5 ms·
I've seen my dad cry once, and it involved the death of my mom. From his lack of crying I learned an important lesson that I've been sharing with my kids (1 and
by Waterluvian 7y ago
I've seen my dad cry once, and it involved the death of my mom. From his lack of crying I learned an important lesson that I've been sharing with my kids (1 and 2): it's okay to cry.
I cry in front of them when I'm sad. And then I talk about why I feel the way I do, and that it will be okay. My oldest is developing wonderful empathy. "Why are you sad, daddy?" And then we talk about it. He probably doesn't understand it a lot, but I know he's learning that it's okay to feel these feelings.
Sadness is not a nice feeling, but it's a valid feeling. I think too often people see sadness as a bug that needs fixing. It's okay to be sad, and then you eventually stop being sad.
Closely related to this is another lesson I learned from my dad on not what to do. He's Willy Loman levels of optimistic. Thousands of times I've heard him go on and on about how great the day was, how much progress is happening at work, how the next big breakthrough is over the next hill. But as his child growing up, I badly needed him to occasionally say, "today didn't go well. X rejected our offer and Y isn't working so we have to start over on that one. But it's okay because these days happen and tomorrow might be better." To this date I'm still struggling with the reality that life, by design, has bad days, and that's fine.
- zrail 7y ago> He probably doesn't understand it a lot, but I know he's learning that it's okay to feel these feelings. You're a good dad. I've been trying to do this with my kids too (both girls). Teaching them that feelings are real, and valid, and trying to teach them ways to productively handle them.
- signalremotefac 7y agoAre you being good to them? Are you doing it for them? The person you are replying to seems to be crying AT his children. "watch me cry!" "see how I feel!" "look wife, I'm a good man now!". To me, this seems to be self-indulgence. For example he is boasting "My oldest is developing wonderful empathy." Read: I am imposing the whims of a group I see myself as been good for associating with onto my child. This is not what a father is for. I've seen my father cry a few times. The most recent was when my cousin commited suicide. He meant it. It was not an exhibtion of his goodness, but the acknowledgment of her goodness.
- zrail 7y agoWhat would you say a parent's job is?
- signalremotefac 7y agoWait...I should be mindful that I come from an unconventional background and...I am also English. Those people known for a lack of emotion. Maybe I am not the best person to answer this question.
- Waterluvian 7y agoYou couldn't have understood or interpreted what I was saying more wrongly. To keep it simple: 1. for example, it was Christmas. I usually have a cry at some point when I think about the amazing Christmases my mother put on. Kids are in the room and I don't try to hide it. The oldest takes notice, worries about me. I engage him rather than trying to hide it. 2. I'm proud of my kids. If you've got kids you'll understand it takes effort _not_ to brag about their accomplishments all the time. 3. While not my intent, there's nothing wrong with boasting, and a bit of self-indulgence. Though I certainly didn't feel any. 4. What I want, above all else, is to share with other parents the lessons I'm discovering to be important. I cherish when parents share theirs with me. Parenting is fucking difficult.
- signalremotefac 7y agoI suppose this is a small example of a larger problem. We are communicating through mediums with limited context, constricted conversations. Compelled to keep it simple, when what we are diccusing is anything but, simple. I mean, I can't even see your face. Crying or otherwise.
- remote_phone 7y agoMy son is a crybaby. I get that emotions are valid, etc, but he cries when he loses at video games, when he gets an answer wrong, when he doesn’t get picked to answer a question at school, when someone gets the book he wanted before he does. We have tried everything and he’s old enough but won’t stop crying. I’m ready to just start spanking him every time he cries and to tell him that it’s not okay to just cry whenever he doesn’t get his way. It’s getting to the point where he is far too old to be acting this way and I’m at my wits end.
- tartoran 7y agoLet your son cry, he will grow out of it by himself. My wife is a strong woman and she's telling me that she cried a lot when she was a kid. My nephew cried a lot when he grew up. Now he seems emotionally stronger than his peers. I cried some when I was growing up and still do occasionally when I can but mostly ran out of tears. Please do let your child cry and manifest his emotions, your trying to help might scar him.
- zrail 7y agoHow old is he?
- Waterluvian 7y agoSome people are wired to cry when emotions of any sort are overwhelming. I was like this as a kid. I'd cry when my brothers and dad lost their shit at a Leafs goal. It's possible you're misunderstanding why they cry. Particularly as you say they're too old for it. Striking them to stop is a great way to really fuck them up. If you're feeling stuck and not sure how to proceed this is absolutely an appropriate thing to talk with their physician about.
- klyrs 7y ago> I’m ready to just start spanking him every time he cries and to tell him that it’s not okay to just cry whenever he doesn’t get his way. This is extremely counterproductive, and this punitive attitude might be why he has so much difficulty handling his emotions. Spanking the tears out is a great way to raise a volatile misanthrope who drinks his pain away and beats his wife and kids (my dad). It sounds like what he needs is a bit of talk therapy. Ask him why he's crying. Dig deeper. Ask him why losing at a video game illicits such a strong emotional response. Ask him why he continues to play, even if he knows that there's a risk of failure. Help him reason through this stuff, and it'll start to click after a while. He'll enjoy this even less than spanking (which, fyi, can and does turn into a fetish for folks; yes, even straight boys can have "daddy issues"), but more importantly, you'll be equipping him with the tools he needs to process complex emotions. This isn't meant as an insult; but you might consider therapy yourself. We all need it, even if we think our life was idyllic or that a hard life made us too tough to need the help.
- jrumbut 7y agoThis is a challenge for me because I also felt the need to do the Willy Loman thing for a while but then realized that other people needed me to be more open about negative emotions or pessimism. But I feel I've gone too far in the other direction now, that if you go through a difficult stretch you can't let yourself be a dark cloud. It doesn't help anything, people want progress, joy, hope, etc. It's a tricky balance to find, especially since my actual internal experience seems to vary more by week or month than by day.
- Waterluvian 7y agoI think optimism and humour can play a large role in bringing light to a dark time in life. You can be true to yourself and others without being a constant dark cloud. Comedy is, if nothing else, the purest form of honesty.
- tartoran 7y agoI agree, optimism and humor do help a lot. But sometimes a dose of reality, thinking that we all die, that all is temporary, think of all the humanity that was born and died and the cycle will naturally continue makes whatever issue is bothering me less grim.
- Waterluvian 7y agoI think Rick and Morty is so compelling to me for this exact concoction of comedy plus cold hard truth. Life is fleeting, I'm about 1/3 of the way done, am I really that upset about X?