/21/uk-firm-...
- timoth3y 7y agoEfficiency needs to be viewed with target storage times in mind. For example, the reason batteries are not used for seasonal storage is not just because of their cost, but the fact that they lose their charge pretty quickly. They are 90%+ efficient in the short term, but that drops pretty quickly. On the other hand, something like pumped hydro is less efficient and takes longer to bring online, but can store the energy for months or even years.
- meatmanek 7y agoThis Low-Tech Magazine article[1] does a much better job of explaining the complexities of compressed-air energy storage, including different ways to minimize or harness adiabatic heating, though with a focus on home-scale installations rather than grid-scale. 1. https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2018/05/ditch-the-batteries-off-grid-compressed-air-energy-storage.html https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2018/05/ditch-the-batterie...
- 8bitsrule 7y agoFrom what I've read, winter heating consumes 40% of American households' energy budget. (A seldom-mentioned part of the big picture.) The heat extracted from liquifying air might be used for home-heating in a place like Vermont. I recall walking by a city telecom building getting rid of excess heat, in the winter, by opening big vents in the wall. Meanwhile, apartment buildings around it were burning fuel to keep warm. There are many ways we can do this stuff better.
- gwbas1c 7y agoI always wondered if mining crypto currency would be profitable enough to reduce my heating costs!
- nkrisc 7y agoMaybe! Just running my computer to game on raises the temperature in my office by about 3°F. My hunch is that a significant portion of that is from my monitor, as well.
- dredmorbius 7y agoDistrict heating and cooling, and seasonal energy storage, are both approaches to an integrated energy system which distributes needs over space (district) and/or time (seasonal). District heating distributes heating (or cooling) from sites with an excess to sites with a need. Industrial processes are frequently utilised, though in sufficiently dense construction, office cooling can be a source of heating elsewhere. Many office towers have a net cooling load at all times of year, even under cold ambient conditions. Seasonal energy storage banks heat from warm periods of year for use in cold periods. This may be completely adequate for general space heat, and sufficient for a large portion of higher-intensity heating (e.g., water). Storage may be in geological structures, if those are sufficiently stable (ground-water migration will also migrate out your stored heat), or constructed energy storage facilities, often little more than well-insulated water tanks with vertical thermal stratification. Thorstein Chlupp of Rienna LLC designs zero-net-energy homes in Fairbanks, AK, utilising seasonal thermal energy storage. His videos run long, but are exceedingly comprehensive and explain in detail design and construction decisions. Seasonal storage is covered here beginning at about 1h18m, to about 1h30m: https://invidio.us/watch?v=AtHkvpRI6fc https://invidio.us/watch?v=AtHkvpRI6fc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seasonal_thermal_energy_storage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seasonal_thermal_energy_storag...
- im3w1l 7y agoMaybe in the future we could use desalination/resalination for power storage. There is a lot of sea out there.
- peteretep 7y agoHow would that work? Is resalination exothermic?
- caf 7y agoTo the contrary, dissolving sodium chloride in water is slightly endothermic.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoIn desalination, you're taking a substance that is literally worthless and turning it into something valuable (though cheap). It seems unlikely that once you've got the water, the best available use for it would be dumping it back into the sea. (Which would be the easiest way to resalinate it -- since you're already desalinating, we can safely assume you're next to the sea.)
- adrianN 7y agoPerhaps they want to use https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21721049 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21721049
- ChuckMcM 7y agoIt is a fun idea, I tried to convince a large internet company to do something similar outside their data centers at one time, they chose not to bite. A much better solution is this one: https://www.heindl-energy.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Brochure_Gravity_Storage_2017.pdf https://www.heindl-energy.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Bro... it stores energy by pumping water into a tank to lift up a giant concrete piston. When you want the energy back you just let it down by running the turbo pumps. The nice thing about gravity storage like this are that it doesn't need anything but a hole in the ground and existing hydroelectric technology. The down side is that it can freeze at low temperatures, you get some back because at the depth these cylinders would be dug there is significant below ground heating but there would be days when it would be too cold to run these things without warming them (and thus impacting your efficiency)
- ul5255 7y agoIt's a nice idea but are there implemenatations yet except prototypes? I'm only aware of activities in Weilheim/Bavaria in Germany: https://www.haustec.de/energie/wie-pumpspeicherkraftwerke-im-flachland-ueberschuessige-energie-speichern https://www.haustec.de/energie/wie-pumpspeicherkraftwerke-im... and http://gravityenergyag.com/demoanlage-weilheim/ http://gravityenergyag.com/demoanlage-weilheim/ but this still looks like it will take a while to complete
- gorgoiler 7y agoDinorwig in (under!) Snowdonia is another implementation of the idea, at a large scale: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dinorwig_Power_Station https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dinorwig_Power_Station
- Intermernet 7y agoThat's impressive. The scheme opened in 1984, payed for itself in 2 years, can supply 1.7MW, and stores 9.1GWh. Why is this not being done more?
- rob74 7y ago
- hedora 7y agoThey should be able to pull liquid CO2 or dry ice out at some point during the cooling process. That could be fed into a carbon recapture system. I wonder if using this system for both carbon capture and energy storage is more efficient than using wind or solar to power carbon capture and charge batteries directly. The energy to crack the CO2 into carbon and oxygen is probably the same either way, but concentrating atmospheric CO2 is energy intensive, and direct carbon capture would have to do that anyway — probably by cooling down a bunch of air, then releasing it. Perhaps another way to think about it is that carbon capture will create a large “waste” stream of cooled CO2-free air; perhaps converting that air to liquid is better than wasting the energy it took to cool it in the first place. Either way, as the price of renewables drops, the problem of stranded/excess capacity will only grow. The atmosphere is way past the point where we need to use that capacity to pull CO2 out of the air.
- syllable_studio 7y agoThis is a smart solution - it's great that stories like this are getting attention. I'd like to share a similar project that I'm working on called Terrament. https://www.terramenthq.com/ https://www.terramenthq.com/ Terrament is building underground pumped hydro energy storage (UPHS). Just like other pumped storage solutions, UPHS is extremely cost competitive (measured by LCOE, levelized cost of energy). It's extremely efficient (80-90% round trip). But unlike most pumped hydro, you can build UPHS anywhere. Just like this liquid air solution, you only need a couple acres of land. Many people assume this would use lots of water, but it doesn't because it's a closed-loop system. I see that Heindl energy's solution was also mentioned above -- I love that design. Though, our analysis suggests that our design will give us better capacity. Thanks everyone for your interest in this important field! This is not just a booming business, it's also critical for supporting the sustained growth renewable energy.
- rwmj 7y agoIsn't the classic problem with pumped hydro that you can't really store very much energy unless you have a huge amount of water or a large drop?
- syllable_studio 7y agoYup, though we don't consider it a problem, that's just the simple math. Our solution tunnels down 1 mile deep and excavates an underground reservoir. While this may sound extreme, it's entirely feasible and cost-effective. We can say that with confidence because we're basing our analysis on research from the U.S. Department of energy. We link to that research on our website if you're interested.