5 ms·
Unlike CO2 Methane has a half life of ~7 years in the atmosphere, thus front loading warming before breaking down into CO2 and water. So, in terms of climate
by Retric 7y ago
Unlike CO2 Methane has a half life of ~7 years in the atmosphere, thus front loading warming before breaking down into CO2 and water. So, in terms of climate impact in 2040+, natural gas burned today is significantly better than coal.
- kingkawn 7y agoIf it breaks down into CO2 after the 7 years doesn’t that mean it continues to be a climate changing element?
- Retric 7y agoIt’s a question of scale. Methane is useful fuel, so leaks are an exception rather than the most common result. Spilled gasoline when fueling your car also results in atmospheric CO2, but you produce vastly more CO2 from what ends up in your tank.
- breakyerself 7y agoThere is plenty of evidence that leakyness is a common feature of natural gas infrastructure. The Methane being leaked is 86x more potent than co2 over 20 years and 34x more potent over 100 years. At 1% leakage todays natural gas emissions don't gain a climate advantage over coal until around 2100. At 2% leakage todays natural gas emissions are still significantly worse than coal in 2100. https://www.technologynetworks.com/applied-sciences/news/global-spike-in-atmospheric-methane-linked-to-fracking-322843 https://www.technologynetworks.com/applied-sciences/news/glo... http://theconversation.com/the-us-natural-gas-industry-is-leaking-way-more-methane-than-previously-thought-heres-why-that-matters-98918 http://theconversation.com/the-us-natural-gas-industry-is-le... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_warming_potential https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_warming_potential
- frank2 7y agoInteresting. Oil companies frack to get petroleum, and are OK with burning the natural gas at the well head. I get the impression that a big reason they choose to capture the natural gas instead is criticism of just burning it by environmentalists, but maybe it is more environmentally friendly to just burn it in the absence of the political will to ban fracking. (I am assuming that burning at the well head is an effective way to reduce the amount of unburnt gas released.)
- breakyerself 7y agoApparently I misunderstood how it works. Averaged over 100 years its 34x more potent, but the vast majority of the impact is early on.
- throwaway100773 7y agoThey flare it where there is no infrastructure or insufficient infrastructure to get the gas to market. There are limits on what can be flared and this is what drives some of the decision making. However, if sufficient infrastructure exists they are literally burning money by flaring the gas or just letting it evaporate into the atmosphere.
- breakyerself 7y agoIt breaks down by half over 7 years. 7 years is the half life not the lifespan. Also yes it continues being a greenhouse gas even after it breaks down. So the "Global warming potential" of a ton of methane leaked to atmosphere starts out extremely high. (Edit: I misunderstood this next part. It's potencies here are averaged over that period of time. Most of the impact comes at the begining.) After 20 years it is 86x more potent than co2 and after 100 years it is 34x more potent. It never becomes less potent than co2 because it eventually becomes co2.
- kingkawn 7y agoYes, I understand half-lives. my point was that even after breaking down it continues to contribute to the changing of the climate.
- acidburnNSA 7y agoIf you have a bunch of gas infrastructure leaking constantly, the powerful methane is actually far worse for climate, molecule for molecule, because the methane level will equilibriate high and cause constant high warming as long as the infrastructure is operating and leaking.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- breakyerself 7y agoIn 2040 methane emitted today will still be 86x more potent than co2. Co2 emissions from natural gas are 50% that of coal. So todays natural gas with a 1% leakage rate will still have 135% of the warming impact of coal in 2040. By 2120 the methane emitted today will be 34x as potent as co2. So todays natural gas with a 1% leak rate will have 84% of the impact on warming that you would get from coal. So if you can keep leakage to 1% (it hasn't been that low and efforts to regulate it to those levels have been attacked by republicans.) Then by sometime around 2100 it should be coming down to the same impact as coal. This bridge fuel/front loading of the warming strategy would have been great in 1970 and 1980. Today it really doesn't make any sense.
- ralfd 7y agoBut this potency will be in the past, as all the methane broke down in 2100. The effect of a warmer day now will surely be negligible a 100 years in a future and climate instead find a new equilibrium?
- Retric 7y agoYou’re vastly off. Averaged over 20 years methane is (GWP) 104x as potent as CO2, averaged over 100 years it’s (GWP) 28x. But, to get that average you can calculate ((28 * 100) - (104 * 20)) / 80 = 9. So, from year 20 to year 100 it’s 9x as potent on average. You get this because 1 - (1/(2^(20/7)) = 86% of methane released today has broken down in 20 years. Further, methane goes from CH4 atomic weight 18 to CO2 atomic weight 44. Thus, after breakdown you get (44/18) = 2.75x as much CO2 by weight. So, in 2120 methane produced today will be 99.995% CO2 and provide ~2.75x as much warming vs CO2 emitted today. Edit: Updated with numbers from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmospheric_methane https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmospheric_methane
- breakyerself 7y agoThat makes sense. Do you know if there is a graph that illustrates this so it cements in my mind better? I wonder how much feedbacks are considered with this. The early pulse of warming can cause changes to alebedo, co2 and methane emissions from melting permafrost, etc that carry on after the initial methane has broken down.