4 ms·
the scientific community has discussed this for some time. A lot of discussions I see on HN about this start from "let's understand this from de-novo first ord
by dekhn 7y ago
the scientific community has discussed this for some time. A lot of discussions I see on HN about this start from "let's understand this from de-novo first order principles". But to make rapid progress, scientists in these fields use evidence from many different sources rather than first order principles.
One of the interesting things that we've learned over the years, painfully and repeatedly, is that fairly simple encodings of fairly simple data can repeatedly generate extremely complex visible outcomes. A great example of this is patterning in animal fur- there isn't a section that encodes a pixel map of the resulting spots or their X/Y locations. INstead a collection of genes operate in a feedback loop to generate the patterns. Turing's theory of morphogenesis has turned out to be highly prescient application of very simply theories that does a good job of explaining observed patterning.
What I've seen repeatedly over the years is that the proteins themselves aren't that interesting- all the interesting complex repeatable phenotypes come from careful regulation of the expression of proteins with feedback loops and spatial gradients. The best work on this has been done in evo-devo field on model organisms (not humans). C Elegans was an exceptionally good choice for a model organism for many reasons, not the least of which is that every instead of the organism has exactly the same cells in exactly the same location, and that appears to be completely genetically encoded (again, not like a pixel map, but as generative rules).