3 ms·
One person's "worsening their condition" is another person's self-medication. Sure, you can ask them what they need, but the nice thing about cash if they can
by jrochkind1 7y ago
One person's "worsening their condition" is another person's self-medication.
Sure, you can ask them what they need, but the nice thing about cash if they can use it to buy whatever they need, that's what cash is for. And have the dignity to decide for themselves what it is, not have to tell you and get it approved like you're their teacher or boss.
I mean, are you spending some of YOUR money on alcohol, drugs, and cigarettes? Then you can afford to give someone cash without needing to worry about whether they might do the same, and whether that's good for them or not.
- fastball 7y agoWhat is the point of giving someone money so that they can die of an overdose using the drugs you helped them buy?
- jlokier 7y agoThe OP explained: It gives them dignity and perhaps self-determination. Both of those things have value. A person can still die from self-determination of course, so it comes down to a decision about what you think matters the most.
- fastball 7y agoThey already have self-determination without you giving them money to buy drugs. And dying of an overdose doesn't give you any dignity.
- jrochkind1 7y agoYou are not able to predict who is going to die of an overdose -- let alone because of your gift (ie suggeseting they wouldn't have otherwise, it is your gift that led to that). So you can decide to treat everyone with dignity as an adult, or nobody with dignity as an adult. You are advocating for nobody (or at least nobody who is on the streets), out of an abundance of 'caution'. You are mistaken if you think you are helping people by being an asshole to them. But it is certainly your right to do so.
- fastball 7y agoNot giving people money doesn't make you an asshole.
- jrochkind1 7y agoMaybe, maybe not, but claiming the reason you don't give people money is "What is the point of giving someone money so that they can die of an overdose using the drugs you helped them buy?" -- definitely does. You can treat someone respectfully while giving them money, or while not giving them money; and you can be an asshole either way too.
- fastball 7y ago"This money could help this person, but it's also quite risky, given that the majority of chronically homeless people (most people panhandling) have drug addictions or other mental health issues or both. My money would be better spent on services that can help address these issues over the long term." I think we disagree on what constitutes an asshole. Being aware of the statistical realities of a situation and operating on them is not being an asshole. If you were to say "of course I'm not giving you money, you're probably addicted to heroin" to someone's face after they ask you for change, that would make you an asshole. But that's not what I'm advocating.
- filoleg 7y agoIf you are in position where you can take care of yourself, as well as others, then it doesn’t seem like spending money on those vices yourself is what’s ruining your life that much and keeping you down. To truly help the person struggling to crawl out of that hole, you shouldn’t be enabling the behaviors that keep them there and (possibly) have put them there in the first place. Take them out for lunch, buy them some food, have a conversation, help them figure out the resources available to them, etc. But straight up cash is not something i would be advocating for, unless it goes to a reputable charity/fund/etc (do your research on that one first, because there are quite a few “charities” that spend majority of the funds on administrative expenses and such, with only a small percentage going towards the actual cause) that can allocate that cash in a good way. Ffs, volunteer at a homeless shelter or a food bank.
- imtringued 7y agoYes, drugs are a form of self medication but at the same time being homeless should sting, it shouldn't make you feel like all you need is one more cigarette. The real problem is helping these people find a home and a job but that's a tough nut to crack.