21 ms·
Slack has started disabling unrelated features if you disallow notifications. For instance, you can’t add channels to the “ignore @here” list if notifications
by hedora 7y ago
Slack has started disabling unrelated features if you disallow notifications. For instance, you can’t add channels to the “ignore @here” list if notifications are off. I’m sure this’ll get worse over time.
FF needs a “disable notifications, but lie to the website and say they’re enabled” button.
- Nightshaxx 7y agoI feel like a good extension to make would be a lying extension. Make it able to lie to a site about any API and have set configurations to deal with specific types of behavior.
- timlyo 7y agoMaybe even one that can randomise some settings to throw off fingerprinting.
- daxelrod 7y agoI've seen sites that refuse to show you their content at all until you've enabled notifications. I like this lying idea.
- zamalek 7y agoIt should always lie. Consistently rejecting notifications is yet another bit for fingerprinting a user (not just a device).
- marcosdumay 7y agoI don't understand why browsers would ever not lie about this.
- currysausage 7y agoMaybe because of the privacy implications of web workers keeping connections/checking for new notifications in the background?
- Paul-ish 7y agoIt may require bandwidth and CPU to check for notifications.
- twic 7y agoA non-malicious website could activate some alternative UI for giving you news if you disable notifications.
- rtpg 7y ago"Why are my notifications for Slack not working?"
- OskarS 7y ago"Because you've declined to get notifications for Slack" This does not seem like a reasonable complaint to me.
- ViViDboarder 7y agoBut the application would have no way of knowing that to display this message to the user if the browser lies about it.
- ric2b 7y ago"Check if you have notifications enabled for Slack on your browser's settings"
- radicalriddler 7y agoI feel like if a specific browser, ie. Firefox went down this path, it wouldn't take long until websites stopped supporting that browser. It'd take browser wide action to take on big players such as Slack imo.
- dannyw 7y agoNo, no company is going to choose to see a -5% dip in overall engagement just because they want to fight a web browser.
- IfOnlyYouKnew 7y agoThis is a common error people make. It’s transferring their emotions to inform what some (often companies or countries) should do. In the specific example, it makes no sense for any single website to forgo, say, 5% of revenue to “teach browsers a lesson”, especially since any change would benefit them accrue mostly with their competitors. See also: “Google/FB/... should leave the EU to protest these privacy laws...”
- ric2b 7y agoUnless a huge number of websites cooperate, they will all think it's useless for them individually to "fight the power".